‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

First in Line for an Ace: The Mets Make Their In-Person Pitch to Tarik Skubal as the Dodgers Wait Their Turn

New York's meeting with baseball's top free agent reportedly went very well, with five more clubs still to come and a Dec. 1 labor deadline looming.

By CONNOR MAGUIREStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 17, 8:05 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic still life on the pitcher's mound of an empty generic ballpark at dawn: a brand-new white baseball with red stitching resting on the clay beside a plain brown leather glove, a fountain pen lying on a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The New York Mets have made their pitch to the best pitcher on the market. Now they wait to see whether Tarik Skubal says yes.

The Mets held an in-person meeting with the two-time Cy Young Award winner on Monday in Orange County, California, according to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, as relayed by ClutchPoints. Heyman reported that the session "went very well," with the expectation that the left-hander will sign somewhere before a possible lockout. Bleacher Report noted that it is not known whether the Mets put a formal offer on the table.

New York may have been the first of Skubal's finalists to get in the room, but it will not be the last. Heyman reported that the Los Angeles Dodgers, San Diego Padres, Toronto Blue Jays and two unnamed clubs are also expected to get meetings, putting the field at six. The Blue Jays were set to sit down with Skubal's representatives this week, RotoBaller reported, citing Heyman, and the Dodgers are expected to follow later in the week, according to Bleacher Report. Whether going first gives the Mets any edge is unclear.

Why the Mets Want Him So Badly

The need in Queens is obvious. The Mets' rotation is thin heading into 2027, with only Nolan McLean and Christian Scott viewed as locks, ClutchPoints reported. At last week's general managers meetings, president of baseball operations David Stearns made no secret of the plan to add arms. "There's no question we're going to add to that group," Stearns said, according to MLB.com. ESPN reporters described the Mets on Friday as the industry favorites to land Skubal, ClutchPoints reported.

The arm they are chasing is worth the fuss. From 2024 through 2026, Skubal won 43 games over 546 innings with a 2.42 ERA and led the majors in wins above replacement by FanGraphs' measure, ESPN reported. The Dodgers acquired him from the Detroit Tigers before the August trade deadline and got a five-day exclusive negotiating window when free agency opened, ESPN reported.

The price will be steep. Some executives told ESPN they believe Skubal could approach a $400 million deal, though others were skeptical he will get that high.

The Labor Clock

All of this is happening on a deadline. Baseball's collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, and a lockout is widely expected to follow, the Associated Press reported. Skubal's agent, Scott Boras, reminded reporters that 27 contracts worth more than $1.4 billion were announced the day before the last lockout in 2021. If history repeats itself, the next two weeks could be among the busiest of the winter.

That gives the Mets' meeting a little extra weight. Clubs that make a strong first impression now may not get a second chance once the doors close.

Maguire's Take: Bold Is Good, Patience Is Better

I like what the Mets are doing here. They have the need, and Stearns has said plainly that the rotation needs help. Going after the best pitcher alive, in person and early, is how a contender should act.

But the Mets also need to keep their heads. Skubal will hear five more pitches, including one from a Dodgers club that already knows him well. The worst thing New York could do is bid against itself out of fear. Smart organizations set a price, make their case and trust the player to weigh the whole picture: the city, the clubhouse, the chance to win and the people he will be working with every day.

There is a bigger point for baseball fans, too. A winter of huge contracts is fun, but a winter of locked doors is not. The players and owners both have a duty to the families who fill the seats and buy the jerseys. Here is hoping the same urgency that has six teams lining up for Skubal carries over to the bargaining table before Dec. 1.

What Comes Next

The rest of Skubal's meetings are expected to unfold this week, with the Dodgers and Blue Jays among those still to come. Heyman's reporting suggests a decision could land before the labor deadline. For a Mets team built to win now, the next two weeks may decide whether 2027 opens with an ace at the top of the rotation or with another long winter of what-ifs.

Sources

  1. ClutchPoints: Mets news: Tarik Skubal has in-person meeting with NY amid high-profile free agency (link)
  2. Bleacher Report: New Tarik Skubal Rumors Reveal How Mets Meeting Went Amid Dodgers Buzz in MLB Free Agency (link)
  3. MLB.com: Mets to meet with Skubal next week as Stearns says 'no question' team will add pitching (link)
  4. ESPN: What's next for Tarik Skubal, MLB's top free agent of 2026-27 offseason (link)
  5. Associated Press: When Scott Boras' phone rings, agent quips: 'Just another owner begging to meet with Skubal' (link)
  6. RotoBaller: Blue Jays to Meet With Tarik Skubal's Representatives (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageStandards and Second Chances: Kyle Hamilton Holds the 4-6…Turn the pageBack to the Dunes: Two-Time F1 Champion Fernando Alonso…