Investigations & Special Reports
A Forensic Expert Says Epstein Was Strangled. The Official Ruling Says Suicide. Here Is What Each Side Rests On
Michael Freeman's review of the medical examiner's file revives the hardest questions about the night Jeffrey Epstein died, and about a government that never fully answered them.
By KEVIN NAKAMURAStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 16, 8:30 PM · 5 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Seven years after Jeffrey Epstein was found dead in a federal jail in Manhattan, a forensic medicine expert says the evidence points to homicide, not suicide. Michael Freeman told BBC Newsnight that after reviewing the New York City medical examiner's file, he believes Epstein was strangled, most likely by someone standing behind him.
Freeman laid out his findings in a lecture in London on Monday, and they were reported the same day by the BBC, CBS News and the New York Post. The Post reported that he spent a year working through the complete autopsy file, which Epstein's brother, Mark, gave him.
The official finding has not changed. New York City's medical examiner ruled the death a suicide by hanging in 2019, concluding there was no evidence of the defensive wounds expected in a homicide, and Dr. Barbara Sampson, who led the office at the time, has said she stands behind that ruling. Federal investigators and the Justice Department's own watchdog reached the same bottom line.
For readers who have followed this case with deep and understandable suspicion, the question is not whether to take one expert's word for it. It is whether the government ever did the careful, transparent work that would let Americans trust its answer.
What Freeman Says He Found
According to the BBC, Freeman pointed to injuries he says do not fit a suicide: a deep hemorrhage in Epstein's left shoulder, injuries that appeared consistent with blows to the face, and what appeared to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark on the neck. In his view, those marks suggest a struggle.
"The injuries and the way the body was found don't match up," Freeman told the BBC.
CBS News reported that Freeman also took issue with the mark on Epstein's neck itself, saying it was neither smooth nor uniform and did not slope upward the way a typical hanging mark would. He argued that the horizontal pattern points to a ligature pulled from behind. He also rejected the idea that Epstein made two attempts that night, arguing that a first attempt severe enough to fracture structures in the neck would be unlikely to leave a man conscious and able to try again.
The Holes in the Scene
Some of Freeman's sharpest criticism is aimed not at the autopsy but at how the scene was handled. CBS News reported that he says no photographs were taken of Epstein's body in its original position, that the ligature said to have been used was never preserved or compared against the neck wounds, and that the cell was never sealed for a forensic investigation.
Those complaints land on ground the government itself has already conceded. In 2023, the Justice Department's inspector general described a cascade of failures at the Metropolitan Correctional Center, where Epstein was being held on federal sex-trafficking charges when he died in August 2019. Staff did not give Epstein the cellmate the jail's psychology department had called for, guards failed to make required checks and then falsified records saying they had, and a camera system that was not fully working left investigators with limited video. The watchdog also found employees stretched thin by staffing shortages.
Two officers on duty that night were charged with falsifying records, and those charges were later dismissed. Even so, Inspector General Michael Horowitz said his office found no evidence contradicting the FBI's conclusion that there was no criminality in how Epstein died.
Not the First Expert to Break Ranks
Freeman is not the first to challenge the ruling. In 2019, Dr. Michael Baden, a former New York City chief medical examiner hired by Mark Epstein, observed the autopsy and said fractures in Epstein's neck were more consistent with homicidal strangulation than with suicidal hanging. "I think that the evidence points toward homicide rather than suicide," Baden said then. Sampson rejected that view at the time and stood by her office's work.
What is new is the depth of Freeman's review. He built his case on the whole file, along with three-dimensional reconstructions he created himself. CBS also noted an important limit: Freeman never examined the body. His work rests on the autopsy records and photographs supplied by Epstein's brother. Fair-minded readers should weigh both facts.
What the Government Has Said
In July 2025, the Justice Department and the FBI released a memo concluding that Epstein died by suicide and that a systematic review found no incriminating "client list". The memo said jail footage covering roughly 10:40 p.m. to 6:30 a.m. showed no one entering the area of Epstein's cell, and that no further charges would be filed. It also said releasing more of the files was not warranted, citing the risk of exposing victims and people never charged with a crime.
That memo was meant to close the book. For many Americans who had been promised openness, a closed door was exactly the problem. Freeman's lecture now arrives in that climate of distrust, and it will be read by many as confirmation of what they long suspected.
Why It Matters
Caution is still in order. One expert's reading of a file is not proof of murder, and the medical examiner's ruling stands. Freeman's conclusions will now face scrutiny from other forensic specialists, as they should.
But consider what is not in dispute. By the government's own account, the jail failed at basic duties on the night that mattered most, and its records were falsified. By Freeman's account, the body was not photographed where it was found and the ligature was not kept. Those are not internet rumors. They are the kind of failures that leave room for doubt to grow, and they fall on the people charged with guarding one of the most notorious prisoners in the country.
Conservatives have long held that institutions earn trust by being accountable, not by demanding it. That principle matters most when the institutions are the federal prison system and the Justice Department, which hold real power over American lives and owe the public a full accounting when something goes this wrong.
There is a moral dimension as well. Epstein's death meant his victims never saw him stand trial on the federal charges against him. Justice delayed for them became justice denied. Scripture teaches that what is hidden will one day be brought into the light (Luke 8:17), and Americans are right to keep asking until it is.
What Comes Next
The questions now move to the experts and to Washington. Specialists will test Freeman's reconstructions against the same file, and Sampson and the medical examiner's office will face renewed pressure to answer his specific points. The Justice Department, which said in 2025 that further disclosure was not warranted, will face a fresh round of calls to show its work.
Our view is simple. The public does not need a new theory. It needs the full record, released with care for the victims, so that the truth about August 10, 2019, rests on evidence rather than on trust that the government has not earned in this case.
Sources
- BBC News: Forensic expert says his analysis raises doubts about how Epstein died (link)
- CBS News: Jeffrey Epstein's death may not have been suicide, new analysis by leading forensics expert suggests (link)
- New York Post: Forensic expert stunningly claims Jeffrey Epstein didn't kill himself after reviewing autopsy (link)
- ClickOnDetroit (AP): Pathologist: Epstein's autopsy more consistent with homicide than suicide (link)
- NPR: Negligence, staff failures led to Jeffrey Epstein's suicide, a DOJ report says (link)
- Al Jazeera: Epstein had no 'client list', died by suicide, US Justice Department says (link)
— 30 —


