Tonight on Home Front with Carlos Mendoza
Treatment Is Not a Detour: Why HUD's Push to Fund Recovery, Not Just Rent, Deserves Another Day in Court
A federal judge in Rhode Island blocked HUD's plan to steer $1.3 billion toward transitional housing and services. A decade of rising street homelessness explains why the administration wants to try something different.
Filed November 21, 2026 · 📍 Washington, DC 20001
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Judge Mary McElroy ruled HUD exceeded its authority in reshaping a $4 billion homelessness program.
- HUD wanted $1.3 billion set aside for transitional housing and supportive services.
- HUD's own count found a record 771,480 people homeless on one night in January 2024.
- HUD says it reserves the right to appeal; grants must be awarded by Dec. 31.
A federal judge in Providence has stopped, for now, the Trump administration's effort to change how Washington spends its largest pot of homelessness money. U.S. District Judge Mary McElroy ruled on Friday that the Department of Housing and Urban Development overstepped its authority when it tried to overhaul the roughly $4 billion Continuum of Care program [1].
HUD had planned to set aside $1.3 billion of the more than $4 billion Congress appropriated for fiscal 2026 for transitional housing and supportive-services grants, moving money away from long-term permanent housing [1]. The judge found the department went beyond what the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act allows [1]. The New York Times described the decision as a blow to an effort to shift aid from housing subsidies toward treatment for mental illness and addiction [2].
The ruling orders HUD to let applicants amend and resubmit their applications by Dec. 1 and to award the money by Dec. 31 [3]. The challenge was brought by 22 mostly Democratic-led states, the District of Columbia and a coalition of housing and homelessness advocacy groups, who praised the decision; an appeals court had lifted an earlier order before this renewed round [1].
What the Ruling Decides, and What It Leaves Open
To be fair to the court, Friday's decision is about the limits of an agency's power under a statute Congress wrote, not a verdict on whether treatment works. That matters, because the political reaction has treated the ruling as proof that the administration's approach is wrong. It proves nothing of the kind. It says HUD must follow the law as written, and that if the law is going to change, Congress is the place to change it.
The advocates' concern deserves a hearing too. They argue that pulling dollars from permanent housing could put vulnerable people back on the street. That is a serious worry. But it has to be weighed against what the current approach has delivered.
The Numbers Behind the Push for Change
HUD's own most recent national count is sobering. On a single night in January 2024, 771,480 people were homeless in America, the highest number ever recorded and an 18 percent jump from the year before [4]. The number of people counted as chronically homeless reached 152,585, up from 77,486 at its low point in 2016 [4]. Homelessness among families with children rose 39 percent in a single year [4].
Not everything moved in the wrong direction. Veteran homelessness fell nearly 8 percent, to 32,882 [4]. That is worth celebrating, and it shows that focused, accountable effort can make a difference.
The overall trend is why the President signed an executive order in July 2025 directing agencies, to the extent the law permits, to end support for "housing first" policies and to prioritize treatment, recovery and accountability [5]. HUD has described its reforms as an effort to promote self-sufficiency rather than government dependency [6]. A HUD spokesperson told Reuters, in substance, that the department is finished pouring taxpayer money into a status quo that has repeatedly failed the most vulnerable Americans [1].
Common sense agrees. A man fighting addiction or untreated mental illness needs more than a key and a lease. He needs a bed in a program that helps him get sober, a counselor who checks on him, and a path to work. Christians know this pattern well. In the parable, the Good Samaritan did not simply drop the wounded traveler at the inn; he paid for his care and promised to come back. Compassion that asks nothing of anyone is not the fullest kind of compassion.
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
HUD has already fought earlier rulings in this long-running case and appealed a prior decision that blocked its overhaul [6]. HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the department reserves the right to appeal again and argued the ruling disrupts $4 billion in grants just as awards were due [3].
The calendar is tight. Applicants have until Dec. 1 to resubmit, and the money must go out by Dec. 31 [3]. Cities, shelters and recovery programs across the country are waiting on those dollars, and nobody wants a funding gap in the middle of winter.
The lasting answer, though, belongs to Congress. McKinney-Vento is a law, and lawmakers can rewrite it to give treatment-first programs, transitional housing and recovery services a fair share of federal money. The question for both parties is simple: after record homelessness on the old approach, are they willing to let communities try something that asks more and may deliver more? The families sleeping in cars this Thanksgiving deserve an honest answer.
Sources
- [1]U.S. News & World Report (Reuters)US Judge Rejects Trump Administration's Homelessness Program RevampOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]The White HouseEnding Crime and Disorder on America's StreetsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]U.S. Department of Housing and Urban DevelopmentHUD Appeals Judicial Decision to Shift Homelessness ParadigmOpens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.