‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

World News

Land for NATO, a New Order for Europe and a Summit in China: The Hard Questions in the Ukraine Peace Push

A week after Abu Dhabi, Washington is testing a Donbas-for-NATO trade, Moscow wants a new European security framework, and the drones keep flying. Here is what each side wants before Thursday's meeting in Shenzhen.

By DOMINIC KANEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 16, 10:40 AM · 6 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic scene of a long, empty negotiating table in a grand, dimly lit hall at dusk, three high-backed chairs on one side and two on the other; a large unlabeled topographic relief map of rolling eastern…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Three days before President Trump sits down with China's Xi Jinping and Russia's Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, the effort to end the war in Ukraine has plenty of ideas on the table and almost no agreements.

In the space of a week, U.S.-brokered talks in Abu Dhabi produced a prisoner deal and little else. American negotiators then asked Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy whether his country would leave the Donbas if it were allowed into NATO. And overnight into Monday, Russia's defense ministry said Ukraine launched 1,336 drones at targets in Russia and occupied Crimea, including a strike on the bridge to the peninsula.

Each of those developments has been reported on its own. Taken together, they show the outline of a bargain, the price each side is asking, and the questions that will decide whether any of it becomes a peace that lasts.

What Abu Dhabi Settled, and What It Didn't

The two days of talks on Nov. 10 and 11 ended with an agreement in principle on a large prisoner exchange, which Zelenskyy said could involve roughly 1,000 to 1,500 people on each side, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty reported. Zelenskyy pressed for an all-for-all swap. For families who have waited years for a son or husband to come home, that matters more than any communique.

On the core of the war, the talks moved very little. Russia's chief negotiator, Vladimir Medinsky, reportedly ruled out territorial exchanges, and Moscow turned down Ukraine's proposal for a ceasefire on strikes against energy targets, RFE/RL reported. Paul Saunders, a former State Department adviser, called the progress largely symbolic and suggested Moscow sees the talks as a way to keep Washington engaged while it bets on a war of attrition, according to the outlet.

The real shift came on the agenda. RFE/RL reported that Washington is pushing to widen the talks to cover Europe's security architecture and to bring European governments into the room. That was a turn Kyiv and European capitals see as important, and it set up everything that followed.

The Land-for-NATO Gambit

Days later, Zelenskyy disclosed that American negotiators had asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from the Donbas if it joined NATO, and he said it was the first time the question had come up, CBS News reported.

Zelenskyy did not say yes. He said he would put any such exchange to the Ukrainian people only if it came as part of a broader package, including specific guarantees from NATO and the European Union, a strong Ukrainian military and financial support for a set period, according to CBS News. He said guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5 would be the absolute minimum, and that Kyiv would not simply surrender its territory.

The idea turns the logic of the war on its head. Moscow has spent years insisting that Ukraine must never join the Western alliance. A trade that hands Russia the rest of the Donbas while bringing Ukraine into NATO would give Putin the land he has fought for and Ukraine the protection he went to war to prevent. Nothing Russia's negotiators said in Abu Dhabi suggests the Kremlin is ready to accept the second half of that deal.

Moscow's Bigger Ask

Russia's demands reach well past the front line. RFE/RL described Moscow as seeking a broader security bargain with the West rather than a narrow settlement over territory. Al Jazeera reported Monday that, after Abu Dhabi, the United States encouraged Ukraine and its backers to agree to a Russian demand for a new security framework for Europe, a demand many Europeans see as an attempt to weaken NATO.

That is the heart of the matter. A peace that ends the shooting in Ukraine but loosens America's alliances in Europe would not be a victory for anyone but the man who started the war. Europe signaled where it stands on Monday by adding another round of sanctions on Russia, aimed at dozens of banks and financial firms, Al Jazeera reported. The European Union says it wants a ceasefire first, followed by a lasting peace agreement.

Negotiating Under Fire

While diplomats talk, both armies are trying to change the facts on the ground. Russia's defense ministry said Ukraine launched 1,336 drones overnight into Monday, and Moscow's mayor, Sergei Sobyanin, said about 600 of them were headed for the capital region, France 24 reported. Crimea's Russian-installed governor, Sergei Aksyonov, said Ukraine struck the bridge across the Kerch Strait and that traffic was limited. Those figures come from Russian officials and could not be independently confirmed.

France 24 noted that the barrage came only days before the Shenzhen summit. Russian strikes on Ukrainian towns continued at the same time, Al Jazeera reported.

The pattern is plain. Ukraine is using its long-range drones to raise the cost of the war for Moscow, while Russia refuses to pause its campaign against Ukraine's power grid as winter sets in. Each side believes force will strengthen its hand at the table. That is why a ceasefire has proved so hard to reach: neither side wants to stop until it believes the terms are as good as they will get.

Who Speaks for Washington, and What Happens in Shenzhen

The American effort runs on two tracks. Special envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner carried the Abu Dhabi talks to Putin in Moscow and then to Zelenskyy in Dublin. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has set the public frame. On Nov. 9, Rubio said Washington had not settled on a final plan for postwar security guarantees, that any arrangement must be something Russia agrees to if it is to work, and he did not rule out a formal treaty, the Kyiv Independent reported.

Those two tracks now meet in China. The White House confirmed on Nov. 13 that the president will join Putin and Xi for the first summit of the three leaders, with nuclear arms reductions and Iran on the agenda and Ukraine left off it, bne IntelliNews reported. A senior U.S. official said no agreement is expected.

Moscow tells a different story. Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said Putin and Mr. Trump plan to keep discussing a Ukraine settlement in Shenzhen in a separate meeting, according to bne IntelliNews. Ukraine's foreign minister, Andrii Sybiha, warned that a three-way meeting of that kind would only encourage Putin to keep fighting. Neither Ukraine nor the European governments will be at the table.

The Hard Questions

Scripture calls the peacemakers blessed, and Americans of every political stripe should want this effort to succeed. But a lasting peace has to answer questions that a summit photo cannot.

First, is the land-for-NATO idea a real offer or a probe? Rubio's insistence that guarantees must be acceptable to Russia sits uneasily beside an offer of the one thing Moscow has always rejected. If Washington is testing the Kremlin, Americans deserve to know what answer would count as failure.

Second, who would honor the guarantee? NATO membership means Article 5, a promise that an attack on Ukraine is an attack on the United States. Zelenskyy calls that the minimum, and Rubio has not ruled out a treaty. Under the Constitution, a treaty needs the consent of two-thirds of the Senate. A commitment of that weight should be debated openly in Congress, not settled in a side room.

Third, what does Europe give up? If the price of peace in Ukraine is a new security framework written to Moscow's taste, the bill falls on Poland, the Baltic states and every ally that relies on NATO's word.

Fourth, will Shenzhen stay on nuclear arms, as the White House says, or drift into Ukraine, as the Kremlin says? A deal about Ukraine made without Ukraine in the room would be fragile from the first day.

Finally, can either side be trusted to stop shooting? The prisoner swap agreed in Abu Dhabi is the simplest test. If Moscow delivers it, that is a sign of good faith. If it stalls, it tells Washington what to expect from everything else.

President Trump has made clear that he wants the killing to end. The surest path there is the one that worked in the Cold War: negotiate from strength, keep faith with allies, and never confuse a pause in the fighting with a just and lasting peace.

Sources

  1. CBS News: U.S. floated exchanging Ukrainian territory for NATO membership, Zelenskyy says (link)
  2. Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty: Abu Dhabi Talks Advance Diplomacy, Not Peace, As Russia Seeks Broader Security Bargain (link)
  3. France 24: Ukraine hits Russia's Crimea bridge in 1,300-drone barrage (link)
  4. Al Jazeera: Russian attacks kill three in Ukraine, EU accuses Moscow of prolonging war (link)
  5. bne IntelliNews: US confirms first Putin-Trump-Xi summit in China, with Ukraine off trilateral agenda (link)
  6. Kyiv Independent: Security guarantees for Ukraine must also be acceptable to Russia, Rubio says (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageShowing Up for Allies, Standing Up for Travelers: The…Turn the pageJailed Imran Khan Asks Pakistan's Top Judges for Urgent…