Yesterday on From the Bench with Margaret Callahan
Don't Take Away the Choice: Why Democrats' Push to Repeal School Vouchers Would Shortchange 110,000 Texas Students
Newly empowered Democrats in Texas and other states are moving to repeal or overhaul private school choice programs. Parent demand, long-term results and Supreme Court precedent all argue for keeping them.
Filed November 17, 2026 · 📍 Supreme Court, DC 20543
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- The Washington Post reports Democrats gained power in five of the six states that spend the most on voucher programs.
- Texas Democrats filed at least seven bills to repeal the Texas Education Freedom Accounts, which serve more than 110,000 students.
- Research on Florida's Tax Credit Scholarship found participants more likely to enroll in and graduate from college.
- Carson v. Makin bars states from excluding religious schools from programs open to other private schools.
After the Nov. 3 midterms, the fight over who decides where a child goes to school has moved to the statehouse, and families who rely on school choice are right to be worried.
The Washington Post reported this week that Democrats, who mostly oppose vouchers, gained power in five of the six states that spend the most money on voucher programs, and that the shift could reverse years of steady expansion [1]. According to the Post, Democrats are vowing to eliminate or overhaul many of those programs, including in Texas, New Hampshire, Ohio and Arizona, and a new federal tax credit for K-12 scholarships could be at risk as well [1].
Texas is the sharpest test. Houston Public Media reported that the early agenda of the incoming Democratic House majority includes repealing the state's private school voucher program, and that state Rep. Christina Morales, who leads House Democrats' campaign arm, named voucher repeal as a priority [2]. Democrats filed at least seven repeal bills in the first two days of prefiling for the 2027 session, five in the House and two in the Senate, according to the Dallas Express [3]. Senate Bill 294 from state Sen. Royce West of Dallas would end the program in September 2027, and House Bill 646 would repeal the governing law, abolish the program's fund and wind down existing accounts [3].
That is the proposal, stated fairly. Here is why it is the wrong one.
Families Have Voted, and the Results Are In
Texas lawmakers created the Texas Education Freedom Accounts in 2025 and funded the first year with $1 billion [3]. More than 110,000 Texas students are now participating, according to reporting compiled by the Dallas Express [3]. Behind that number are families who applied, waited and rearranged their lives around a school they believe fits their child.
Some of the most compelling voices belong to parents of children with special needs. More than 18,800 Texas students with disabilities are using the accounts this year, according to the state comptroller's office, Governing reported [4]. Parents interviewed by Governing described the program as a blessing that finally opened doors their children's assigned schools could not [4]. Repealing the accounts mid-stream would yank that support away from the very children public-school advocates say they want to protect.
Opponents often argue that private choice programs do not deliver. The research on long-term outcomes says otherwise. An Urban Institute evaluation of Florida's Tax Credit Scholarship, one of the country's largest and longest-running private choice programs, found that participating students were more likely to enroll in college and more likely to earn a degree than similar students who did not participate, The 74 reported [5]. The program serves children from lower-income families [5], and college completion is the kind of outcome that changes a family's trajectory for generations.
Choice also respects something money cannot measure: a parent's conviction about how a child should be formed. For many American families, that means a school where faith is woven into the day rather than checked at the door.
The Constitution Protects Faith-Based Options
The Supreme Court has spoken clearly on this point. In Carson v. Makin in 2022, the justices held that Maine violated the Free Exercise Clause by excluding religious schools from a tuition assistance program open to other private schools [6]. The Court built on its 2020 decision in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, explaining that a state need not subsidize private education, but once it does, it cannot disqualify schools solely because they are religious [6].
Precision matters here. Carson does not stop a legislature from repealing a program altogether [6]. But any overhaul that keeps public dollars flowing to secular private options while squeezing out Christian, Catholic, Jewish or other faith-based schools would run headlong into that precedent [6].
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
Parents are organizing. Moms for Liberty's Texas leader, Christie Slape, said she hopes the state Senate will protect the laws the group fought for, and the group said it will work with elected officials from both parties, the Dallas Express reported [3]. Families of children with disabilities have spoken out publicly about what they stand to lose [4].
The math in Austin also favors restraint. Republicans kept a 19-12 majority in the Texas Senate, which championed the program and can block repeal [2]. Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa, who campaigned against vouchers, cannot end the accounts by executive order; repeal requires legislation passed by both chambers [3]. Governing reported that Hinojosa could still veto the program's funding in the next state budget, though she has not said whether she would [4], which means the budget fight may matter as much as the repeal bills.
The 90th Texas Legislature convenes Jan. 12, 2027 [2].
The question before lawmakers is not complicated. When more than 110,000 Texas children are already using a program their parents chose, when the long-term evidence points toward better outcomes, and when the Supreme Court has affirmed that faith-based schools may not be singled out for exclusion, the burden of proof belongs on those who would take the choice away [3][5][6]. Election results change who holds power. They do not change what parents know about their own children.
Sources
- [1]The Washington PostPrivate school vouchers at risk in some states as Democrats gain controlOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Houston Public MediaTexas Democrats have started laying out their agenda. Where might Republicans draw the line?Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Dallas ExpressTexas Parents' Group Warns Of Wider Rollbacks As Democrats File 7 School Choice Repeal BillsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Supreme Court of the United StatesCarson v. Makin, No. 20-1088 (2022)Opens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.