Last night on The Vance Edge with Sienna Vance
Given a Real Choice, Americans Pick Fixing ICE Over Scrapping It: The Facts Behind the 'Abolish ICE' Push
An MS NOW host says abolishing Immigration and Customs Enforcement has gone mainstream. The polling, the law and the agency's own record tell a more complicated story, and point to reform, not abolition.
Filed November 21, 2026 · 📍 Boston, MA 02108
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- MS NOW's Ali Velshi said abolishing ICE has become very mainstream, Breitbart reported.
- In an NBC News poll with three options, only 29% chose abolishing ICE.
- The latest Civiqs tracking shows slightly more Americans opposing abolition than supporting it.
- ICE removed 271,484 people in fiscal 2024 and helped 1,783 child exploitation victims.
Ali Velshi has a theory about where the country is headed. Guest-hosting MS NOW's "All In" on Friday, the anchor told his audience that abolishing Immigration and Customs Enforcement, a position he said Republicans call radical, has become very mainstream, not only among Democrats but among Americans, according to a clip published by Breitbart [1]. He was speaking with Rep.-elect Dan Koh of Massachusetts, and Velshi argued that the agency has become so tied to violence and danger in the public mind that something else must take its place [1].
That is a big claim, and it deserves a fair answer. The short version: Americans are frustrated with how immigration enforcement has been carried out, and the polls show it. But when they are given a real choice, most do not want to tear the agency down. They want it fixed.
What the Polls Actually Say
Start with the numbers that help Velshi's case, because they are real. In an Economist/YouGov survey taken in late February and early March, half of Americans said they somewhat or strongly supported abolishing ICE, a new high for that poll [4]. Even among Republicans, support reached 23 percent, though 68 percent of Republicans remained opposed [4].
Now look at what happens when the question gets more honest. An NBC News poll in February offered three choices instead of two. Just 29 percent said ICE should be abolished. Forty-three percent said it should be reformed, and another 29 percent said it should continue in its current form [2]. Put those last two groups together and more than seven in 10 Americans want ICE to keep existing, whether as it is or improved.
And the yes-or-no numbers have cooled. The latest Civiqs tracking, updated through late October, shows 46 percent supporting abolition and 48 percent opposed [3]. A country split down the middle on a two-option question, with abolition losing badly when reform is on the table, is not a country that has embraced getting rid of the agency.
What ICE Does That Abolition Would Erase
The slogan also skips past what the agency actually does. In fiscal year 2024, ICE removed 271,484 people from the country, including 237 known or suspected terrorists, and more than 30 percent of those removed had criminal histories [5]. Its investigative arm, Homeland Security Investigations, made 32,608 arrests that year, and ICE reported identifying or assisting 1,783 victims of child exploitation and 818 victims of human trafficking [5].
Those are not abstractions. They are children pulled out of abuse, trafficking victims freed and dangerous people removed from American neighborhoods.
Fair critics make a real point here too. The Associated Press has reported that as agents were shifted toward deportations, seizures of guns and federal drug arrests dropped sharply [6]. That is a fair argument about priorities and resources. But it is an argument for staffing and managing the agency well, not for erasing the people who do this work.
The Law and the Constitution
ICE is not a campaign promise that can be undone with a speech. Congress built the modern immigration enforcement system in law, and the agency took its current form in 2003 [5]. The Constitution gives Congress the power to set the rules of naturalization and gives the President the duty to take care that the laws be faithfully executed. As long as immigration laws are on the books, someone has to enforce them. Abolishing ICE without a serious replacement would not end enforcement debates; it would simply leave the laws Congress passed without anyone to carry them out.
That is why even many critics of current tactics talk about reform, oversight and training rather than abolition [2].
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
The strongest pushback is coming from the public itself. Given the choice, most Americans pick fixing over scrapping [2], and the latest tracking shows the abolition idea slipping below 50 percent [3].
A new Congress arrives in January, and lawmakers will have plenty of room to argue about budgets, oversight and how agents do their jobs. That is healthy. Scripture calls on rulers to be a terror not to good works but to evil, and a nation that loves both mercy and order should want an immigration system that does both well.
Mainstream is a strong word. The mainstream position, judging by the polls, is to keep the agency and make it better.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]CiviqsAbolish ICEOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]U.S. Immigration and Customs EnforcementICE Annual Report, Fiscal Year 2024Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]AOL (The Associated Press)Guns seized and federal drug arrests drop dramatically as Trump team turns agents' attention to deportationsOpens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.