Markets
Thursday, November 19, 2026Updated 11:42 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Immigration & Border Security

Tonight on Border Watch with Cole Brennan

Ninth Circuit Keeps Venezuela's TPS Termination in Place for Now: What the Freeze Does and What Comes Next

A federal appeals court extended its pause on a San Francisco judge's order reviving deportation protections for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans, and the administration pulled its Supreme Court request while vowing to return if it loses.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: The James R. Browning U.S. Courthouse in San Francisco, its ornate Beaux-Arts granite facade and arched windows glowing in warm late-afternoon light under a clear blue sky, an American flag lifting in the breeze on a pole out…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Part of our continuing coverage: A Third Trip to the Justices: Administration Says a San Francisco Judge Defied Two Rulings on Venezuelan Migrant Protections

Key points

  • Late Wednesday the Ninth Circuit extended its freeze on Judge Edward Chen's order restoring Venezuelan TPS until seven days after it issues a full ruling.
  • The Justice Department withdrew its emergency Supreme Court application Thursday but said it will return immediately if the appeals court rules against it.
  • Former TPS holders remain without valid TPS work permits and can still be detained and deported while the case continues.
  • The appeals court must now apply the Supreme Court's June 2026 Mullin v. Doe ruling, which sharply limited judicial review of TPS terminations.

A federal appeals court has kept the Trump administration's termination of Temporary Protected Status for Venezuelans in force, at least until it rules on the merits of the case. Late Wednesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit extended a temporary freeze on a lower-court order that would have restored the protections, and that freeze will now last until seven days after the court issues a full decision, the Associated Press reported [1]. The order came only hours after the administration asked the Supreme Court to step in [1][2].

By Thursday, the Justice Department had withdrawn that emergency request, SCOTUSblog reported, while making clear it would return to the justices if the appeals court rules against it [4]. Al Jazeera described the result as letting the administration move ahead, for now, with ending the deportation protections, while noting that the underlying legal challenges are not over [3].

For hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans, the practical bottom line is unchanged: the status they once held remains terminated [1][2]. Published estimates of the number of people affected vary, so this explainer uses the broad description found in the wire coverage rather than a single figure.

What TPS is, and who decides

Congress created Temporary Protected Status in 1990 [6]. The law lets the Homeland Security secretary designate a foreign country when armed conflict, an environmental disaster or other extraordinary and temporary conditions make it unsafe for its nationals to go home. People from a designated country who are already in the United States are shielded from removal and may be authorized to work [6]. Designations run for set periods and must be reviewed before they lapse, at which point the secretary decides whether to extend or end them [6].

Congress wrote a limit on the courts into the same statute. The law says there is no judicial review of the secretary's determinations on designating, extending or terminating a country's status, a provision found at 8 U.S.C. 1254a(b)(5)(A), the Congressional Research Service explained [5]. How much room that clause leaves judges has become the central question in the Venezuela fight.

The name states the purpose: a bridge for people who cannot safely go home for a season, with the judgment about when that season ends assigned to the secretary rather than the courts [5][6].

How Venezuela's status rose and fell

Venezuela was first designated for TPS in 2021, during the Biden administration, and was designated a second time in 2023, which opened the program to more recent arrivals [6]. In January 2025, in the final days of that administration, then-Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas extended the 2023 designation for 18 months, through Oct. 2, 2026 [6].

Shortly after President Trump returned to office, Secretary Kristi Noem vacated that extension and then terminated the 2023 designation, with the termination taking effect in April 2025 [6]. The National TPS Alliance, an organization of TPS holders, sued in San Francisco [3][6]. U.S. District Judge Edward Chen postponed the termination that spring, and in May 2025 the Supreme Court put his order on hold [6]. In September 2025, Chen issued a final ruling setting aside both the vacatur and the termination under the Administrative Procedure Act, and that fall the Supreme Court again paused his ruling as it applied to Venezuela [4][6].

In January 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel affirmed Chen, concluding that Noem had exceeded her authority under the TPS statute when she moved to undo an extension her predecessor had already granted [6].

Then the ground rules changed. In June 2026, in Mullin v. Doe, a case brought by Haitian and Syrian TPS holders, the justices ruled 6-3 that the statute bars courts from hearing non-constitutional challenges to a secretary's decision to end a country's TPS [5]. Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the majority. Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, dissented, arguing that the bar covers the secretary's final judgment about country conditions but not the procedural steps that come first, such as consulting other agencies [5]. The Congressional Research Service observed that the ruling appears to place most DHS decisions about designating, extending or ending TPS beyond the reach of judges [5].

At the administration's request, the Supreme Court in early October vacated the Ninth Circuit's Venezuela decision and returned the case to that court to reconsider in light of Mullin [1][2].

Why the fight returned this week

Chen's September 2025 order was poised to take effect once a temporary Ninth Circuit freeze expired on Friday, Nov. 20 [1][4]. On Wednesday, Solicitor General D. John Sauer asked the justices to block it, warning that the Department of Homeland Security would otherwise have to revive TPS for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans after a nineteen-month gap, SCOTUSblog reported [4]. Government lawyers put the number of Venezuelans in immigration custody at about 1,800 and said roughly 330 of them face deportation, according to the AP [1].

Within hours, the Ninth Circuit extended its freeze until seven days after it decides the case [1][4]. The Justice Department then pulled its Supreme Court application. In a letter to the court, Sauer wrote that if the Ninth Circuit enters an adverse judgment, "we intend to immediately return to this Court for additional relief" [4].

The order is a pause, not a verdict. It does not decide whether Noem acted lawfully or end the legal challenges to the administration's moves on TPS [1][3].

What it means for Venezuelans here now

For former TPS holders, the freeze keeps things where they have stood for most of the past year and a half [4]. Work permits issued under Venezuela's TPS remain invalid, and the government may continue to detain and deport people who once held the status, the AP reported [1].

That is a hard reality for many families, and it deserves to be said plainly. These are people who were permitted to live and work here legally under a program the federal government itself created and extended [6]. The order does not, on its own, decide any individual's case, but it leaves those families without the protection they once counted on while the courts finish their work [1][3].

The arguments on each side

The administration's case rests on the statute and on the Supreme Court's recent decisions. Congress made the program temporary and gave the secretary, not judges, the call on when a designation ends, and in Mullin a majority of the justices held that the review bar means what it says [5]. Twice in 2025 the Supreme Court allowed the Venezuela termination to take effect while the litigation played out [4][6], and the justices have since drawn tight limits around judicial review of such decisions, the Daily Wire noted [2]. In the government's telling, reviving the program after a nineteen-month gap would also reach the roughly 1,800 Venezuelans now in immigration custody [1][4].

The National TPS Alliance and the Venezuelans it represents see a different question. Their challenge has focused on a narrower point: that the statute lets a secretary extend or end a designation at its scheduled review, but gives no power to cancel an extension a predecessor already granted. The Ninth Circuit panel accepted that argument in January and concluded the review bar did not stop courts from deciding it [6]. Chen, for his part, found the vacatur and termination unlawful under the Administrative Procedure Act [6]. Whether that reasoning can survive Mullin is exactly what the appeals court must now decide [1][2].

What comes next

The next step belongs to the Ninth Circuit, which must issue a full ruling on remand that applies the Supreme Court's June decision [1][2]. If the panel again sides with the Venezuelan plaintiffs, the seven-day cushion built into Wednesday's order gives the government time to return to the justices before anything takes effect, and Sauer has said it will do so immediately [4]. If the panel sides with the government, the termination stands, and the plaintiffs would have to decide whether to seek further review.

The Supreme Court will likely have the last word. This week's filing was the administration's third emergency trip to the justices over Venezuela's protected status, after the two 2025 orders that let the termination proceed [4][6].

The rule of law points in a clear direction here. Congress wrote a temporary program, handed the timing to the executive branch and told courts to stay out of that judgment, and the Supreme Court has now enforced that choice [5]. A nation that keeps its word to its own laws can also keep faith with the stranger by handling these cases with dignity and due process. If Americans want a lasting answer for Venezuelans who have built lives here, that answer has to come from Congress, written in law, rather than from a judge's order that rises and falls with each appeal.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Would you support an immigration deal with the new Democratic Congress?

  1. Only if the border stays secure and there's no amnesty
  2. Yes, it's time to fix the system
  3. No deals at all
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.