Today on Order in the Court with Harold Whitmore
Defense Asks a Utah Judge to Halt New FBI Tests on the Bullet Fragments in the Kirk Assassination Case. Here's Why Those Fragments Matter
The defense wants its own experts to examine the autopsy fragments before the FBI runs 3D scans and metallurgy tests, while prosecutors say the work is non-destructive and the data will be shared.
Filed November 18, 2026 · 📍 Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: Charlie Kirk's Accused Killer Won't Face Trial Until June 2028
Key points
- Robinson's lawyers asked Judge Tony Graf to pause FBI virtual comparison microscopy on the bullet fragments
- Prosecutors say the 3D scans are non-destructive and the data will go to the defense
- An earlier ATF report could not include or exclude the recovered rifle
- Jury selection in the capital case is set for June 21, 2028
More than a year after Charlie Kirk was shot and killed while speaking to students at Utah Valley University, the case against the man accused of murdering him has turned on a handful of metal fragments.
Lawyers for Tyler Robinson have asked a Utah judge to halt a new round of testing on bullet fragments recovered during Kirk's autopsy, Fox News reported Wednesday [1]. Prosecutors want the FBI to examine the fragments with an advanced 3D technique, and the defense wants its own experts to get a look first [1]. Here is what the fight is about, why it matters and where the case goes from here.
The Two Sides of the Motion
Robinson's attorneys asked Fourth District Judge Tony Graf to stop prosecutors from moving ahead with what is known as virtual comparison microscopy until defense experts can examine and photograph the fragments, Fox News reported [1]. As an alternative, they asked that a defense expert be allowed to watch the testing in person or by video [1].
The defense argues that earlier testing by the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives already altered the evidence, and that further handling could change it again before their experts ever see it [1]. The defense has argued that if the jacket fragment is altered again to the point that no independent comparison is possible, the harm to Robinson would be severe [1].
Utah County prosecutors oppose the request and want the court to allow two kinds of FBI testing, KSL reported [2]. The first is virtual comparison microscopy, which prosecutors describe as non-destructive: it uses 3D technology to capture multiple scans of an object, and the state says the scan data will be preserved and handed to the defense for its own analysis [2]. The second is metallurgy testing on the bullet's jacket fragment and at least one lead fragment [2].
Prosecutors say the goal is to add evidence that the bullet came from the rifle investigators recovered, and they argue that neither test would prevent the defense from running similar tests later [2]. They also told the court there is no reason to believe the fragments hold evidence that would clear Robinson [2].
Why a Few Fragments Matter
The fight traces back to an earlier report from the ATF. According to prosecutors, the agency could not include or exclude the jacket fragment as having been fired from the recovered rifle, and the lead fragments were not suitable for a microscopic comparison [2]. The defense has pointed to that inconclusive result as a reason to protect the remaining evidence, while prosecutors say the defense has described the ATF's findings in a misleading way [2].
For readers who follow criminal cases, this kind of dispute is common. Firearms examiners compare the tiny marks a gun barrel leaves on a bullet, and when a bullet is badly damaged, those marks can be too faint to match. A new scan will not change what happened on that campus, but it could strengthen or weaken one strand of the state's evidence before a jury. Judge Graf has not yet ruled on the request, according to the reports [1].
How the Case Got Here, and What Comes Next
Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk during a Turning Point USA event at Utah Valley University in Orem on Sept. 10, 2025, the New York Post reported [3]. Kirk, the co-founder of Turning Point USA, was 31 [3].
Robinson, 23, has pleaded not guilty to seven counts, including aggravated murder, Reuters reported in a story carried by The Daily Signal [4]. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty, and Breitbart News described the case as a capital murder trial [5].
Earlier this month, Graf set jury selection for June 21, 2028, Breitbart News reported, rejecting the defense's request to push the trial into the third quarter of 2029 [5].
Kirk's family has made clear how hard the wait has been. After the trial date was announced, the family called the decision "deeply disappointing," The Christian Post reported [6]. Erika Kirk, his widow, voiced the family's frustration after the ruling, according to the report [6].
Every defendant in America is presumed innocent and is entitled to a vigorous defense, and Robinson's lawyers are doing what defense lawyers are supposed to do. But justice delayed weighs on victims too. Americans who heard Kirk speak on campuses across the country are watching for a process that is both fair and timely.
The immediate question is whether Graf lets the FBI testing go forward as prosecutors propose, requires that the defense first be allowed to examine the fragments, or allows defense experts to observe [1]. Whatever he decides, the fragments will likely surface again when the trial begins in the summer of 2028 [5].
Sources
- [1]Fox NewsTyler Robinson defense wants testing on bullet fragments paused in assassination of Charlie KirkOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]New York PostTyler Robinson defense wants to pause bullet fragment testing in Charlie Kirk assassinationOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Breitbart NewsCharlie Kirk Assassination Trial: Judge Sets 2028 Start Date for Suspect Tyler RobinsonOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]The Christian Post'Deeply disappointing': 4 reactions to 2028 trial date for Charlie Kirk's accused killer Tyler RobinsonOpens in a new tab ↗
Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?
- Yes, for the worst murders
- Only with absolute proof like DNA
- No, life without parole is enough
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.