Markets
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Updated 5:54 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Pushback

Last night on Order in the Court with Harold Whitmore

Who Decides Who Serves? A 2-1 Ruling on Transgender Troops Runs Into the Constitution and the Supreme Court

An appeals panel refused to pause its ruling for 27 service members, but the high court has already let the Pentagon policy take effect, and the Constitution puts military standards with Congress and the commander in chief.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic image of the white marble steps and columns of the U.S. Supreme Court at dusk, a folded American flag and a pair of polished military dress shoes resting on the bottom step in the foreground, warm…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Key points

  • A divided D.C. Circuit panel barred the Pentagon from discharging the transgender troops who sued; their lawyers say 27 are covered.
  • The order is narrow: it does not reopen recruiting and the policy stays in force for the rest of the military.
  • The Supreme Court allowed the policy to take effect in May 2025 in United States v. Shilling.
  • Judge Justin Walker dissented, and the administration is asking the justices to take up the case.

A divided federal appeals court on Tuesday ordered the Pentagon not to discharge the transgender service members who sued over the administration's military service policy. In a 2-1 order, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit refused the government's request to put its own June ruling on hold while the Justice Department asks the Supreme Court to hear the case [1]. Lawyers for the plaintiffs say the order protects 27 service members [2].

The Advocate reported the order as the court protecting transgender troops, and the Associated Press account carried in The Washington Times stressed the majority's view that the policy likely violates the Constitution [1][2]. The fuller record tells a different story: the Supreme Court has already let the policy take effect, a respected appeals judge dissented, and the Constitution places decisions about military fitness first with Congress and the commander in chief, not with a two-judge majority.

What the Court Did, and What It Did Not Do

Judges Robert Wilkins and Judith Rogers formed the majority, concluding that the policy likely violates the plaintiffs' constitutional rights; Judge Justin Walker dissented [1]. The order is narrow. It covers only the active-duty plaintiffs in this lawsuit, and it does not reopen military recruiting to transgender applicants [1][2]. The policy remains in force for the rest of the armed forces.

That narrowness matters, because it follows the panel's June 1 decision, which agreed with a district judge's findings but limited relief to the troops who brought the case [3]. In other words, even the judges who ruled against the Pentagon did not claim the power to rewrite personnel rules for the entire military.

The Supreme Court Has Already Spoken Once

This fight has been to the high court before. In May 2025, in a related case, United States v. Shilling, the Supreme Court paused a lower-court order and allowed the Pentagon to enforce the policy while the litigation continued [3][5]. The administration asked the appeals panel to hold its ruling while the justices consider the case, pointing to that history, and the majority said no [1].

When the nation's highest court has allowed a policy to operate, a lower court refusing to pause its own contrary ruling while the justices weigh a petition is, at the least, an invitation for the Supreme Court to step in again.

The Constitution Gives This Job to the Elected Branches

Article I of the Constitution gives Congress the power to raise and support armies and to make rules for the government and regulation of the land and naval forces. Article II makes the president commander in chief. Those clauses are why courts have long given the military unusual latitude on who may serve and under what standards.

Judge Walker made that point in his June dissent. He wrote that Supreme Court precedent allows the armed forces to limit rights "that the Constitution may well guarantee to civilians," and argued that judges lack the authority to second-guess the decision on transgender service [4]. That is not a fringe view; it describes decades of rulings in which the justices declined to manage military personnel policy from the bench, on everything from the draft to uniform rules.

The Readiness Numbers Behind the Policy

The administration's policy, laid out in a February 2025 memo from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, stopped new transgender enlistments and halted military-provided procedures tied to gender transition [6]. Defense officials said at the time that 4,240 troops in the active duty, Guard and Reserve had a gender dysphoria diagnosis as of December 2024, and that the department had spent about $52 million from 2015 through 2024 on related care, including psychotherapy, hormones and surgery [5]. About 1,000 service members came forward to begin voluntary separation after a later directive [5].

Critics argue $52 million is small next to the Pentagon's health budget, and that is a fair point to weigh [5]. But the military's standards have never been about cost alone. The armed forces set medical rules on everything from eyesight to asthma because deployability, unit cohesion and time in the field come first. Deciding where that line falls is precisely the kind of judgment the Constitution leaves to the people accountable to voters.

Who Is Pushing Back and What Comes Next

Hegseth answered the June ruling by signaling he would take the fight to the Supreme Court, and the administration is now asking the justices to take up the case [1][4]. The dissent gives the high court a ready road map, and its earlier order in Shilling shows the justices were willing to let the policy operate while the courts sort out the law [3][5].

Respect for the men and women who serve, including those affected by this policy, is not in question. The question is who decides the standards for service. The Constitution answers it: Congress writes the rules, the commander in chief carries them out, and the courts should be slow to substitute their judgment for both. Expect the next chapter of this fight to be written at the Supreme Court.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?

  1. Yes
  2. I think so
  3. No
  4. I'm not on social media
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.