‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Investigations & Special Reports

Fifteen Million Leaked Files Put Deutsche Bank's Promise of Reform on Trial

A trove of about 15 million leaked internal records raises hard questions about Deutsche Bank's controls, from Epstein payments to Russian clients to the mishandling of President Trump's private tax statements.

By KEVIN NAKAMURAStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 17, 7:00 AM · 6 min. read

Illustration: A cinematic, photorealistic dusk view of Frankfurt's glass banking towers along the River Main, the iron Eiserner Steg footbridge in the middle distance and rain-slicked embankments reflecting cold office lights, with an…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

For years Deutsche Bank has assured regulators, investors and the public that it is a changed institution. On Tuesday, a mountain of its own paperwork put that promise on trial. A cache of roughly 15 million internal files, copied by two insiders and examined by more than 200 journalists at roughly 50 news organizations, went public in coordinated reports describing a bank that repeatedly bent its own safeguards for lucrative or powerful clients.

Investors did not wait for the fine print. Deutsche Bank shares fell 5.2 percent in early trading in Frankfurt, Reuters reported, while CNBC put the decline at 4.7 percent. Reuters noted that it could not immediately verify the reports.

The bank answered quickly. In a statement, it said the matters described date back many years, in some cases as long as two decades, and that it invested 7 billion euros in its control systems between 2019 and 2025. The bank said it is a different institution today. That defense deserves a fair hearing. It also deserves scrutiny, because several of the episodes now coming to light unfolded with the knowledge of Christian Sewing, the man who has run the bank since 2018, according to the reporting.

Fifteen Million Files and Two Insiders

The project, published under the banner "Inside Deutsche Bank," was coordinated by Barracuda Media, a South African nonprofit, with technical support from the Data and Research Center in Germany. Two whistleblowers handed the records to journalists, and partner outlets say they paid nothing for the material and independently checked everything they chose to publish. The consortium includes the Financial Times, Der Spiegel and The New York Times. The trove holds millions of emails along with internal investigations, board minutes, compliance files and chat logs, according to coverage of the leak.

Fairness requires a caveat that the consortium itself offered. Many bank clients who appear in the records are accused of nothing, and the documents contain no evidence of illegal activity on their part. That is why this report names only public figures and the bank's own leadership. Readers should also know that the whistleblowers may have a financial stake: under American rules, they could be entitled to a share of any penalties the U.S. government collects because of their information.

A President's Private Records, Mishandled

Of all the revelations, one should trouble every family that trusts a bank with private papers. In March 2017, early in President Trump's first term, a Deutsche Bank relationship manager sent year-end tax statements for 1,586 accounts, the President's among them, to the accountant of a single other client, the Financial Times reported, according to CNBC. The accountant alerted the bank and deleted the file.

The bank did not tell the White House, according to the reporting. Mr. Sewing, who was then in charge of private banking, knew of the incident and called it "an awful mistake".

The facts here are simple. The President was the wronged party. A client's confidential financial records were exposed through a basic lapse, and the customer whose privacy was breached was apparently never informed. If a global bank would keep such an error from the most prominent client it had, ordinary account holders have every reason to ask what they might not be told about their own records.

Epstein and the Cost of Looking Away

The files also deepen the record on Jeffrey Epstein, the convicted sex offender Deutsche Bank accepted as a client in 2013. Coverage of the leak puts the suspicious transactions tied to Epstein and his network at roughly $582 million, about twice the amount previously known to the public. The bank has said it acknowledges its error in taking Epstein on and regrets its past connection with him.

This is not new ground for regulators. In July 2020, New York's Department of Financial Services imposed a $150 million penalty after finding that the bank failed to properly monitor Epstein's account activity despite ample public information about his history. The regulator pointed to more than $7 million in settlement payments and more than $800,000 in suspicious cash withdrawals over roughly four years, and described the case as the first enforcement action by any regulator against a financial institution over dealings with Epstein. The same order also faulted the bank's oversight of its correspondent relationships with Danske Bank's Estonian branch and FBME Bank.

For Christians who believe the vulnerable deserve protection, this is not abstract. Banks are meant to be a line of defense against exploitation and the money that fuels it. When that line is drawn loosely for the wealthy and well connected, real people pay the price.

Russia, Oligarchs and Overruled Gatekeepers

Russia is the darkest chapter in Deutsche Bank's regulatory file. In January 2017, New York regulators fined the bank $425 million and required it to hire an independent monitor over a so-called mirror-trading scheme that moved about $10 billion out of Russia through its Moscow, London and New York operations. In those paired trades, a client bought stock in rubles in Moscow while a related party sold the same shares for dollars in London, quietly shifting money across borders.

The leaked records suggest the lesson did not fully take hold. Under Mr. Sewing, the bank plotted an expansion of its Russia business and overruled its own compliance staff's concerns about clients connected to the Kremlin, the Financial Times reported, according to CNBC. Compliance officers exist precisely to say no when the risk is too high. A bank that overrides them for growth is treating its gatekeepers as an obstacle rather than a safeguard.

The Chief Executive's Own Words

Mr. Sewing's own correspondence features in the files. In a 2017 internal email, written while he sat on the management board, he complained that know-your-customer checks, the basic rules for verifying who a client really is, were hurting the bank's revenue, according to coverage of the leak. When he became chief executive the following year, he promised a steadier and more boring bank.

The bank pushes back hard on that portrait. It says the emails were quoted selectively, some drawn from separate threads, and that it is legitimate to tailor such checks to the risk profile of each business. It firmly rejected suggestions about Mr. Sewing's attitude as false. The bank also credits his leadership with a fundamental transformation of the institution, pointing to the 7 billion euros in control spending, and it declined to discuss individual current or former client relationships.

Those points deserve weight. Rebuilding compliance at a bank of this size is costly, and much of the material is years old. But the bank's history is the problem. It has been penalized by New York regulators before, over Russia in 2017 and over Epstein in 2020. Fines are ultimately paid by shareholders, many of them ordinary savers and pension holders, while the decision makers who approved risky clients rarely face personal consequences.

What Accountability Should Look Like

Scripture teaches that whoever is faithful in small matters will be faithful in large ones (Luke 16:10). A bank earns trust the same way, one account and one honest disclosure at a time. Know-your-customer rules are not red tape invented by bureaucrats; they are how a bank keeps criminals, sanctioned regimes and predators away from the financial system that hardworking families depend on.

The questions raised on Tuesday are straightforward. Did the bank apply the same standards to powerful clients that it applies to a small-business owner opening a checking account? Why was a client whose private tax records were exposed not told? And who inside the bank decided that compliance warnings about Kremlin-linked money could be set aside?

Deutsche Bank says it is a different, stronger institution today, and its spending on controls is real. The 15 million files now in reporters' hands give regulators in New York, Washington and Frankfurt fresh material to test that claim. Investors delivered their verdict in a single morning of trading. Regulators, and the bank's board, now owe the public a fuller accounting.

Sources

  1. CNBC: Deutsche Bank shares sink as whistleblowers reveal Epstein payments, Trump tax leak, Russia bets (link)
  2. Reuters (via Investing.com): Deutsche Bank shares fall 5% as it defends itself from media reports based on leaks (link)
  3. Foundation for Investigative Journalism: Inside Deutsche Bank: All you need to know (link)
  4. Financial Mail: Inside Deutsche Bank: Secrets, scandals and double standards (link)
  5. New York State Department of Financial Services: DFS Fines Deutsche Bank $425 Million for Russian Mirror-Trading Scheme (link)
  6. Axios: Deutsche Bank pays New York $150 million for dealings with Jeffrey Epstein (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageJudge Boasberg Keeps Most of Ilhan Omar Search Affidavit…Turn the pageA Forensic Expert Says Epstein Was Strangled. The Official…