Today on The Verdict Room with Natalie Sinclair
Charlotte Asks a Judge to Toss the Zarutska Family's Lawsuit, Citing Governmental Immunity and a $1 Million Cap
The city says transit policing is a protected government function and that the accused killer alone caused Iryna Zarutska's death. Her family says the light-rail system failed her.
Filed November 18, 2026 · 📍 Charlotte, NC 28202
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Charlotte filed a motion Monday to dismiss the wrongful-death suit over Iryna Zarutska's August 2025 light-rail killing.
- The city cites governmental immunity, the public duty doctrine and a $1 million state liability cap.
- The family argues the city waived immunity and that running a fare-charging train line is a proprietary function.
- The accused killer's federal case is paused after a June finding that he is incompetent to stand trial.
The city of Charlotte has asked a judge to throw out the wrongful-death lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee who was stabbed to death on a city light-rail train in August 2025. City lawyers filed the motion Monday in Mecklenburg County Superior Court and argued that governmental immunity shields Charlotte from the family's claims, The Daily Wire reported [3].
The motion goes beyond immunity. It also invokes the public duty doctrine and several other grounds for rejecting the suit, WBTV reported [1]. For a family that has spent more than a year asking how their daughter and niece could be killed on a crowded train, the filing lands as a hard answer.
What the City Argues
According to Carolina Journal, the city contends that policing the transit system, preventing crime, overseeing its private security contractor and running public safety are all governmental functions protected under state law [2]. City lawyers also argue that the intentional criminal act of the man accused of the killing, not the city's security practices, was the legal cause of Zarutska's death [2].
Charlotte disputes that the attack was foreseeable, and it denies that thin security staffing or weak fare enforcement led to her death, WBTV reported [1]. The city also wants a ceiling on what it could owe. Its lawyers say any claims tied to Zarutska's injury and death fall under a cumulative $1 million limit set in state law [2]. The motion asks the court to dismiss every claim against the city and to bar the family from filing them again [2].
No ruling has been reported, and a judge will decide whether to grant or deny the motion [1].
What the Family Says Went Wrong
The family sued on Aug. 21, almost exactly one year after Zarutska was killed, naming the city and its transit security contractor, Professional Security Services, WBTV reported at the time [4]. The plaintiff is her uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, who serves as the administrator of her estate, according to Carolina Journal [2].
The complaint describes what the family calls systemic failures on the Charlotte Area Transit System [4]. It says the city's contract with the security company budgeted for 219 security positions, including 39 armed personnel, and it points to four homicides on the system between December 2024 and the August 2025 attack [4]. The family is seeking damages of more than $25,000 for its suffering and funeral costs, along with punitive damages from the contractor [4]. When the suit was filed, the city said it would not comment on active litigation [4].
The family's lawyers expected the immunity defense. Their complaint argues that Charlotte waived its immunity and that operating a light-rail line that sells tickets is a proprietary, business-like activity rather than a core governmental one, Carolina Journal reported [2]. Whether running the trains counts as governing or as doing business is likely to decide whether this case moves forward.
The Criminal Case and What Comes Next
Zarutska was riding a Charlotte Area Transit System light-rail train on Aug. 22, 2025, when she was attacked and killed [4]. The man charged in her death, DeCarlos Brown Jr., had been arrested more than a dozen times and had served more than five years in prison on a violent robbery count, according to court records cited by ABC11 [6]. He faces state and federal charges, including first-degree murder [6].
His federal case has stalled. In June, a federal judge found Brown incompetent to stand trial, committed him for up to four months of treatment at a federal medical facility and found his prognosis for having his competency restored to be good, WUNC reported [5]. State prosecutors have said they will wait for the federal case to finish before resuming their own prosecution [5].
Her death has already changed North Carolina law. Gov. Josh Stein signed "Iryna's Law" in October 2025, ending cashless release for certain violent crimes and many repeat offenders, limiting the discretion of judges and magistrates over pretrial release and requiring them to weigh a defendant's mental state before letting him go, ABC11 reported [6].
The next step in the civil case is a ruling on the city's motion. If the judge sides with Charlotte, the family's claims against the city would end, though its separate claims against the security contractor were filed in the same suit [2][4]. If the judge lets the suit proceed, the city could still try to hold any recovery to the $1 million cap it cites [2].
Charlotte is entitled to every defense the law gives it. But the question this family is asking is a fair one that every rider deserves answered: when a city sells a ticket, invites the public aboard and hires guards to keep order, what does it owe the passengers who trust it? Iryna Zarutska came to this country to escape a war. Her family is asking for a full hearing on whether the system that carried her home did its job, and the people of Charlotte, who ride those same trains every day, have every reason to want that answer too.
Sources
Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?
- Yes, for the worst murders
- Only with absolute proof like DNA
- No, life without parole is enough
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.