Markets
Friday, November 20, 2026Updated 4:50 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Pushback

Today on First Principles with Benjamin Stone

Voters Are Not a Rough Draft: Seattle Schools Now Back a Bid to Freeze I-638, but the Supreme Court and the Ballot Say Otherwise

Seattle Public Schools is backing a union-led bid to freeze Initiative 638 before it takes effect Dec. 3. The record, the high court's June ruling and the girls who supported the measure point the other way.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic view of an empty high school gymnasium in the Pacific Northwest at early morning, polished hardwood court with a basketball resting at center court, folded bleachers, tall windows showing evergreen…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Part of our continuing coverage: Seattle School Board Votes to Fight Voters' Protections for Girls' Sports

Key points

  • Seattle Public Schools filed a brief supporting a bid to freeze I-638 but did not join the suit
  • The teachers union, TransFamilies and five families argue privacy and state Equal Rights Amendment claims
  • The U.S. Supreme Court upheld Idaho and West Virginia girls' sports laws on June 30
  • Five high school athletes filed declarations backing I-638; a hearing is set for Dec. 3

Washington voters were asked a plain question this fall: should girls' school sports be reserved for girls? They said yes, approving Initiative 638 [2]. Now, with the measure days from taking effect, the state's largest school district is asking a judge to put it on hold.

Seattle Public Schools filed a brief supporting a preliminary injunction against I-638 the same night a coalition led by the Washington Education Association and the ACLU asked a King County Superior Court judge to block it, KING 5 reported [1]. The district is not a plaintiff, and Superintendent Ben Shuldiner said the filing is not costing the district any money, according to KING 5 [1]. The district argues it cannot faithfully carry out the measure on schedule because of unclear requirements and undefined terms [1]. The Daily Wire reported that Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson has backed the district's push in court [3].

The lawsuit itself was filed Nov. 9 by five families, the advocacy group TransFamilies and the state teachers union, Axios Seattle reported [2]. The plaintiffs argue that the measure's sex-verification requirement intrudes on student privacy and conflicts with Washington's Equal Rights Amendment because it applies only to girls' sports [2]. A judge is scheduled to hear the injunction request on Dec. 3, the same day the measure is set to take effect [1].

Those concerns deserve a fair hearing, and every student involved deserves to be treated with dignity. But the case for freezing a law the voters just passed is weak on the facts, the Constitution and common sense.

The Highest Court Has Already Spoken

On June 30, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Idaho's and West Virginia's laws limiting girls' and women's teams to female athletes, SCOTUSblog reported [5]. The justices ruled unanimously that the laws do not violate federal civil rights law, though they divided over the constitutional question in the West Virginia case [5]. NPR reported that the court reasoned that because Title IX explicitly allows sex-separated athletic teams, states are free to limit those teams by sex [6].

To be precise, the Washington lawsuit rests on the state constitution, not the federal one, so the Supreme Court's ruling does not decide it [2][5]. But it does settle the national question that hung over this debate for years. Separate girls' teams are not a form of discrimination that federal law forbids. They are the reason Title IX exists in the first place [6].

Voters Are Not a Rough Draft

There is something troubling about a school district racing to court to suspend a law before a single game has been played under it. Initiatives are how Washington's citizens make law directly when they believe elected officials will not. A measure that clears the ballot is not a suggestion awaiting the approval of the institutions it was written to correct.

Seattle's concern about unclear terms is not a reason to throw out the law. It is a reason to write clear rules. The district has said its objection is about implementation, not cost, and it chose not to join the lawsuit as a plaintiff [1]. Every other district in the state faces the same questions about how to apply the measure. The answer is to resolve those questions, not to suspend what the voters approved.

Privacy matters, and families who worry about how eligibility will be verified are right to ask hard questions. The answer is careful rules that protect students' dignity, written in the open and applied the same way everywhere, not an open-ended freeze that leaves girls unsure which rules they will be playing under in the middle of a season.

Who Is Pushing Back

The girls themselves are speaking up. Five high school athletes filed declarations in support of I-638, KUOW reported, entering a legal fight that could overturn the measure they backed [4]. Let's Go Washington, the group behind the initiative, accused the ACLU and the teachers union of trying to override the voters, according to KUOW [4].

Their argument is the common-sense one. Fair competition, safe locker rooms and a fair shot at a podium, a roster spot or a scholarship are not small things to a 16-year-old who has trained since grade school. Every parent who has driven a daughter to 6 a.m. practices understands what is at stake.

What Comes Next

The judge will take up the injunction request on Dec. 3 [1]. If the court lets I-638 take effect on schedule, schools will begin applying the new rules this winter [1]. If it does not, the voters' decision will be on hold while the case moves forward, and the families who supported the measure will be left waiting [2].

Either way, the Supreme Court has already confirmed that keeping girls' sports for girls is consistent with federal law [5][6]. Washington's voters reached the same conclusion on their own [2]. Seattle's school leaders should spend their energy helping students and coaches prepare for the rules the people approved, not asking a court to set them aside.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?

  1. Yes
  2. I think so
  3. No
  4. I'm not on social media
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.