Today on Saturday Nation with Wade McAllister
Five Arms, One Trophy: Arch Manning Joins CJ Carr, Gunner Stockton, Devon Dampier and Drew Mestemaker as Golden Arm Finalists
Texas' senior quarterback made the final cut for an award that weighs character and leadership alongside passing numbers, and not every fan is happy about the list.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Stockton, CA 95202
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Arch Manning, CJ Carr, Devon Dampier, Gunner Stockton and Drew Mestemaker are the five Golden Arm Award finalists.
- Manning is Texas' first finalist since 2024, with 2,198 yards and 19 touchdowns so far this season.
- Some fans questioned Manning's place on the list, and Miami supporters pointed to Darian Mensah.
- The winner will be honored at the Golden Arm ceremony in Baltimore on Dec. 9.
The Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award trimmed its field to five on Friday, and Arch Manning made the cut. The Texas quarterback joins Notre Dame's CJ Carr, Utah's Devon Dampier, Georgia's Gunner Stockton and Oklahoma State's Drew Mestemaker as the finalists for one of college football's best-known quarterback honors, the University of Texas announced [1].
Manning becomes Texas' first finalist for the award since 2024, the school said, after he was first named to the award's top 10 earlier this month [1]. The list was cut down from a top 10 that also included Noah Fifita, SMU's Kevin Jennings, Sam Leavitt and USC's Jayden Maiava, according to the award's earlier announcement [2]. The winner will be honored at the annual Golden Arm ceremony in Baltimore on Dec. 9 [2].
More Than a Stat Line
The Golden Arm is not simply a passing-yards contest. The award, named for the Hall of Fame Baltimore Colts quarterback, honors an upperclassman quarterback for his play on the field along with character, leadership, scholastic achievement and community service [2]. That is part of what makes it worth paying attention to. In an age of transfer portals and name, image and likeness deals, an award that asks how a young man carries himself off the field is a welcome reminder of what football at its best is supposed to build.
Manning's numbers this season are solid rather than spectacular. Through the season so far, he has completed 187 of 289 passes, about 64.7 percent, for 2,198 yards and 19 touchdowns, averaging just under 220 yards a game, according to Texas [1].
His defining moment came last Saturday in Baton Rouge. Manning threw three interceptions against LSU, then led a final drive and found Raleek Brown for the winning touchdown in the closing seconds of a 22-21 victory that dealt a heavy blow to the Tigers' playoff hopes, the New York Post reported [5]. Afterward, he said he relished ending somebody else's dream, a line Texas fans will remember for a long time [5].
Not Everyone Agrees
The list has stirred debate. Newsweek reported that Manning's inclusion drew strong reactions from some college football fans [3]. Miami fans have their own complaint: Yahoo Sports raised the question of whether Hurricanes quarterback Darian Mensah was snubbed by the award [4].
Here's my take. The critics have a point about the raw numbers, and nobody in Austin would argue that Manning has had a flawless year. But this award was never meant to be a spreadsheet. A quarterback who throws three interceptions on the road in one of the loudest stadiums in America and still asks for the ball with the game on the line is showing exactly the kind of leadership the Golden Arm says it rewards. That counts for something.
There is also something to be said for how he has handled the noise. Manning arrived in Austin as the most talked-about recruit in the country, carrying one of the most famous last names in the sport, and he waited his turn instead of chasing an easier path somewhere else. He has taken his lumps this fall in public and kept showing up. Patience and perseverance are not stats, but they are exactly the qualities a character award ought to notice.
The other four finalists, from Notre Dame, Utah, Georgia and Oklahoma State, each bring their own case to Baltimore, and any of them would be a worthy winner [1][2].
What Comes Next
Manning's immediate focus is Saturday's final home game in Austin, where he will take part in the Senior Day ceremony even though he has not decided whether to return to Texas next season or enter the 2027 NFL Draft, the New York Post reported [6]. Texas, ranked No. 5 in the College Football Playoff standings, still has work to do to stay in the field [1].
The award will be handed out in Baltimore in less than three weeks [2]. Whoever wins it will join a long line of quarterbacks honored in the name of a man who did things the right way. That is a standard worth chasing, on Saturday and long after the cheering stops.
Sources
- [1]University of Texas AthleticsNo. 8/8/5 Football's Manning named Top 5 finalist for Johnny Unitas Golden Arm AwardOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]New York PostTexas' Arch Manning reveled in ending 'someone else's dream' with stunning comeback over LSUOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Should athletes keep politics out of the game?
- Yes, just play
- They can speak off the field
- They have every right to speak out
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.