‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Investigations & Special Reports

Judge Boasberg Keeps Most of Ilhan Omar Search Affidavit Sealed, Says He Will Release Records on Congressional Safeguards

A federal judge sided with the Justice Department on keeping the bulk of the affidavit secret while saying he will order a narrower release about how Rep. Ilhan Omar's legislative protections were handled. Omar has not been charged.

By KEVIN NAKAMURAStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 17, 3:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: The E. Barrett Prettyman federal courthouse in Washington, D.C., on a gray November afternoon, with a sealed manila envelope bearing a red wax seal resting beside a wooden gavel on a courtroom bench, and the U.S. Capitol dome…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

A federal judge in Washington said Tuesday that he will keep most of the sworn affidavit behind last month's search of Rep. Ilhan Omar's home under seal for now, while saying he will order the release of a narrower set of records about how investigators were told to protect her work as a member of Congress.

Chief Judge James E. Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia said at a court hearing that he agreed with the Justice Department that the "vast majority" of the search warrant affidavit should remain sealed, NBC News reported. He said it would be premature to unseal the entire document. But Boasberg said records of discussions between attorneys and a federal magistrate judge about safeguards for Omar's rights as a lawmaker should be made public.

The New York Post reported that portions of the warrant executed at Omar's Washington residence, along with other information about the immigration-fraud investigation, are expected to be revealed following Tuesday's hearing. The early reports did not give a firm date for the release.

Who Asked for the Records, and What Each Side Argued

The hearing followed requests from news organizations and a conservative legal watchdog to open the court file. Newsweek reported that the judge was weighing whether to unseal records that could reveal the basis for the federal search. Judicial Watch filed its motion to unseal on Oct. 15, and Boasberg's Nov. 12 order setting Tuesday's 11 a.m. hearing directed the government to be prepared to explain why materials beyond the affidavit itself could not be unsealed.

The Justice Department has argued for keeping the bulk of the file secret while its investigation continues. At the hearing, Justice Department attorney Alessandra Serano told the court that officials were still reviewing material seized from the home, according to NBC News. A department lawyer also indicated that some material about the congressional-safeguard discussions could be released, NBC reported.

Omar's lawyers have pressed a separate challenge. They have contested the legality of the search and asked for the return of property agents took, arguing that agents violated protections tied to her congressional work, did not provide the warrant and kept her from reaching her attorneys. The Justice Department rejects that account and says agents complied with the court's orders. A department spokesperson has said officers and attorneys carefully followed the protocol laid out in the warrant.

What Is Known, and What Omar Says

Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar's Washington home on Oct. 12. In a statement that day, the Justice Department said agents executed a judicially authorized search warrant as part of an ongoing federal criminal investigation, without saying whom or what the warrant concerned. Sources told ABC News that the probe relates to Omar's immigration paperwork.

Omar has not been charged with any crime. She has long denied accusations of immigration fraud made by political opponents. The specific allegations, the evidence investigators presented to obtain the warrant and whether any charges will follow all remain unknown to the public. Boasberg's decision to keep most of the affidavit sealed means those questions will not be answered by the upcoming release.

What the public is likely to learn is narrower but still significant: how prosecutors, defense lawyers and a magistrate judge handled the Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause, which shields lawmakers' legislative work, during a search of a sitting member's home. How those protections were applied matters to lawmakers of both parties, whatever becomes of this particular case.

Omar has described the search as an effort to target political enemies and weaponize federal law enforcement, and has said she will not be silenced. In an interview after the search, she said she was confident she had done nothing wrong. She has said agents took 17 items, including old phones, and that she plans to move out of the home for safety reasons.

What Comes Next

Two tracks now move forward at once. On the first, the court is expected to release the limited set of records Boasberg identified, while the affidavit's core stays sealed as the Justice Department continues reviewing what it seized. On the second, Omar's challenge to the search and her request for the return of her property remain in dispute between her lawyers and the department.

For readers, the principles at stake cut both ways. The public has a legitimate interest in understanding why federal agents searched the home of a member of Congress, which is why news organizations and a watchdog group went to court. At the same time, every American under investigation, Omar included, is entitled to the presumption of innocence unless and until the government proves a case in court. No charge has been filed, and no court has found any wrongdoing.

The Liberty Bell Report will continue to follow the case as records are released.

Sources

  1. NBC News: Judge to order release of some records in federal search of Ilhan Omar's home (link)
  2. New York Post: Ilhan Omar probe secrets set to be revealed after search warrant ordered released (link)
  3. Newsweek: Judge Weighs Unsealing of Ilhan Omar Search Warrant (link)
  4. ABC News: Rep. Ilhan Omar's residence searched as part of ongoing criminal investigation, DOJ says (link)
  5. NBC News: Rep. Ilhan Omar details federal search of her D.C. home, says she'll have to move for safety reasons (link)
  6. Judicial Watch: Federal Judge Orders November 17 Hearing on Unsealing Ilhan Omar Search Warrant Records (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageStanding Guard Over What Veterans Earned: Justice…Turn the pageFifteen Million Leaked Files Put Deutsche Bank's Promise of…