Technology
'Zero Evidence' of a Link: Rubio and Intelligence Chief Clayton Trace a Week of U.S. Tech Failures to Upgrades and Patches, Not Hackers
The secretary of state says America is not under systemic attack, and the director of national intelligence says no nation-state is behind the outages that hit flights, banks, the NSA and Apple.
By RYAN MERCERStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 18, 12:20 AM · 2 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the string of technology failures that has rattled Americans for nearly a week is not the work of hackers or a foreign power, telling reporters the country is not "under systemic attack". Rubio said there is "zero evidence" tying the outages to one another, CBS News reported.
His message matched that of Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, who told CNBC on Tuesday that the disruptions were neither a cyberattack nor a coordinated effort by any nation-state. Together, the statements from the nation's top diplomat and its top intelligence official answer the theories that have spread online as one system after another has gone dark.
What the officials said
Rubio, speaking in Manila as President Trump opened his Asia trip, acknowledged that many Americans feel fearful and uncertain after the back-to-back failures, but said he wanted to be clear about what the government has found, according to CBS News. The BBC reported that Rubio rejected claims circulating online that the outages hitting Microsoft, banks and flights were connected.
Rubio also offered a possible explanation. According to The New York Times, he suggested that companies and agencies rushing to patch weaknesses in their systems, flaws that new artificial intelligence tools are now exposing, may account for the recent failures in air traffic control, banking and government networks.
Clayton made a similar case on CNBC's "Closing Bell." He said "This is not a cyber attack" and that investigators have looked at the incidents very closely. He traced the disruptions to government institutions and private companies pushing through upgrades to their computer systems at roughly the same time.
A week of failures
The outages have reached nearly every corner of daily life. CNBC's tally of the week runs from Microsoft and the Federal Aviation Administration to JPMorgan Chase, the National Security Agency and Apple, with banks and air travel among the hardest hit.
This week the NSA's classified internal network went down, though sources told NBC News there was no indication it was an attack. On Tuesday, Apple users reported trouble with the company's services as well.
Why it matters
For families who could not reach their bank accounts, travelers stuck at airports and workers locked out of email, the cause matters as much as the fix. An attack by a hostile nation would call for a very different response than a cluster of rushed upgrades and patches, and both officials said the evidence so far points away from an attack.
That is welcome news for Americans who have been on edge all week. It also puts the responsibility where it belongs: on the companies and agencies whose upgrades, by the officials' account, knocked critical systems offline, and who now owe their customers better planning before the next one.
What comes next
The officials' assessments answer the biggest question, whether the country is under attack, but each company and agency involved still has to account for its own failure. The pressure now shifts to them to explain what went wrong and show they have fixed it. Liberty Bell Report will keep following each outage and every new finding.
Sources
- BBC News: Rubio says US not 'under systemic attack' after series of tech outages (link)
- CBS News: Rubio says there's "zero evidence" recent tech outages are related (link)
- The New York Times: Cause of Recent Tech Outages Isn't Hackers, Rubio Says (link)
- CNBC: Jay Clayton on recent tech outages: 'This is not a cyber attack' (link)
- CNBC: Widespread outages hit banks, air travel, the NSA and Apple, disrupting seemingly everything (link)
- NBC News: Classified NSA network went down, but no indication it was an attack, sources say (link)
— 30 —


