‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Old Enough to Vote, Serve and Sit on a Jury: Why Two Liberty Students Are Right to Challenge Virginia's Under-21 Gun Ban

Richmond's new law bars adults 18 to 20 from buying a handgun. The Constitution, the founders' own militia laws and a federal appeals court point the other way.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 18, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic image of the white-columned Virginia State Capitol in Richmond at dusk, an American flag and the Virginia flag lifting in the breeze, in the foreground on a wooden courthouse table an open pocket copy…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Natasha Rousseau is 18. Melody Boyer is 19. Both are students at Liberty University in Lynchburg, both are adults in the eyes of the law, and both are now suing the Commonwealth of Virginia for the right to buy a handgun, WSLS reported. Their case is a test of a simple question: can a state treat a grown citizen as a full adult for every purpose except the one the Constitution names outright?

What Virginia did

This spring, Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed a sweeping package of gun legislation that reshaped the state's firearm laws, the Virginia Mercury reported. Among the changes, the age to buy a handgun or what the law calls an "assault firearm" rose from 18 to 21, with exceptions for people in military or law enforcement training. Supporters in the Democratic-led General Assembly framed the package as a public-safety measure.

The two students are challenging that age limit, along with Virginia's universal background check rules for private sales, according to WSLS. They are suing State Police Superintendent Jeffrey Katz, whose office enforces the law, and the attorney general's office is defending him, WSET reported. The Virginia Citizens Defense League is backing the suit, and Gun Owners of America has joined it. The students ask a judge to block enforcement and declare the restrictions unconstitutional.

What the Constitution and history say

The Second Amendment protects "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms." It does not say "the people over 21." In 2025, a unanimous panel of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals applied the Supreme Court's history-based test from the Bruen decision and struck down the federal ban on handgun sales by licensed dealers to adults under 21, holding that 18-to-20-year-olds are part of the people the amendment protects, the ABA Journal reported. The court leaned heavily on the founding era, when federal and state militia laws required young men to bear arms beginning at 18. The generation that ratified the Bill of Rights expected 18-year-olds to show up with their own musket. It did not make them wait three years to buy one.

The rest of our law agrees that 18 is the age of adulthood. The Twenty-Sixth Amendment guarantees 18-year-olds the vote. An 18-year-old can enlist, deploy and fight for this country. She can sign a contract, marry, serve on a jury that decides whether a fellow citizen goes to prison, and be tried as an adult herself. Virginia trusts these young women with every one of those duties. It is hard to explain why it will not trust them to buy a pistol to protect themselves walking back to a dorm at night.

Virginia's own Bill of Rights says the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. That language belongs to Virginians, and it was written by a state that gave the nation George Mason and James Madison.

The courts are split, and that matters

Defenders of the law will note, fairly, that not every court agrees. The Eleventh Circuit upheld Florida's ban on retail gun sales to adults under 21, and this summer the Supreme Court declined to take up a group of challenges to under-21 restrictions, leaving that split in place, the Washington Times reported. Justice Clarence Thomas said he would have granted review in a challenge to the federal handgun-sale ban. When the highest court leaves a constitutional question this unsettled, state courts and state constitutions become the front line.

That is exactly where Rousseau and Boyer have taken their fight. Their case is in Lynchburg Circuit Court, WSET reported, and AmmoLand reported the students argue that the right to keep and bear arms necessarily protects the right to acquire a firearm. A right you cannot exercise until 21 is, for three years of adult life, no right at all.

Common sense, not fear

No one disputes that Virginia wants to reduce gun violence. Every parent wants that. But the answer is to prosecute violent criminals, keep guns from people who are legally barred from having them, and support families and schools. Disarming law-abiding young women who have never committed a crime does none of those things. It simply tells them that their safety must wait.

What comes next

A hearing that was expected this week has been moved to early December because of a scheduling conflict for the judge, WSLS reported. Whatever the outcome in Lynchburg, the case is likely headed for appeal. Two college students have taken on the state with the Constitution in hand. They deserve a fair hearing, and the Commonwealth owes them a better answer than telling them to wait until they turn 21.

Sources

  1. WSLS 10: Liberty University students sue Virginia over new gun restrictions for young adults (link)
  2. WSET: Two Liberty University students challenge Virginia's gun restrictions (link)
  3. Virginia Mercury: Spanberger amends, signs sweeping gun legislation reshaping Virginia's firearm laws (link)
  4. ABA Journal: 5th Circuit overrules itself and finds law banning handgun sales to youths under age 21 is unconstitutional (link)
  5. The Washington Times: Supreme Court won't hear challenges to age limits on gun purchasing (link)
  6. AmmoLand: Virginia Students Sue Over Under-21 Gun Purchase Ban and Private-Sale Restrictions (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pagePushbackTurn the pageSanders Puts Medicare for All on a Four-Year Clock. The 154…