Tonight on Order in the Court with Harold Whitmore
A Second Judge Halts the Arch: What Brinkema's Ruling Says, Why It Turns on Congress and Where the Appeal Goes Next
Judge Leonie Brinkema joins Judge Tanya Chutkan in freezing the 250-foot Memorial Circle arch. The Justice Department says it will appeal, but a vote in Congress may be the fastest fix.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Richmond, VA 23219
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: A Pause, Not a Verdict: What the Arch Ruling Really Says, and Why the Case for the Gateway at Arlington Is Still Alive
Key points
- Judge Leonie Brinkema of the Eastern District of Virginia said she will issue a preliminary injunction against the 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle.
- Her ruling, in Arlington County's lawsuit, centers on the lack of approval from Congress; she called the planning a 'rushed job.'
- Judge Tanya Chutkan's separate order in Washington holds the project until Dec. 3 or until she rules on a longer block.
- The Justice Department says it will appeal; a clear vote by Congress would answer the central objection.
For the second time in a week, a federal judge has stopped work on President Trump's planned memorial arch at the gateway to Arlington. On Friday, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema of the Eastern District of Virginia, who sits in Alexandria, said she would issue a preliminary injunction against the 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle, going a step beyond the temporary order a judge in Washington issued earlier in the week, NPR reported [2].
The Justice Department says it will appeal right away, MS NOW reported [5]. So this is not the end of the story. It is the start of the next round. Here is what the two rulings say, what they do not say, and where the case goes from here.
What Judge Brinkema Decided
Brinkema ruled from the bench in a lawsuit brought by Arlington County, Virginia, the Washington Examiner reported [3]. According to NPR, she found the challengers are likely to win their case, the key test a court applies before it freezes a government project while a lawsuit plays out [2]. CNN reported that her central objection is that the arch lacks the approval of Congress [1].
She did not mince words about the process. MS NOW reported that the judge called the planning a "rushed job," and that her order keeps the project on hold with no set end date while Arlington's challenge moves forward [5].
It matters what kind of order this is. A preliminary injunction is not a final judgment that the arch can never be built. It is a judge's prediction that the challengers will probably win, paired with a decision to keep the ground untouched until the case is decided. Appeals courts review that kind of order, and they can lift it.
The Washington Case and a 100-Year-Old Law
The Virginia ruling lands on top of a separate fight in Washington. Earlier this week, U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended her temporary block on the arch, keeping construction, excavation, demolition and road closures at Memorial Circle on hold until Dec. 3 or until she rules on a request for a longer injunction, ABC News reported [4].
The legal heart of both cases is the same question: did Congress say yes? The administration points to a century-old approval for a two-column structure near the site, according to ABC News [4]. Chutkan found that the old statute did not authorize an arch of this size, and in her original order she questioned whether a 100-year-old law could contain authority that no earlier administration had ever found, ABC News reported [4]. Brinkema, as CNN reported, reached the same basic conclusion from the Virginia side of the river [1].
The challengers are a varied group. The Washington case began with a lawsuit from a group of Vietnam veterans, ABC News reported [4]. Arlington County brought the Virginia case [3]. And the New York Post reported that nine members of the Kennedy family have separately joined the legal fight, arguing the towering structure would shadow the graves of relatives buried at Arlington National Cemetery [6]. Those are serious, sincere objections from people who love that ground, and they deserve a serious answer rather than a brush-off.
Why This Fight Is About Congress, Not Patriotism
There is nothing unpatriotic about wanting a grand monument to the nation's 250th year. Americans built the Lincoln Memorial, the Memorial Bridge and the Marine Corps War Memorial because great nations honor their story in stone. Those who want the arch are not wrong to want something lasting near the hallowed ground at Arlington.
But conservatives have argued for decades that the Constitution gives Congress real power over federal land and federal money, and that presidents of both parties should not stretch old laws to do new things. Both judges have now framed their rulings in exactly those terms [1][4]. That is a doctrine conservatives defended when it limited the last Democratic administration, and it does not stop being true because the project is one we might like.
The good news is that the fix is not complicated. If the problem is the missing approval of Congress, then Congress can give it. Republicans still hold the House and Senate until January, and a clear vote would answer the central objection in both courtrooms far faster than an appeal.
What Happens Next
Three tracks are now running at once. The Justice Department's appeal of Brinkema's order will go to the federal appeals court that covers Virginia [5]. In Washington, Chutkan's order holds until Dec. 3 unless she rules sooner on the request for a longer block [4]. And the Kennedy family's challenge remains in play [6].
For now, the ground at Memorial Circle stays untouched. The question that will decide the arch's future is the same one the courts keep asking: will Congress say yes?
Sources
Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?
- Yes, for the worst murders
- Only with absolute proof like DNA
- No, life without parole is enough
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.