Tonight on Report Card with Rebecca Hartman
Thirty States Said Yes. Why Virginia's Parents and Faith Schools Are Asking Spanberger to Stop Saying No to Federal Scholarships
The governor says the new tax credit won't help public school students. The law itself says otherwise, and Republicans plan to force the question in Richmond.
Filed November 21, 2026 · 📍 Richmond, VA 23219
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: Spanberger Is Closing a Door Washington Opened for Virginia Families. The Facts Say Keep It Open
Key points
- Spanberger's office says Virginia won't join the federal scholarship tax credit this year, reversing Youngkin's January opt-in.
- The law lets scholarships cover tutoring, special needs services and books for public, private or religious school students.
- About 30 states have opted in, including some led by Democratic governors.
- Catholic and Jewish education groups are urging a reversal, and GOP lawmakers plan legislation to require it.
Virginia families were promised a door. Now the governor has closed it, at least for this year.
Gov. Abigail Spanberger's administration has confirmed Virginia will not complete its enrollment in the new Federal Scholarship Tax Credit, reversing the opt-in that former Gov. Glenn Youngkin began in January [1][3]. Her office's explanation is direct: it says it has not seen evidence the program would benefit students in Virginia's public schools, and the commonwealth will not participate this year [2][3]. The governor has said she will watch how other states carry out the program before deciding whether Virginia should join later [3]. The Virginia Education Association, the teachers union, praised the decision [2].
The administration's defenders also point to timing. Youngkin opted in, but the IRS portal for state authorities did not open until after he left office, and his team never submitted the required list of scholarship-granting organizations, according to reporting cited by JNS [3].
Those are the arguments, stated fairly. The facts do not support the conclusion.
What the Law Actually Does
Starting Jan. 1, 2027, the federal credit gives taxpayers a credit of up to $1,700 per person, or $3,400 for married couples filing jointly, for cash donations to approved scholarship-granting nonprofits in participating states, Education Week reports [4]. Eligibility is tied to the public schools, not set against them: a scholarship can go to any student who is eligible to attend a public elementary or secondary school and whose household earns no more than 300 percent of the area's median income [4].
Here is the point the governor's office leaves out. The statute lists tuition, fees, tutoring, special needs services, books, supplies and equipment as eligible expenses for students at public, private or religious schools [4]. A public school child who needs a reading tutor or therapy services is exactly the kind of student this law can help. The IRS has said more detailed guidance on eligible expenses is coming [4], and that is a reason to finish the paperwork and help shape the program, not to walk away from it.
There is also a practical cost to sitting out. Virginia donors can still give to scholarship groups in other states [2]. In other words, Virginians' generosity can keep flowing under this program, just to children somewhere else.
Not a Partisan Program Everywhere Else
If this were simply a Republican idea, the map would look very different. About 30 states have formally opted in, according to Ballotpedia [5]. New York's Democratic governor announced the state's participation in October, and New Mexico's governor announced on Nov. 4 that her state would join as well [5]. Democrats remain divided on the program, Ballotpedia notes, and five opted-in states, Georgia, Iowa, Nevada, Ohio and Texas, are about to be led by newly elected Democratic governors [5].
That is the real test ahead. Virginia's choice should not become the template for those new governors. A program that lets a family choose a tutor, a therapist or a faith-based school is not a threat to public education. It is a lifeline for the children that large systems struggle to serve, and it costs local school budgets nothing.
Who Is Pushing Back
Parents and faith communities have not been quiet. Steven Cheeseman, president of the National Catholic Educational Association, said he was deeply disappointed and urged the governor to reconsider and finish the opt-in process [6]. Orthodox Jewish education groups and the Jewish Federations of North America have also urged a reversal [3][6]. For many working families in Richmond, Hampton Roads and Northern Virginia, these scholarships could make the difference between a school that fits their child and one that does not.
Republican lawmakers say they will introduce legislation to require Virginia to opt in [1]. That fight will play out when the General Assembly returns in the new year, and it gives every parent in the commonwealth a reason to call a delegate and a state senator.
None of this requires anyone to question the governor's motives. She has said she wants to see evidence, and the evidence is in the law's own text and in the decisions of 30 states. Gov. Spanberger has left herself room to change course. She should take it. Virginia's children deserve the same chance that children in New York, New Mexico and Texas are about to get.
Sources
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.