Overnight on Report Card with Rebecca Hartman
Fair Play for Girls: Why Chino Valley Parents Are Right to Stand Up for Girls' Sports Over Sacramento's Objections
California's attorney general warned a school board that protecting girls' teams and locker rooms breaks state law. The board voted yes anyway, and the Supreme Court's June ruling on girls' sports is on its side of the argument.
Filed November 21, 2026 · 📍 Sacramento, CA 95814
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Chino Valley Unified voted to keep girls' teams and girls' restrooms and locker rooms for girls.
- A deputy attorney general wrote for Rob Bonta that the policy conflicts with California law.
- In June, the Supreme Court upheld state laws limiting girls' teams to girls.
- The Trump administration is suing some states that allow boys on girls' teams.
A Southern California school board did something this week that should not require courage: it voted to keep girls' sports for girls. For that, it got a warning letter from the state's top law enforcement officer.
What Sacramento Said
The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education approved a policy barring transgender athletes from girls' teams, The Center Square reported [3]. The policy also keeps biological boys out of girls' bathrooms and locker rooms, according to the Los Angeles Times [2]. The vote came at the board's final meeting with Sonja Shaw as president; Shaw ran this year for California superintendent of public instruction [2].
Before the vote, Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent wrote to the board on behalf of Attorney General Rob Bonta, urging members to reject the proposal and arguing it conflicts with California law, KVCR reported [1]. Bonta's office said the board was misreading recent Supreme Court decisions [1]. Shaw answered that federal law outranks state law and tore up the letter at Thursday night's meeting, according to KVCR [1]. Board member Andrew Cruz voted no after first trying to delay the vote so incoming members could weigh in [1].
This is not the first fight between Chino Valley and the attorney general. Bonta previously sued over a Shaw-backed policy requiring schools to tell parents if their child identifies as transgender, and a court blocked it [2].
What the Supreme Court Actually Held
Here are the facts the attorney general's letter brushes past. On June 30, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that states may bar transgender athletes from girls' and women's sports teams, upholding laws in West Virginia and Idaho, JURIST reported [5]. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote for the majority [5].
Just as important, the justices agreed unanimously that the Idaho and West Virginia laws do not violate federal civil rights law, SCOTUSblog reported [4]. In other words, Title IX, the 1972 law that opened the doors of American athletics to millions of girls, does not require schools to put boys on girls' teams.
The ruling did not decide what happens in states like California that go the other direction, Axios noted, and the Trump administration is suing some states over policies that let transgender athletes compete on female teams [6]. That is exactly the question Chino Valley has now put on the table, and it is a fair one for the courts to answer.
Common Sense Has Not Changed
Girls' sports exist because of biology. Boys who go through puberty develop, on average, greater height, muscle mass, bone density and heart and lung capacity. That is why we have separate teams in the first place. Pretending otherwise does not create fairness; it erases it.
Privacy in locker rooms is just as basic. Parents across the political spectrum understand that a teenage girl changing for practice should not have to share that space with a teenage boy. Protecting her dignity is not hostility toward anyone else.
To be fair to the district's critics, The Center Square noted that no transgender athletes have been identified as playing girls' sports in Chino Valley [3]. But good policy does not wait for a crisis. It sets clear rules before a girl loses her spot on the podium, her place on the roster or her scholarship.
Who Is Standing Up
The pushback is not coming from one school board alone. States from West Virginia to Idaho wrote these protections into law, and the Supreme Court upheld them [4][5]. The federal government is pressing states that refuse [6]. And in Chino Valley, parents have spent years showing up to meetings to insist that they, not Sacramento, know what is best for their daughters [1][2].
The Constitution leaves room for local communities to protect their children, and federal civil rights law, as the justices have now confirmed, does not stand in their way [4].
What Comes Next
Expect Sacramento to push back, possibly in court [1]. If it does, the case could become one of the first big tests of how far a state can go in forcing local districts to open girls' teams to boys after the Supreme Court's ruling [6]. Chino Valley's girls are worth that fight.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Los Angeles TimesChino Valley Unified bans trans-students from girls sports, restrooms as Sonja Shaw exitsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]The Center SquareChino Valley bans transgender athletes from girls' sportsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]SCOTUSblogCourt rules that states can exclude transgender athletes from girls and women's sports teamsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.