‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Four in Five Americans Want Photo ID at the Polls. Rick Scott Is Making One Last Push Before Democrats Take the Senate

As Sen. Rick Scott pushes to pass voter ID before the Senate changes hands, the case against it rests on claims that the public, most states and even most Democratic voters have already rejected.

By SOPHIA REYESStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 18, 3:00 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic scene of a small-town American polling place inside a church fellowship hall at dawn, a row of voting booths with red, white and blue bunting, a poll worker's table with a sign-in book and a driver's…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., is making one more push for voter ID before Democrats take control of the Senate in January. He said this week that the budget reconciliation process, which needs only a simple majority, is Republicans' only realistic shot at passing it, Just the News reported.

Senate Democrats have made their position just as clear. Democratic leader Chuck Schumer has called the Republican SAVE Act a "radical voter suppression bill" on the Senate floor, according to Senate Democrats' own published remarks. Critics argue that the bill's documentation rules could keep eligible citizens from voting, and FactCheck.org noted that the National Conference of State Legislatures considers the bill's requirements stricter than most existing state voter ID laws.

That is a fair summary of the other side. Here is why the facts point the other way.

The voters have already decided

Asking voters to show identification is not a fringe idea. It is one of the most popular election policies in America. In an October 2024 Gallup poll, 84% of U.S. adults supported requiring all voters to show photo identification at their polling place, and 83% supported requiring proof of citizenship for people registering to vote for the first time.

Support crosses party lines. Gallup found that about two-thirds of Democrats backed photo ID, along with the overwhelming majority of independents and Republicans. NBC News reported that Americans broadly support the photo ID requirement in the SAVE America Act even as Democratic lawmakers reject it.

When a policy wins the backing of four out of five Americans, including most of the opposing party's own voters, calling it suppression is not an argument. It is a label.

Most states already do it

Voter ID is not an experiment. FactCheck.org reported that 36 states already have some form of voter ID law. Americans in those states have been showing identification at the polls for years, and they keep voting.

Common sense tells the same story. Americans show ID to board a plane, pick up a prescription, open a bank account, buy cold medicine or check into a hotel. Choosing the leaders who will write the nation's laws is at least as important as any of those. A simple ID check protects every legal voter's ballot from being canceled out by one that should not have been cast.

The Constitution leaves room for both states and Congress

The Constitution's Elections Clause, in Article I, Section 4, gives state legislatures the power to set the times, places and manner of congressional elections, while allowing Congress to make or alter those rules. That is why states have led the way on voter ID, and why Congress has the authority to set a national floor for federal elections if it chooses to.

Supporters of the SAVE America Act are using exactly that power. Opponents are free to argue about the details, such as which documents count and how states should help citizens who lack them. Those are reasonable questions, and they can be solved with free IDs and simple paperwork. They are not a reason to reject the principle that only eligible citizens should vote.

Democrats' own record

The vote tally tells its own story. Senate Democrats blocked a Republican amendment to require photo identification to vote, even after saying they support voter ID, Fox News reported. When the question has come to the Senate floor, the answer from Democratic leaders has been no.

Voters notice that gap between words and votes. They are right to ask why a measure most of them support cannot get a fair hearing.

What comes next

Scott says reconciliation is the path forward because it cannot be blocked by a filibuster. Reconciliation comes with strict rules about what can be included, a hurdle supporters will still have to clear. Time is short. Once the new Democratic majority is sworn in, the bill's chances in this Congress fade.

Whatever happens in Washington, the states will keep leading. The 36 states with ID laws on the books show that a simple, fair rule can work. The voters have spoken on this question again and again. It is time for their representatives to listen.

Sources

  1. Just the News: Sen. Rick Scott says budget reconciliation incentive is Republicans' only shot to pass voter ID (link)
  2. Senate Democrats: Leader Schumer Floor Remarks On Republicans' Radical Voter Suppression Bill, The SAVE Act (link)
  3. FactCheck.org: Competing Claims on SAVE America Act Disenfranchising Voters (link)
  4. Gallup: Americans Endorse Both Early Voting and Voter Verification (link)
  5. NBC News: Americans support SAVE America Act's photo ID requirement, but Democrats reject it (link)
  6. Fox News: Senate Democrats block voter ID amendment despite saying they support it (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageHalf the Bills, Same Promise: The Numbers Behind Mamdani's…Turn the pageA Hand Up, Not a Trap: Why Medicaid's Work Rule Deserves a…