Markets
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Updated 5:54 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Crime & Justice

Monday night on Order in the Court with Harold Whitmore

Two Courts, One Verdict: How President Trump's Fight to Erase the Hush Money Conviction Works, and What Comes Next

A New York appeals panel heard his challenge Nov. 5, and a federal appeals court took up his bid to move the case on Monday. Here is a plain-English guide to the arguments, the judges' questions and the paths ahead.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: The grand columned facade of a classic New York appellate courthouse at twilight, granite steps glistening after rain, a single brass scale of justice silhouetted in a lit window, an American flag stirring on a pole, autumn…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Developing

Story tracker

0 updates · last updated Nov 16, 11:26 PM ET

Our anchors are following this story. New details will appear here as they come in.

Key points

  • Trump is challenging his 34-count hush money conviction in New York's Appellate Division and at the federal Second Circuit.
  • In state court, his lawyers argue federal election law preempts the felony theory and that immunity-protected evidence was wrongly admitted.
  • CNN reported the five state justices at times appeared open to his arguments; one questioned whether preemption alone could void the verdict.
  • The Second Circuit heard his bid Monday to move the case to federal court; neither court has ruled.

President Donald Trump is fighting the same criminal conviction on two fronts at once. In New York, a state appellate court has already heard his argument that the verdict should be thrown out. In federal court, an appeals panel is weighing whether it can, or should, step in at all, PBS News reported Monday [1].

Neither court has ruled. The conviction, 34 felony counts of falsifying business records, stands for now, and Trump's sentence remains the unconditional discharge he received in January 2025 [3][6]. But the arguments of the past two weeks show where the case is headed, and why the answers matter well beyond one defendant.

How We Got Here

A Manhattan jury convicted Trump in May 2024 of falsifying business records connected to reimbursing his former lawyer, Michael Cohen, for a $130,000 payment to adult-film actress Stormy Daniels before the 2016 election [3][6]. It was the first criminal conviction of a former American president [3].

Falsifying business records is ordinarily a misdemeanor in New York. Prosecutors in Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg's office turned the charges into felonies by arguing the records were falsified to hide another crime, a theory that relied in part on federal election law [2][6].

Justice Juan Merchan sentenced Trump to an unconditional discharge shortly before he returned to the White House, meaning no jail, no fine and no probation, while leaving the felony record in place [3][6]. Trump has been appealing ever since [3].

The State Appeal: Two Big Arguments

On Nov. 5, Trump's lawyer Robert Giuffra stood before a five-justice panel of the Appellate Division, First Department, in Manhattan [2][3]. He pressed two main arguments, according to CNN and ABC News [2][3].

The first is preemption. Trump's team argues that the federal law governing campaign money, the Federal Election Campaign Act, covers federal campaigns so completely that a state prosecutor cannot use it as the hidden crime that turns a misdemeanor into a felony [2][3]. Under the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, when Congress fully occupies a field, the states must step back. If the court agrees, the felony theory at the heart of the case falls.

The second argument is about presidential immunity and evidence. After the trial ended, the Supreme Court ruled in Trump v. United States that presidents have broad immunity from prosecution for official acts, and that prosecutors may not use evidence of those acts to prove other charges [2][3]. Trump's lawyers say jurors heard testimony about his time in office, including from former aide Hope Hicks, that should never have come in [2].

Prosecutors answered that the testimony at issue concerned Trump's personal views and private matters, not his official duties [2][3].

What the Justices Asked

Courtroom watchers read the hearing differently. CNN reported that the five justices, all appointed by Democratic governors, at times appeared open to Trump's arguments that federal election law and presidential immunity could affect the conviction [2]. ABC News and CBS News focused more on the hard questions both sides faced [3][6].

One justice pushed back on the preemption argument, asking whether it alone could justify tossing the verdict when federal election law was only one part of the state's overall case [3]. That question goes to the heart of the appeal. Prosecutors offered jurors more than one possible "other crime," and an appeals court that finds one theory flawed must still decide whether the error tainted the whole verdict.

The immunity argument raises a related question: how much of the challenged testimony touched official acts, and whether any error was serious enough to matter. Appellate judges often ask whether a mistake was harmless, meaning the jury would have reached the same result without it. That standard can decide cases like this one.

The Federal Track: Why the Second Circuit Matters

The second front opened Monday at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit [1][4][5].

Trump has argued for years that the case belongs in federal court because it involves conduct while he was president, and federal law allows certain cases against federal officers to be moved out of state courts [4][5]. A federal judge in Manhattan has now rejected that request three times, most recently in an August ruling that Trump is challenging [4][5].

This is not Trump's first trip to the Second Circuit on this question. The appeals court previously sent the removal fight back to the district judge for a fresh look in light of the Supreme Court's immunity decision, and the August ruling now under review came out of that second look [4][5]. The repeated rounds show how unsettled the law still is when a former president's official conduct and a state prosecution collide.

On Monday, his lawyers told the appeals panel that presidents enjoy broader immunity from prosecution and that the case should be moved to federal court [5]. Judge Raymond Lohier pressed them on procedure, suggesting the court was being asked to adopt a mechanism that Congress never authorized, Courthouse News reported [4].

PBS framed the key issue simply: whether the federal court can, or should, intervene now that the state appeal is already underway [1]. Federal courts are generally reluctant to interfere with a state case midstream, and Monday's questions suggested the panel is weighing that concern carefully [1][4].

What a Win Would Mean, and What It Would Not

If the Appellate Division accepts the preemption argument, the felony theory collapses and the conviction could be thrown out entirely. If it finds the immunity-related evidence should have been excluded and the error was not harmless, the likely remedy is a new trial rather than an outright dismissal.

A loss in the state court would not end Trump's options. Either side could seek review at New York's highest court, the Court of Appeals, and federal questions such as immunity and preemption could eventually reach the U.S. Supreme Court.

On the federal track, a win would move the case into federal court, where Trump's team believes immunity claims would get a fuller hearing [4][5]. A loss would leave the state appeal as the main battlefield [1].

Why It Matters

For our readers, this case was never only about one man. It raised a question Americans of every political stripe should care about: whether a local prosecutor may stretch a records charge into a felony by borrowing a federal campaign law that federal regulators enforce, and then try that case against a leading candidate for president in the middle of an election year [2][6].

Equal justice under law means the same rules for everyone, which includes the rule that prosecutors must charge crimes the law clearly defines. The Supreme Court's immunity ruling also gave the appellate courts a real question about what jurors were allowed to hear [2][3]. Those are not partisan talking points. They are the kind of issues appeals courts exist to settle, and it is a healthy sign that judges on both courts appear to be taking them seriously [2][4]. How the courts answer will shape what any future president, of either party, can expect from local prosecutors once he or she leaves office.

As for timing, there is no deadline for either court to rule [1]. State appellate decisions in cases this complex can take months, and the Second Circuit could choose to wait for the state court before acting [1][4]. Whatever happens, the losing side is likely to keep appealing, which means the final word on the hush money case could still be a long way off. We will explain each ruling as it comes.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?

  1. Yes, for the worst murders
  2. Only with absolute proof like DNA
  3. No, life without parole is enough
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.