‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

No Age, No Price Tag, No Plan to Pay: The Facts Behind Jeffries' Call to Lower the Medicare Age

The incoming House majority's leader wants a lower Medicare age, new dental, vision and hearing benefits and coverage for every child, while the program's own trustees say its hospital fund runs dry in 2033.

By SAMUEL ADEYEMIStaff Correspondent · WISCONSIN · Nov 18, 9:30 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A worn kitchen table in an older couple's home at early morning, a blank red, white and blue insurance-style card with no writing, reading glasses, a weekly pill organizer and a neat stack of unopened envelopes, a window…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, on track to lead the House when Democrats take the majority in January, laid out the first big health care promise of the new Congress on Tuesday. He said Democrats should lower the age when Americans qualify for Medicare, add dental, vision and hearing benefits, and guarantee coverage for every child, NBC News reported.

What he did not say is how old Americans would have to be, how much it would cost, or who would pay for it. NBC News reported that Mr. Jeffries did not name a specific eligibility age, and The Epoch Times reported that he did not say whether the children's coverage would run through Medicare. A promise with no age, no price tag and no funding plan is not a policy yet. It is a slogan, and seniors who already depend on Medicare deserve better than that.

What is being proposed

The Jeffries outline did not come out of nowhere. Becker's Payer Issues reported that Sen. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin introduced a bill earlier this month to open Medicare at age 50, and that Sen. Andy Kim of New Jersey introduced a children's coverage bill in July. Sen. Bernie Sanders has called lowering the eligibility age an "immediate first step" toward his Medicare for All plan, The Epoch Times noted. In other words, the incoming leader of the House is endorsing the opening move of a single-payer agenda.

What the numbers say

The best guide to the cost comes from the Congressional Budget Office, Congress's own nonpartisan scorekeeper. In a 2022 analysis, CBO estimated that lowering the Medicare age to 60 would add $155 billion to federal deficits over six years and put 7.3 million more Americans into Medicare Parts A and B. CBO also flagged costs it did not include, such as the money needed to run the expanded program.

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget explained how that number works: about $390 billion in new Medicare spending, partly offset by roughly $230 billion in lower spending on other federal health programs as people moved out of them. The group estimated the cost of the policy's first full ten years at about $250 billion. And that is for age 60 alone, before adding dental, vision and hearing coverage for tens of millions of people, and before covering every child in the country. A lower age such as 55 or 50 would cost more.

A program already running short

Here is the part that should worry every family. Medicare cannot afford the promises it has already made. The program's trustees projected this year that Medicare's hospital insurance trust fund will run dry in 2033, one quarter earlier than they projected last year, KFF reported. Once that happens, incoming revenue would cover only about 89 percent of scheduled hospital benefits.

Seven years is not a long time. A 58-year-old worker today will be 65 when that date arrives. Adding millions of younger enrollees and costly new benefits to a program that is already headed for automatic cuts is like adding new passengers to a lifeboat that is taking on water. Compassion for the sick is a Christian duty, and so is honesty about what a promise costs. Making new promises to new groups while the money for current retirees runs short is not compassion. It hands the bill to today's seniors.

The Constitution puts the bill on the House

The Constitution gives the House a special role here. Article I says all bills for raising revenue must start in the House of Representatives. If Mr. Jeffries becomes Speaker, his chamber will not only be able to propose a Medicare expansion, it will be responsible for writing the taxes or the borrowing that pay for it. Voters should ask him to show that math before the first bill is filed.

Who is pushing back, and what comes next

The warnings are coming from numbers, not partisans. The CBO's estimate and the trustees' report both point to the same conclusion: expanding Medicare costs more than it saves, and the program's existing commitments are already underfunded. Budget watchdogs such as the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget have spelled out the price.

Any expansion would still have to pass both chambers and be signed by the President. Watch for whether House Democrats name an age, release a cost estimate and propose a way to pay for it, and whether they first offer a plan to keep Medicare solvent for the seniors who already count on it. Fixing the program Americans have should come before promising a bigger one.

Sources

  1. NBC News: Jeffries endorses lowering Medicare age, adding benefits and universal coverage for kids (link)
  2. The Epoch Times: Jeffries Says Democrats Should Lower Medicare Age, Add Dental, Vision, Hearing Coverage (link)
  3. Becker's Payer Issues: Jeffries backs lowering Medicare age, universal coverage for children (link)
  4. Congressional Budget Office: Budgetary Effects of a Policy That Would Lower the Age of Eligibility for Medicare to 60 (link)
  5. Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget: Medicare at 60 Costs $155 Billion, According to CBO (link)
  6. KFF: Key Facts About Medicare Spending Trends and Projections from the 2026 Medicare Trustees Report (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageExpose for the Sake of Exposure? The Supreme Court Has…Turn the pageHalf the Bills, Same Promise: The Numbers Behind Mamdani's…