‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

The Science Has a Say in Girls' Sports. The Seattle Times Should Let Its Readers Hear It

A Nov. 8 story told Washington readers there is no serious evidence that trans women have an athletic edge. Peer-reviewed research says otherwise, and female athletes are now asking a court to let them defend the law voters passed.

By ETHAN CALLOWAYStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON STATE · Nov 17, 11:31 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic scene of an empty outdoor high school running track in the Pacific Northwest at dawn, misty evergreen forest and distant snow-capped mountain behind the stadium, starting blocks set in a lane in the…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Washington voters settled a question this month that many of their leaders would rather not answer, approving Initiative 638 to keep girls' and women's sports for female athletes. In its Nov. 8 report on the measure, The Seattle Times told readers there is no serious scientific evidence that transgender girls or women are better athletes, according to accounts of the article. The paper added that while a few trans girls have won at the high school level, none of the trans women who have competed at elite college or professional levels have dominated their sport.

More than a week later, Fox News' OutKick reported, the paper still had not corrected or clarified that line, even after commentator Jason Rantz and journalist Benjamin Ryan pointed to published studies showing lasting advantages.

A newspaper is free to report the arguments on both sides of a ballot fight. It is not free to tell readers a body of evidence does not exist when it does.

What the research shows

Start with a study of the United States Air Force. Researchers examined the fitness test records of service members who transitioned and found that after two years of testosterone suppression, trans women still ran a mile and a half 12 percent faster than the women they served with, according to the paper published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine. To be fair to the full record, the same study found that the gaps in push-ups and sit-ups had closed by the two-year mark. But running speed is the foundation of almost every field and court sport, and a 12 percent edge is enormous at any level.

A widely cited 2021 review in the journal Sports Medicine reached a similar conclusion. After about a year of testosterone suppression, the authors found, muscle mass and strength fell by only around 5 percent, leaving most of the advantage built during male puberty in place. Height and the bone structure built during puberty do not reverse with medication.

That is what the honest scientific debate looks like: researchers arguing over how much advantage remains, in which sports, and for how long. It is not a debate over whether there is any evidence at all.

Who is pushing back

The voters were first. Now the female athletes themselves are stepping forward. On November 13, Alliance Defending Freedom asked King County Superior Court to let Female Athletes United join the lawsuit over the initiative as a defendant, OutKick reported. The suit was brought by the Washington Education Association, the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington and allied groups, who want the measure blocked.

Attorney General Nick Brown's office has said it will defend the law, but ADF argues the state cannot fully represent the athletes' interests. The group also intends to argue that the U.S. Constitution and Title IX require female-only teams, not merely allow them. Declarations from five members of the group say some of them would leave school teams for club sports if the initiative is blocked, ADF said.

Those young women are the ones the Times story left out. They trained for years for a fair shot at a roster spot, a podium or a scholarship, and they are asking for nothing more than the protections Title IX was written to give them.

A word about fairness and dignity

Every student deserves respect and a place to play, and nothing in the science above is a judgment on anyone's worth. Jesus reminded his listeners that from the beginning God made them male and female (Mark 10:6). The body matters, and in sports the body is the whole contest. Protecting a girls' category is not an insult to anyone. It is the reason the category exists.

What comes next

The court must now decide whether Female Athletes United may join the case. Under Washington's constitution, a voter-approved initiative takes effect 30 days after the election, which puts I-638's start in early December unless a judge blocks it. And The Seattle Times still has an easy fix available: tell readers what the studies say.

Sources

  1. Yahoo News: The Seattle Times says there's 'no serious scientific evidence' trans athletes have an advantage over women (link)
  2. Fox News (OutKick): Seattle Times still hasn't corrected claim that trans women have no athletic advantage despite studies (link)
  3. British Journal of Sports Medicine: Effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance in transwomen and transmen: implications for sporting organisations and legislators (link)
  4. Sports Medicine: Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage (link)
  5. Alliance Defending Freedom: WA female athletes stand up for girls, voters, new state law protecting women's sports (link)
  6. Fox News (OutKick): ADF seeks to defend Washington girls' sports measure, argues state cannot fully represent female athletes (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageDue Process Runs Both Ways: Why Lisa Cook Should Make Her…Turn the pageReparations at the Top of the List? The Voters, the Record…