Tonight on Street Watch with Elijah Carter
The Palisades Fire Case Goes Back to a Jury: Closing Arguments Set as a Second Panel Weighs Whether Jonathan Rinderknecht Started It
Testimony ended Tuesday in the federal arson retrial over the fire that devastated Pacific Palisades. Prosecutors point to location data; the defense says New Year's fireworks are the likelier cause.
Filed November 18, 2026 · 📍 Los Angeles, CA 90012
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Closing arguments were set for Wednesday in the federal retrial of Jonathan Rinderknecht.
- He has pleaded not guilty to two arson counts alleging he set the Lachman Fire, which prosecutors say rekindled into the Palisades Fire.
- His first jury deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal in June, leading to a mistrial.
- The retrial was briefly halted this week over a dispute about evidence the defense did not share.
Nearly two years after the fire that devastated Pacific Palisades, the man accused of setting it is again waiting on a jury. Closing arguments were scheduled for Wednesday in the federal arson retrial of Jonathan Rinderknecht, NBC Los Angeles reported [1], after testimony wrapped up on Tuesday [2].
The charges
Rinderknecht has pleaded not guilty to two federal arson counts under a revised indictment that accuses him of intentionally setting the Lachman Fire on New Year's Day 2025, according to Yo! Venice [2]. Prosecutors contend that the small Lachman Fire, which crews put out, later rekindled into the Palisades Fire a week afterward [2], one of the most destructive wildfires in Los Angeles history.
Rinderknecht, a former Pacific Palisades resident, was arrested in October 2025, months after the fire, the AP has reported [4]. He has maintained his innocence through both trials.
The retrial follows a first trial that ended without a verdict. In June, that jury deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal, and U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang declared a mistrial [2][5]. Prosecutors then went back to a grand jury, which returned a new indictment that dropped one of the original charges and modified the remaining two counts, the Associated Press reported [4]. Judge Hwang has barred the attorneys from mentioning the first trial in front of the new jury [4].
What each side argues
Prosecutors in the first trial asked jurors to convict based on location data they described as placing Rinderknecht at the scene of the Lachman Fire, and they have rejected the defense's fireworks theory, saying there is no physical evidence to support it, NBC Los Angeles and Yo! Venice reported [1][2].
Defense attorney Steve Haney has argued that prosecutors cannot conclusively prove the Lachman Fire was set on purpose, or that its embers sparked the much larger fire a week later [2]. In the first trial, CNN reported, the defense undercut the prosecution by pressing those gaps and pointing to holiday fireworks as a more likely cause [5].
A fight over evidence
The retrial has not been smooth. Proceedings were halted this week after prosecutors accused the defense of violating court rules by failing to share documents, expert reports and other materials before trial, NBC Los Angeles reported [3]. Judge Hwang paused the case to review the claims before allowing it to move toward closing arguments [3][2].
Why it matters
For the families of Pacific Palisades, this trial is about more than one defendant. The fire killed 12 people and destroyed thousands of homes and businesses, the AP has reported [4], wiping out schools, churches and a lifetime of memories for many neighbors. Many residents are still waiting to rebuild. They want answers, and they want accountability if a crime was committed.
That is exactly why the process matters. In America, a man is presumed innocent until the government proves its case beyond a reasonable doubt to a unanimous jury. A first jury could not agree. A second jury now has the case. Whatever it decides, the verdict must rest on the evidence presented in court, not on public anger or political pressure. Equal justice under law means the same standard for every defendant, no matter how terrible the loss.
The case has also raised hard questions for state and local leaders about how a smoldering fire could reignite a week later in the hills above the city, and whether crews and equipment were in place when the winds arrived. Those questions are separate from the criminal case, and Palisades families deserve full answers to them as well.
What comes next
Once closing arguments end, the jury will begin deliberating. If it convicts, Rinderknecht faces sentencing in federal court; if it acquits, he goes free on these charges; and if it deadlocks again, prosecutors would have to decide whether to try a third time. We will report the verdict as soon as it comes.
Sources
- [1]NBC Los AngelesClosing arguments scheduled in Palisades Fire arson re-trialOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]NBC Los AngelesPalisades arson fire re-trial on hold for judge to review prosecution's evidence discovery claimsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Associated Press via GV WireAccused Arsonist in Los Angeles' Deadly Palisades Fire Returns for Federal RetrialOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
Should the death penalty stay on the books for the worst crimes?
- Yes, for the worst murders
- Only with absolute proof like DNA
- No, life without parole is enough
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.