Today on Border Watch with Cole Brennan
Texas' Claim to Nine Border Islands Faces New Doubts
Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham staked the claim to give police a foothold against the cartels. Her Democratic successor and Mexico both question it.
Filed November 19, 2026 · 📍 San Antonio, TX 78205
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Texas claimed nine Rio Grande islands, about 66 acres, as state land in October
- Buckingham says state title lets law enforcement patrol cartel routes
- Incoming commissioner Benjamin Flores plans to review the claim
- Mexico says only the boundary commission can decide
Texas' move last month to claim nine small islands in the Rio Grande as state land is facing new doubts from the man who will soon run the office that made it. Benjamin Flores, the Democrat elected Texas land commissioner on Nov. 3, has questioned the claim, said he would respect the process run by the International Boundary and Water Commission and plans to review how the islands were acquired, according to an interview with The Atlantic [1].
Why Texas Made the Claim
The claim came from Republican Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham, whose General Land Office announced in late October that it had identified nine islands, totaling about 66 acres and mostly in the Starr County area, as property of the state [2][3]. Federal border officials had raised questions about 28 islands in the river whose ownership had never been settled, and the office's review concluded that nine of them belong to Texas, News 4 San Antonio reported [3].
Buckingham's reason was security. She has argued that land nobody claims can become a haven for cartel smuggling, and that state ownership lets Texas and federal law enforcement go onto the islands and patrol them [3][4]. Fox News reported that Texas also asked the Trump administration to help secure and defend the islands, which state officials say are used by Mexican cartels [4].
This is not the first time. In 2023 the Land Office declared Fronton Island in Starr County state land and opened it to state police, and the Biden administration answered that the island was federal property [5].
The Pushback
Mexico rejected the new claim within days. Its foreign ministry said the border between the two countries cannot be changed by the decision of a state government and that the boundary commission must decide which side of the line each island sits on [2].
Flores, who will take over the Land Office from Buckingham after winning the post this month, has made clear he sees the question differently than his predecessor [1][6]. His planned review could leave the claim in limbo once he is sworn in [1].
Why It Matters
For the deputies, troopers and Border Patrol agents who work the river, these islands are not a legal abstraction. Brush-covered ground in the middle of the Rio Grande sits right on the routes smugglers use, and a clear right to patrol it can be the difference between stopping a load and watching it disappear [4]. A treaty line still governs the map, and the boundary commission is the proper place to settle each island. But Buckingham's office did what a state should do when Washington and Mexico leave a gap: it documented the title, invited law enforcement in and forced the question onto the table.
If the new commissioner backs away, the burden shifts to the federal government and the boundary commission to make sure no stretch of the river becomes a no man's land for the cartels. Texas families along the border will be watching what happens to those 66 acres [2][3].
Sources
Would you support an immigration deal with the new Democratic Congress?
- Only if the border stays secure and there's no amnesty
- Yes, it's time to fix the system
- No deals at all
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.