‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

A Hand Up, Not a Trap: Why Medicaid's Work Rule Deserves a Fair Chance Before Democrats Try to Repeal It

Critics warn of disaster and Democrats promise repeal. But the rule asks able-bodied adults for 80 hours a month of work, school or service, most Americans back the idea, and the administration has built in time to get it right.

By SAMUEL ADEYEMIStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 18, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic scene of a small-town American main street at early morning, a lit community job-training center window beside a church food pantry with volunteers' aprons hanging by the door, a lunch pail and work…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Medicaid's new work requirement is weeks from taking effect, and the warnings are getting louder. Mother Jones has cautioned that the looming changes could end in disaster for people who lose coverage. The Congressional Budget Office has estimated the requirement would leave 5.3 million more people uninsured by 2034, Healthcare Dive reported. And Democratic leaders, who will control Congress in January, plan to push to repeal the Medicaid changes President Trump signed in 2025, Forbes reported.

Those concerns deserve a straight answer. Here it is: the rule asks something reasonable of people who are able to give it, it protects a program that millions of vulnerable Americans depend on, and the administration has already shown it is willing to adjust to make it work.

What the rule actually requires

The requirement applies to adults covered under Medicaid expansion. To keep coverage, they must spend at least 80 hours a month working, going to school, volunteering or in job training, or qualify for an exemption, according to Mother Jones and the Healthcare Financial Management Association.

Eighty hours a month is about 20 hours a week. It can be met by a part-time job, a community college schedule or volunteering at a church food pantry. This is not a demand that every adult hold a full-time job. It is an expectation that people who can contribute to their communities do so, in exchange for health coverage paid for by their neighbors.

The administration is building in time

Critics describe the rollout as a cliff. The facts show otherwise. On Nov. 13, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services gave states an optional six-month grace period, allowing them to keep otherwise eligible people enrolled through June 30, 2027, while they work out the system, Fierce Healthcare reported. States have until Dec. 11 to tell CMS whether they will use it.

Even Mother Jones acknowledged that the administration paused the coverage losses for six months. That is not the behavior of officials trying to throw people off the rolls. It is the behavior of officials trying to get a big change right.

Most Americans agree with the principle

The idea that able-bodied adults should work, look for work or prepare for work in exchange for benefits is not fringe. A KFF poll found that 62 percent of Americans favored requiring nearly all adults to work or be looking for work to get Medicaid, The New Republic reported. In fairness, the same polling found support dropped when people were told about possible coverage losses or that most recipients already work. But the core principle commands broad agreement, across party lines.

That makes sense. Americans are generous, and they want a safety net for children, the disabled, the elderly and people who fall on hard times. They also believe that work brings dignity, structure and a path out of poverty, and that a program meant as a hand up should not become a permanent way of life for those who can do more.

Protecting the program for those who need it most

Medicaid's costs have grown for years, and every dollar spent on adults who could be working is a dollar not available for disabled children, nursing-home residents and low-income seniors. The CBO estimated the requirement would save $317 billion in federal spending, Healthcare Dive reported. That money stays in the pockets of the taxpayers who fund the program, many of whom work hard jobs without generous benefits of their own.

The critics' number, 5.3 million more uninsured, deserves attention. Some of those losses will come from paperwork, and states should make reporting simple, using data they already have whenever possible. That is an argument for doing the rule well, not for scrapping it.

Who is pushing back, and what comes next

The administration is not backing away. CMS has kept the January start date in law while offering states the flexibility to phase in enforcement, Fierce Healthcare reported. That is the right balance: hold the line on the principle, and give states room to get the details right.

Democrats' repeal effort faces long odds. A repeal bill would likely meet a presidential veto that Democrats lack the votes to override, Forbes reported. That leaves the next year as a test: whether states can make the rule work smoothly, and whether more Americans move from benefits into jobs, classrooms and service.

The rule starts in January, with the grace period available through June 30, 2027. Rather than repeal it before it has a chance to work, Congress should let the states show what a fair, simple work requirement can do. Work is not a punishment. For millions of Americans, it is the first step toward a better life.

Sources

  1. Mother Jones: Looming Medicaid Cuts Could End in Disaster. The Trump Administration Just Paused Them for Six Months. (link)
  2. Forbes: Democrats Won Congress. Here's What Can, And Can't, Happen To Medicaid Cuts (link)
  3. Fierce Healthcare: Trump administration delays enforcement of Medicaid work requirements for six months (link)
  4. Healthcare Dive: Brookings researchers slam assumptions in CMS work requirements rule (link)
  5. The New Republic: Americans Like Medicaid, But They Also Like Work Requirements (link)
  6. Healthcare Financial Management Association: CMS allows states to delay enforcement of Medicaid work requirements until July (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageFour in Five Americans Want Photo ID at the Polls. Rick…Turn the pageFund Results, Not Failure: Why Moving L.A.'s Federal…