Tonight on The Verdict Room with Natalie Sinclair
Full Appeals Court Won't Rehear Rep. McIver's Bid to Toss Charges From the Delaney Hall Clash
Only three of 13 judges on the Third Circuit wanted another look, leaving the New Jersey Democrat to face two of three counts unless the Supreme Court steps in.
Filed November 19, 2026 · 📍 Supreme Court, DC 20543
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- The Third Circuit on Thursday denied Rep. LaMonica McIver's request for rehearing by the full court
- Only three of the 13 participating judges voted to rehear the case
- An August panel ruled 2-1 that the Speech or Debate Clause does not shield her from at least two counts
- McIver can ask the Supreme Court to step in; no trial date has been set
The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Thursday turned down Rep. LaMonica McIver's request to reconsider her bid to throw out the federal charges stemming from a scuffle outside an immigration detention center in Newark, The Hill reported [1].
The New Jersey Democrat had asked for rehearing by the full court or by the original three-judge panel. Rehearing by the full court, known as en banc review, is reserved for questions of exceptional importance or for panel rulings that conflict with the court's own precedent, and it is rarely granted. The court's one-paragraph order denied both, Bloomberg Law reported [2]. Only three of the 13 participating judges voted to grant rehearing by the full court, and Judge Emil Bove III did not take part [2][3].
McIver has pushed to have the case dismissed on several grounds [1]. Thursday's order leaves in place an August ruling that allowed the prosecution to go forward on most of the charges.
How the Case Got Here
The charges grew out of a confrontation in May 2025 outside Delaney Hall, the immigration detention center in Newark, New Jersey Globe reported [5]. Federal prosecutors charged McIver over her conduct during the encounter with officers outside the facility, and she has denied wrongdoing, arguing that she was there to carry out her oversight duties as a member of Congress [5].
Her central legal argument rests on the Speech or Debate Clause, the part of the Constitution that protects members of Congress from being questioned elsewhere for their legislative work. McIver argued that the clause, along with separation-of-powers principles, protects what she did that day [4].
In August, a divided Third Circuit panel disagreed. It ruled 2-1 that the clause does not shield her from prosecution on at least two of the three counts, JURIST reported [4]. The panel's opinion also addressed her claim of vindictive prosecution, finding that a trial court's rejection of that claim could not be appealed before trial [6].
Why the Ruling Matters
The Speech or Debate Clause is an important protection. It keeps the executive branch from harassing lawmakers over their votes, their speeches and their committee work, and conservatives have every reason to want it strong. A future administration of either party could be tempted to go after its critics in Congress.
But the clause has limits, and the courts have now said so repeatedly in this case. A congressional visit to a federal facility is one thing. Physical force against officers doing their jobs, which is what prosecutors allege, is another. The panel majority's view was that the Constitution protects legislative acts, not everything a lawmaker does while on official business [4][6].
That principle protects the men and women who enforce the nation's immigration laws. Officers at a detention facility deserve the same protection under the law whether the person in front of them is a protester or a member of Congress. Equal justice means no one gets a pass because of a title.
It also protects McIver's right to a fair process. She has not been convicted of anything, and she will have every opportunity to make her case to a jury.
What Comes Next
McIver can now ask the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the Speech or Debate question. Reports on Thursday's order said her lawyers have 90 days to file that petition [2][3]. She is expected to be arraigned on the remaining counts in the coming weeks, and no trial date has been set [3].
The case is being watched closely in Washington. With a new Congress arriving in January, the boundary between legitimate oversight and conduct that can be prosecuted will matter for members of both parties who want to inspect federal facilities, including immigration detention centers.
For now, the message from the Third Circuit is clear. The full court saw no reason to revisit the panel's ruling, and the prosecution can move ahead.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Yahoo NewsFull 3rd Circuit rejects McIver's appealOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]New Jersey GlobeMcIver asks appeals court to dismiss federal charges tied to Newark detention center confrontationOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third CircuitUnited States v. McIver, Nos. 25-3573 & 26-1122 (opinion)Opens in a new tab ↗
Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?
- Yes, for the worst murders
- Only with absolute proof like DNA
- No, life without parole is enough
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.