‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Three Justices Wanted to Hear It: Why Doctors Are Still Saying No to California's Implicit-Bias Mandate

The Supreme Court let California's continuing-education rule stand, but the research on bias training and the Court's own free-speech precedent keep the fight alive.

By SAMUEL ADEYEMIStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 16, 3:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic view of the U.S. Supreme Court building's white marble columns and broad steps at golden hour in Washington, D.C. In the foreground, a physician's stethoscope rests on a closed medical textbook atop…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a physician's challenge to California's requirement that continuing medical education courses include lessons on implicit bias, leaving the state's rule in place. The challenge fell one vote short. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch wanted to take the case, but four votes are needed to grant review.

Turning a case away is not the same as ruling that California is right. For the doctor who brought this case, the three justices who sided with her and lawmakers in at least one other state, the questions it raised are far from settled.

What California Requires, and What the Courts Said

The 2019 law requires that the continuing education courses doctors take to keep their licenses contain curriculum on the understanding of implicit bias. Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist, and the physicians' group Do No Harm sued, represented free of charge by the Pacific Legal Foundation. They argued that the mandate compels private instructors to deliver a message the state chose, in violation of the First Amendment.

California defended the rule as part of its oversight of medicine. The state told the justices the lower rulings were consistent with Supreme Court precedent and that taking the case would "imperil" medical regulations meant to protect patient health. The lower courts agreed with the state. The Ninth Circuit held that California regulates the practice of medicine so heavily that the courses count as government speech, which falls outside First Amendment scrutiny.

Thomas, joined by Alito, saw it differently. In his dissent he called the state-credited courses a "cloak for compelled speech". Gorsuch said he would have granted the petition.

What the Evidence and the Constitution Say

Start with the science. A 2019 meta-analysis led by researchers Patrick Forscher and Calvin Lai pooled nearly 500 studies of efforts to change implicit bias. It found that interventions can shift scores on implicit-bias measures, though not dramatically. When the researchers focused on 63 studies that looked at whether a change in bias led to a change in behavior, they found no evidence of a causal link. Put plainly, the best-known body of research does not show that moving the needle on a bias test changes how a person acts.

That matters in medicine. Continuing education time is limited, and every hour spent on a concept with an unproven effect on behavior is an hour not spent on new treatments, safer procedures or the latest research. Patients are entitled to ask whether a mandate that touches every covered course is the best use of their doctors' training.

Then there is the Constitution. In 2018, in NIFLA v. Becerra, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that California's requirement that pro-life pregnancy centers post state-scripted notices likely violated the First Amendment. Writing for the majority, Thomas rejected the idea that speech by licensed professionals is a separate category entitled to weaker protection, and the Court reversed the Ninth Circuit.

That precedent stands for a simple principle: earning a professional license does not mean surrendering the freedom to decide what you will say. The government-speech theory adopted by the lower courts reaches a different result by a different road, treating speech as the state's own once the state regulates a field heavily enough. Thomas's dissent rejects exactly that move.

There is also the matter of conscience. Treating every patient with equal dignity is a calling many doctors hold as a matter of faith, rooted in the conviction that each person is made in the image of God. A physician can share that commitment completely and still doubt a particular theory about bias and how to fix it. A free country lets that doctor teach her own course and make her own case, rather than requiring her to repeat the state's.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

The fight is not confined to California's courts. In December 2025, the Michigan House approved a bill to remove implicit-bias training as a requirement for health care licenses in that state.

The challengers say they are not finished. Caleb Trotter, a senior attorney at the Pacific Legal Foundation, said the group is "encouraged that there is support on the Court to review this issue". He said the foundation will keep working so doctors do not have to give up their free speech rights to keep their licenses.

For now, the Ninth Circuit's ruling stands, and California's requirement remains in force. But three justices have signaled that they see a serious First Amendment problem, and a future challenge would need only one more vote to be heard. Until then, the burden should be on the state to show that its mandate actually helps patients. On the evidence so far, it has not made that case.

Sources

  1. The Hill: Supreme Court won't review implicit bias mandate for California medical courses (link)
  2. Courthouse News Service: Conservative justices push for crackdown on implicit bias training (link)
  3. Pacific Legal Foundation: Supreme Court won't hear doctor's challenge to California's compelled-speech mandate; three justices disagree (link)
  4. ScienceDaily: Change the bias, change the behavior? Maybe not (link)
  5. ABA Journal: Required notices at crisis pregnancy centers likely violate the First Amendment, Supreme Court rules (link)
  6. Michigan Public: House adopts bill to scrub bias training from Michigan health care licensing (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageCOP31's Draft Demands a Faster Exit From Fossil Fuels. The…Turn the pageDemocratic States Want the Carbon Capture Mandate Back. The…