Tonight on Fourth Quarter with Andre Coleman
Seven Cy Youngs and an Acquittal: President Trump Says Roger Clemens Belongs in Cooperstown Now and Promises a Look at Barry Bonds
Two days after pardoning Pete Rose, the President makes the case for the seven-time Cy Young winner a federal jury cleared in 2012, while taking a more cautious line on baseball's home run king.
Filed November 21, 2026 · 📍 White House, DC 20500
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: A Pardon for the Hit King: Trump Clears Pete Rose, Two Years After His Death
Key points
- President Trump said Saturday that Roger Clemens should be in the Hall of Fame immediately, citing his seven Cy Young Awards.
- He promised to take a look at Barry Bonds' case but said the evidence against Bonds appeared stronger.
- A federal jury acquitted Clemens in 2012 on all six counts tied to his denials of steroid use.
- Both men drew fewer than five votes from the Hall's era committee in December 2025 and are off its next ballot.
President Trump is not finished with Cooperstown. Two days after he issued a posthumous pardon to Pete Rose, the President said in a Fox News interview that aired Saturday that Roger Clemens belongs in the Baseball Hall of Fame, and that he should be enshrined "immediately," Fox News reported [1]. At the heart of his case were the seven Cy Young Awards Clemens won, the most by any pitcher in the game's history [1].
He also turned to Barry Bonds, baseball's career home run leader, and promised to "take a look" at his case, the New York Post reported [2]. There he was more careful. According to Reuters, the President praised Bonds' record-setting career but said there appeared to be more evidence against Bonds than against Clemens [3].
The Case the President Is Making
The argument Mr. Trump made for Clemens rests on a principle every American learns early: a man is innocent until proven guilty. Clemens has always denied using performance-enhancing drugs, and the President stressed that nothing was ever proven against him [3]. In 2012, a federal jury acquitted Clemens on all six counts he faced, including perjury, making false statements and obstructing Congress, charges that grew out of his sworn denials of steroid use [3].
That is not a small detail. Clemens was not merely accused in the court of public opinion. The federal government brought its case, laid out its evidence before a jury of ordinary citizens, and lost on every count. Whatever a fan thinks about baseball's steroid era, a verdict like that ought to carry weight. The President is asking a fair question: why have the people who guard the Hall treated an acquitted man as if he had been convicted?
The numbers were never the problem. Clemens sits third on the all-time strikeout list, Yahoo Sports noted in its coverage of the President's remarks [6]. Add the seven Cy Youngs, and you have a résumé that would have sailed into Cooperstown in any other era.
How the Doors Stayed Shut
Clemens and Bonds both used up their full 10 years on the Baseball Writers' Association of America ballot. In their final try in 2022, Bonds was named on 66 percent of ballots and Clemens on 65.2 percent, short of the 75 percent needed for election, the Associated Press reported [5].
Their next chance came in December 2025, in front of the Hall's 16-member Contemporary Baseball Era Committee. Former second baseman Jeff Kent was elected with 14 votes, while Bonds, Clemens, Gary Sheffield and Fernando Valenzuela each received fewer than five, according to the AP [5]. Under a new Hall rule, anyone who falls below five votes is left off the committee's next ballot, which keeps Bonds and Clemens out of the 2028 vote [5].
So the gatekeeper here is the Hall and its voters, not the White House. A presidential endorsement cannot hang a plaque on the wall. What it can do is put a long-settled question back in front of fans, and it has done exactly that.
The Rose Precedent
The President's comments came on the heels of his Thursday announcement on Truth Social of a "complete and total pardon" for Rose, the game's all-time hits leader, who died in 2024 [4]. Rose served a federal prison sentence for tax offenses decades ago, and he spent most of his life after playing on baseball's banned list for betting on games [4].
That changed in May 2025, when Commissioner Rob Manfred removed Rose from the permanently ineligible list, a decision that opened a path for the Hall to consider him again [4]. The pardon does not change the Hall's rules, but it adds the weight of the presidency to the argument that a man's punishment should one day come to an end.
Both Sides of the Argument
Plenty of baseball people will not be persuaded. For years, many Hall voters have held a firm line against stars tied to the steroid era, and the voting record shows it: two of the most dominant players of their generation have now been turned away by both the writers and a special 16-member committee [5]. To those voters, the integrity of the record book matters more than any single career, and they see that as a stand for fair play.
There is something honorable in that concern. Records mean something because the men who set them played by the same rules. But fairness cuts both ways. A standard built on suspicion rather than proof can punish the innocent along with the guilty, and Clemens has a jury verdict in his favor that most of his critics never mention.
Where It Goes From Here
Nothing about the Hall's calendar changes because of what was said Saturday. Clemens and Bonds remain off the next Contemporary Era ballot under the Hall's own rule [5], and the President promised only to look at Bonds' case, not to take any particular step [2].
Still, the conversation has shifted. Scripture tells us to judge not by appearances but with right judgment, and that is a good standard for Cooperstown, too. Weigh the evidence. Respect the verdict. Leave room for grace. A Hall of Fame that honors the game's history should be able to do all three, and this week the President made sure baseball will have to answer the question one more time.
Sources
- [1]Fox News (OutKick)Trump says Roger Clemens should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame 'immediately,' won't fully back Barry BondsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Freedom 96.9 (Reuters)Trump says he will consider championing Barry Bonds' Hall of Fame candidacyOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Local 12 (Associated Press)Pete Rose posthumously pardoned by Trump after reinstated by MLBOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]ABC7 News (Associated Press)Hall of Fame welcomes Kent, keeps Bonds, Clemens locked outOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Should athletes keep politics out of the game?
- Yes, just play
- They can speak off the field
- They have every right to speak out
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.