Last night on The Bottom Line with Douglas Park
California Voters Just Said No to Soaking the Rich. A 2028 Rerun on Income Taxes Ignores Why
The state's doctors' association chief is exploring a plan to overhaul the income tax after Prop 40 failed, but California already has the nation's highest top rate and leans on its top 1% for nearly half its income tax.
Filed November 17, 2026 · 📍 Sacramento, CA 95814
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: Even California Said No: Why Voters Rejected the Billionaire Tax, and Why the Facts Back Them
Key points
- California Medical Association CEO Dustin Corcoran is exploring a 2028 ballot plan to overhaul the state income tax.
- Voters rejected Prop 40's one-time 5% billionaire tax 52.8% to 47.2%, with Gov. Newsom opposed.
- California's top income tax rate of 13.3% is the nation's highest and reaches 14.4% on wages over $1 million.
- The top 1% paid almost 45% of the state's personal income tax in 2019, making the budget volatile.
Barely a week after California voters were reported to have turned down a tax on billionaires, the next plan to collect more from the state's top earners is already taking shape. The chief executive of the California Medical Association, Dustin Corcoran, is exploring a 2028 ballot initiative that would overhaul the state's income tax system rather than tax wealth directly, possibly by redrawing the tax brackets, the New York Post reported [1]. The idea is early, with no proposed rates or revenue estimates, according to the Post [1].
Corcoran opposed this year's billionaire tax. But he told the Post he does not see its defeat as "an endorsement of wealth inequality or the status quo" [1]. He is not alone in planning a second round: the head of the SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West union has vowed to come back in 2028 with another billionaire tax, the Post reported [1].
Supporters will argue, fairly, that California voters do not oppose every tax on the wealthy. CalMatters described this month's results as mixed signals on measures to tax the rich [6]. But the facts on this particular question point one way.
Voters Already Answered
Proposition 40 would have required the roughly 200 Californians worth more than $1 billion to pay a one-time 5% tax on their net worth. Voters rejected it 52.8% to 47.2%, according to the Associated Press count reported by GV Wire [2]. At the same time, Proposition 42, a countermeasure to block future wealth taxes, was leading 51.6% to 48.4% in early returns [2].
That happened in one of the most Democratic states in the country, and over the objection of the state's own Democratic Party, which endorsed the tax even though Gov. Gavin Newsom opposed it, Straight Arrow News reported [3]. When a measure loses in California with the governor of California against it, the message is not subtle.
Moving the target from wealth to income does not change the underlying math. It just moves the fight to a tax the state already leans on harder than any other.
California Already Has the Highest Rate in the Country
California's top personal income tax rate is 13.3%, the highest of any state, and it can reach 14.4% on wage income over $1 million once a payroll tax is added, according to the California Chamber of Commerce [4]. Compare that with Texas, Florida, Tennessee and Nevada, which have no state income tax on wages at all.
The state's dependence on a small group of taxpayers is already extreme. The top 1% of earners paid almost 45% of all personal income taxes in 2019, the Chamber reported [4]. A Hoover Institution analysis put the top 1% share at roughly 40% to 50% in recent years [5].
That concentration is a risk, not a cushion. Top earners' income rises and falls with the stock market and asset sales, so a budget that rests on them booms in good years and craters in bad ones, the Hoover analysis warned [5]. Asking the same small group to carry even more of the load makes Sacramento's budget more fragile, not more secure.
The Common Sense Problem
The deeper problem is that people and capital can move, and state lines are easy to cross. A family that owns a business, or a doctor building a practice, can choose to do it in Austin or Miami instead of Los Angeles. Every new rate increase on top of the nation's highest rate makes that choice easier.
The irony of this particular proposal is hard to miss. It is being floated by the head of the state's doctors' association. California's physicians are among the very earners who would feel a higher top bracket, and the state needs more of them, not fewer. Any plan that makes it harder to recruit and keep doctors in California deserves a hard look from the people it is meant to help.
There is also a matter of respecting the voters. Californians weighed a tax on the state's richest residents, heard both sides and said no. Lining up a rerun before the votes are even certified tells those voters their answer was only a rough draft.
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
The pushback is coming from the voters themselves, who rejected Proposition 40 and were leaning toward Proposition 42's limit on future wealth taxes in early returns [2], and from a Democratic governor who refused to back the billionaire tax [3].
Nothing has been filed yet for 2028, and Corcoran's idea has no rates attached [1]. That gives Californians two years to ask the right question. The state does not have a revenue problem caused by the rich paying too little. It has a spending and stability problem that comes from relying on them too much. Fix that, and the next ballot fight may not be necessary at all.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Straight Arrow NewsCalifornia Democrats ignore Newsom, endorse billionaire tax measureOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]CalChamber2025 Business Issues: Income TaxesOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Hoover InstitutionHow Much Longer Will the Top 1 Percent Save California's Budget?Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.