Tonight on Cross-Examination with Dominic Kane
Arrested Twice by the Unit He Is Breaking Up: Why New Yorkers Deserve the Full Safety Case Before Mamdani Disbands the SRG
Crain's found the mayor was taken into custody by the Strategic Response Group at least twice. Before the unit is broken up, the city owes the public answers on safety and on his own record.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Brooklyn, NY 11201
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: Mamdani Just Disbanded the NYPD's Riot and Counterterror Unit. Here's What His Plan Still Doesn't Answer
Key points
- Mayor Mamdani and Commissioner Tisch announced Nov. 16 that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group will be disbanded.
- Crain's New York Business found the mayor was taken into custody by SRG officers at least twice in 2021; City Hall did not respond to Crain's.
- The unit was created in 2015 for both disorder control and counterterrorism, missions paired on purpose.
- The PBA's president warned the plan puts officers and the public at greater risk; a public hearing and published standards should come first.
New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani says breaking up the NYPD's Strategic Response Group keeps a campaign promise and protects the right to protest. This week brought a fact that makes his case harder to take on faith: the mayor himself was taken into custody by that same unit at least twice before he took office. New Yorkers are owed more than a promise kept. They are owed the full safety case.
What the Mayor Did
On Nov. 16, Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced that the Strategic Response Group will be disbanded, CBS New York reported [1]. Under the plan, the unit's counterterrorism and heavy-weapons work moves into the department's Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau, protest response shifts to a civilian unit in the city's Office of Community Safety working with a new NYPD First Amendment Support Team, and the unit's roughly 500 officers are reassigned, according to CBS New York [1]. The New York Post summed it up plainly: the unit is being folded into an existing counterterrorism command and will no longer respond to protests [3].
The mayor's side has an argument, and it should be stated fairly. Civil liberties groups have pressed for years to disband the unit, pointing to its role in policing the 2020 protests, when it faced heavy criticism over its tactics [4]. Commissioner Tisch has said the department's response to large crowds will not change [1].
The History the Mayor Has Not Addressed
Then came the reporting. Crain's New York Business reviewed photos and video and found that Mamdani was taken into custody by SRG officers at least twice, Yahoo News reported in carrying the story [2]. One arrest came at an August 2021 protest over the eviction moratorium in Brooklyn, where he was one of 17 people arrested and later posted video of an SRG officer zip-tying his hands; another came during an October 2021 protest outside City Hall over taxi drivers' medallion debt [2]. City Hall did not respond to Crain's request for comment [2]. The Post reported the same finding [3], and the Washington Examiner's opinion page took up the question under the headline "Mamdani's startling omission" [6].
Being arrested at a protest is not a scandal in itself. Peaceful civil disobedience has a long and honorable place in American history, from lunch counters to pro-life sit-ins. But public life has a simple rule: when an official's decision touches his own past, he discloses it and lets someone independent check the work. A judge steps aside from a case involving his own arrest record. A mayor reorganizing the unit that arrested him should at least tell the public, and show his reasons, before the change takes effect.
What the Unit Was Built to Do
The bigger issue is safety. The Strategic Response Group was created in 2015 under Commissioner Bill Bratton, who said the 350-officer unit would be dedicated to disorder control and counterterrorism [4]. Those two missions were paired on purpose. A huge crowd in Midtown is both a protected exercise of the First Amendment and a tempting target, and the officers trained to keep a march from turning into a riot were the same ones trained to respond if that crowd were attacked.
Splitting those jobs may be workable, but it raises hard questions the city has not answered in public. Who arrives in the first ten minutes when a peaceful march turns violent? How long will it take a counterterrorism team to reach a protest that suddenly needs it? What training will the civilian responders have, and who is accountable when something goes wrong? Those are not partisan questions. They are the questions any parent riding the subway, or any shop owner on a protest route, would ask.
Who Is Pushing Back
The officers who will carry out the plan are among the loudest critics. Fox News reported that police groups condemned the decision, and that Patrick Hendry, president of the Police Benevolent Association, warned the plan would put both officers and the public at greater risk [5].
The answer is not to stop New Yorkers from protesting. It is to protect them while they do, and to protect everyone else at the same time. Before this plan takes full effect, the City Council should hold a public hearing, the department should publish the response-time standards the new teams will meet, and the mayor should explain, in his own words, how his personal history with this unit played no part in its end.
What Comes Next
The overhaul will roll out over the coming months as officers are reassigned and the new teams stand up [1]. That leaves time to get it right. New York's protesters, its police and its millions of ordinary residents all deserve a plan that keeps the peace and keeps the city safe. Openness about the mayor's own record is the place to start.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Yahoo NewsNYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani Was Arrested Multiple Times by the NYPD Unit He Now Plans to DisbandOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]New York PostMayor Mamdani was arrested at least twice by elite NYPD unit he's controversially disbandingOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Washington ExaminerMamdani's startling omissionOpens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.