‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Half the Bills, Same Promise: The Numbers Behind Mamdani's $500 Million Second-Home Tax Don't Add Up

City Hall touts more than $500 million billed, but the list of homes receiving bills was cut roughly in half, the comptroller warned of a shortfall in April, and a top target has already sold.

By DOUGLAS PARKStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 18, 7:00 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A grand prewar limestone apartment building on Park Avenue in Manhattan at blue-hour twilight, warm light in a few tall windows and many dark empty ones, a brass-trimmed revolving door, a neat stack of sealed white envelopes…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is celebrating a milestone for his tax on luxury second homes. The city has billed more than $500 million to owners of second residences worth over $5 million, the mayor said this week, according to Fox News. For a mayor who campaigned on making the wealthy pay more, it is the headline he wanted.

The fine print tells a different story. The number of homes actually receiving bills has shrunk to a fraction of what Albany and City Hall planned for, a major property owner the mayor singled out has already sold, and the city's own fiscal watchdog warned months ago that the promised revenue was unlikely to hold up.

The promise

When Mayor Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul announced the state's first pied-à-terre tax in April, the headline figure was about $500 million a year, the estimate the city comptroller's office set out to test that same month. The surcharge applies to New York City homes valued at $5 million or more that are not the owner's primary residence.

What the numbers show

The city is poised to mail pied-à-terre bills to roughly 8,000 homeowners, the New York Post reported, calling the count an embarrassing blow to the levy's revenue potential. Bloomberg Tax reported that the Department of Finance sent bills to around 8,000 properties after processing exemption requests, about 5,000 fewer than the 13,000 homes the state initially estimated would owe the tax. Fox News put the number of bills at about 7,500, down from roughly 17,000 initial notices mailed over the summer.

In other words, the city's list was cut roughly in half before the first bill went out, yet the mayor still points to more than $500 million billed. That deserves a closer look. A tax that reaches far fewer homes than planned would need much larger bills per home to raise the same sum, and a bill sent is not a dollar collected. Owners can contest their bills, and some will simply stop owning a second home in the city.

That last point is not a guess. In April, the office of New York City Comptroller Mark Levine examined the proposal and concluded that revenue could come in closer to $340 million to $380 million once rented units and changes in owner behavior were taken into account. Even before the bills were printed, the city's own number-crunchers were telling City Hall to expect less.

Behavior changes, and the city pays

Here is what behavior change looks like. Citadel founder Ken Griffin has sold his Park Avenue duplex to New York Jets owner Woody Johnson for $58 million, Bloomberg reported. Fox News reported that Mr. Griffin said the mayor's tax pushed him to double down on Miami.

Mr. Griffin can afford to pay the tax. The question is whether New York can afford to keep sending its most mobile taxpayers the message that they are a target. Wealthy second-home owners do not use many city services, yet they pay property taxes, shop in local stores, fill restaurants and employ doormen, contractors and housekeepers. Push them out and the city loses more than a surcharge.

The constitutional and common-sense answer

There is nothing unconstitutional about a state taxing expensive property, and New Yorkers are entitled to choose high taxes if they wish. But sound tax policy has old and simple rules: tax broadly, keep rates predictable, and do not build a budget on revenue that depends on people staying put after you raise their bill. A tax sold as a reliable $500 million a year, aimed at a narrow group that can leave, breaks all three.

Who is pushing back, and what comes next

The skeptics are not only on the right. The comptroller's office raised its revenue warning back in April. The New York Post's reporting on the shrinking bill count has drawn wide attention, and at least one of the city's best-known owners has already sold. A state appeals court did dismiss a lawsuit over how the surcharge was rolled out, though that case did not challenge the tax's legality, Fox News reported.

The real test comes when payments are due and the city reports how much it collected, not how much it billed. If the money falls short, the gap will land on everyone else in the city budget. New Yorkers deserve that honest number before the mayor and the governor promise to spend it.

Sources

  1. Fox News: NYC bills second-home owners over $500 million under Mamdani luxury tax (link)
  2. New York Post: Mamdani faces major pied-a-terre tax embarrassment — with NYC poised to send out just 8K bills (link)
  3. Bloomberg Tax: NYC Sends Pied-à-Terre Tax Bills to About Half Its Original List (link)
  4. Office of the New York City Comptroller: The Pied-à-Terre Tax and Its Potential Revenues (link)
  5. Bloomberg: Ken Griffin Sells NYC Duplex to Jets Owner for $58 Million (link)
  6. Fox News: Ken Griffin, target of Zohran Mamdani, has officially sold his $58 million apartment to NY Jets owner (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageNo Age, No Price Tag, No Plan to Pay: The Facts Behind…Turn the pageFour in Five Americans Want Photo ID at the Polls. Rick…