Tonight on Power Play with Connor Maguire
No Draft, Bigger Pools: Players Turn Down Baseball's International Draft and Counter With Help for Small Markets as a Lockout Nears
Management wanted a 12-round international draft starting in 2027. The union answered with larger signing pools, a boost for small-market clubs and penalties for teams that strike deals with prospects too early.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Washington, DC 20001
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- The players' union rejected MLB's proposal for an international amateur draft, AP reported
- Management's latest offer included $200 million in 2027 signing pools and a 12-round draft
- Players want bigger pools, a small-market boost and the right to exceed pools with a tax
- The union also proposed stripping teams of prospects they reach agreements with before the signing period
Baseball's owners and players found one more thing to disagree about on Friday. The Major League Baseball Players Association turned down management's proposal for an international amateur draft and instead asked for bigger signing bonus pools under the current system and more rewards for small-market teams, The Associated Press reported [1][2].
AP described the exchange as one more sign that the sport is headed toward a lockout next month [1][3]. Some outlets framed it as the union simply ignoring the draft idea in its counteroffer; either way, the players' answer was no [2][5].
What Each Side Put on the Table
Management has pushed for an international draft for more than two decades without success [1]. In June, it proposed one that would begin with 12 rounds in 2027 [1]. Its latest offer included $200 million in signing bonus pools for 2027, roughly what teams spent on international amateurs in 2026, and would allow clubs to keep signing players who were passed over in the draft for up to $10,000 each [2].
The union's response kept today's signing system and tried to change how it works. According to AP, players proposed a $1 million increase to a small-market club's signing pool during one signing period of a five-year agreement, and want teams allowed to spend beyond their pools as long as they pay a tax on the overage [1]. ESPN reported that the union's plan offered an international signing system with no draft at all [4].
Two other pieces stand out. The players proposed that any team reaching an agreement with an international amateur before his signing period would lose the right to sign that player and would forfeit pool space [2]. They also asked for separate bonus pools for eligible players with limited foreign professional experience [2].
Bruce Meyer, the union's interim executive director, said in a statement that players want a system that protects young prospects from exploitation without adding new restrictions such as a draft [2].
The Bigger Fight Behind It
The international draft is a side street next to the main road. Owners are pressing for a salary cap, which players say they will never accept, and that standoff now threatens the 2027 season [1]. Every proposal traded this month, including this one, is being made in the shadow of that larger fight [1][3].
Connor's Take
Strip away the bargaining language and this argument is about teenagers and the families who raise them. Whatever system comes out of these talks will decide how young prospects from overseas are scouted, signed and paid, and whether they and their parents are treated with fairness or treated like inventory.
Both sides claim to be protecting those kids, and both arguments deserve a hearing. Management has spent more than two decades arguing that a draft would bring order to international signing [1]. The union's position, as Meyer put it, is that young prospects can be protected without new restrictions like a draft [2]. My own worry is that a draft would take choice away from a young man and his family before he has thrown a professional pitch.
The most useful idea on the table may be the union's penalty for early agreements [2]. If a team stood to lose both the player and its pool space for cutting a deal before the signing period, that would be a real deterrent, and it would put the burden on the adults in the room, where it belongs. Protecting the young from being used is something Scripture asks of all of us, and it ought to be the test for any deal that comes out of these talks.
What Comes Next
The current labor agreement runs out next month, and AP reported that the sport appears headed for a lockout [1]. The international draft is unlikely to be what breaks or saves these talks. The salary cap fight will decide that [1].
But Friday's exchange shows how far apart the sides remain. For fans already counting the days to spring training, that is not encouraging. For the teenagers waiting to sign, it means another winter of uncertainty about the rules that will shape their futures.
Sources
- [1]NBC SportsPlayers reject MLB's international draft proposal; ask for higher bonus pools, aid to small marketsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]The Washington PostPlayers ignore MLB's international draft proposal; ask for higher bonus pools, aid to small marketsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]The Globe and MailPlayers reject MLB's international draft proposalOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]CTV NewsPlayers ignore MLB's international draft proposal; ask for higher bonus pools, aid to small marketsOpens in a new tab ↗
Should athletes keep politics out of the game?
- Yes, just play
- They can speak off the field
- They have every right to speak out
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.