‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

Three Rings and a Short, Brilliant Career: Buster Posey Leads 14 Newcomers on the 2027 Hall of Fame Ballot

The Giants' catcher turned team president headlines a 27-name ballot that also includes Jon Lester, Jake Arrieta, Andrew Miller and Pablo Sandoval, with results due Jan. 19.

By CONNOR MAGUIREStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 16, 10:05 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic scene inside a quiet small-town baseball museum gallery at dusk: a long wood-paneled wall lined with blank, untitled bronze plaques under warm spotlights, a well-worn leather catcher's mitt and mask…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Cooperstown season is officially open, and the San Francisco Giants' dynasty is front and center.

The Baseball Writers' Association of America released its 2027 Hall of Fame ballot on Monday, and it lists 27 players: 14 first-time candidates and 13 holdovers. Buster Posey, the catcher who anchored three World Series champions in San Francisco, leads the newcomers.

Joining him on the ballot for the first time are pitchers Jon Lester, Jake Arrieta and Andrew Miller, his old Giants teammate Pablo Sandoval, and Jay Bruce, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Wade Davis, Brett Gardner, Ervin Santana, Kyle Seager, Joakim Soria and Ryan Zimmerman, MLB.com reported.

Ballots must be postmarked by Dec. 31, and the results will be announced Jan. 19. A player needs 75 percent of the vote to be elected, and he can stay on the ballot for up to 10 years as long as he keeps drawing at least five percent.

Posey's Case: Peak Versus Longevity

Posey's résumé reads like a highlight reel. He was the 2010 National League Rookie of the Year, the 2012 NL Most Valuable Player and a three-time World Series champion, all with the Giants, and MLB.com lists him at 45.0 career wins above replacement. MLB.com called his the strongest case of any first-timer in this class.

The question voters will wrestle with is time. Posey played for the Giants from 2009 to 2021 and retired at 34, and the Associated Press noted earlier this year that a couple of injury-plagued seasons and that early exit left his career totals short of the usual Hall of Fame standard. Yardbarker pointed out that the 20 catchers already in the Hall averaged careers of 17.2 seasons, well beyond Posey's 12, and predicted he probably won't get in on the first try but should get there within his 10 years on the ballot.

These days Posey is the Giants' president of baseball operations, trying to build the next winner from the front office.

The Rest of the Newcomers

Lester won World Series titles with the Red Sox in 2007 and 2013 and was the MVP of the NL Championship Series for the 2016 Cubs, and MLB.com lists him at 43.4 WAR. Arrieta won the 2015 NL Cy Young Award and led the league in wins that season, and Miller was the American League Reliever of the Year in 2015 and the 2016 ALCS MVP.

Sandoval, the switch-hitting third baseman beloved in San Francisco as the Panda, arrives on the ballot just after announcing his retirement. Some writers doubt he will draw the five percent needed to stay on next year's ballot, but his appearance alongside Posey is a reminder of how much that Giants core accomplished together.

The Holdovers Still Waiting

Among the 13 returning players, Chase Utley has the most momentum. He received 59.1 percent of the vote last year, the only holdover to top 50 percent, and he is on the ballot for the fourth time, CBS Sports reported. Andy Pettitte drew 48.5 percent, Félix Hernández got 46.1 percent and Alex Rodriguez received 40.0 percent. CBS Sports noted that Pettitte's past use of performance-enhancing drugs will likely keep his ceiling below the 75 percent mark.

There is a second Giants storyline this winter. Former Giants manager Bruce Bochy and Dusty Baker headline the eight-person Contemporary Era committee ballot, and CBS San Francisco reported that both are heavily favored to be elected. If that happens, Posey's old manager could beat him to Cooperstown.

Maguire's Take: Greatness Isn't Measured Only in Years

I'll say it plainly: Buster Posey belongs in the Hall of Fame, and I hope the writers don't make him wait.

Catcher is the most punishing position on the field. Posey squatted behind the plate, called games for a pitching staff that won three championships, and still collected a Rookie of the Year award and an MVP. Very few players in any era can say that.

Longevity is a fair thing to weigh. But the Hall has never asked a man to hang on past his time just to pad his totals. Posey walked away at 34 on his own terms, and in an age when so many players chase one more contract, there is something admirable about a man who knew what mattered most to him and went home.

As for the rest of the ballot, Utley's climb to nearly 60 percent puts him on a real path, and I expect him to keep gaining. Lester and Arrieta were big-game pitchers on championship teams, and they deserve a long look before voters move on.

The envelope opens Jan. 19. Here's hoping the Giants' catcher gets the call on the first ring.

Sources

  1. MLB.com: Posey, Lester headline 14 newcomers to Hall of Fame ballot (link)
  2. BBWAA: Fourteen newcomers join 2027 Hall of Fame ballot (link)
  3. CBS San Francisco: Giants legends Posey, Sandoval among newcomers to 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot (link)
  4. CBS Sports: Who will be on 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot? Buster Posey headlines newcomers (link)
  5. Yardbarker: Reasons for, against Buster Posey's Hall of Fame case (link)
  6. Fox Sports (Associated Press): Buster Posey takes center stage among the newcomers for next year's Hall of Fame ballot (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageSportsTurn the pageA November Measuring Stick in Tucson: Unbeaten No. 3 UConn…