‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

End the Electoral College, Abolish ICE? A Celebrity's Wish List Runs Into Articles II, V and I of the Constitution

An actor's viral video lays out demands for the Democrats who take over Congress in January. The Framers built in checks that a slogan can't skip, and they protect both parties.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 15, 8:30 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: An aged parchment constitution document resting on a polished wooden desk under warm museum light, a quill pen and brass inkwell beside it, the white dome of the U.S. Capitol visible through a tall arched window at golden…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Actor John Leguizamo has a to-do list for the Democrats who take control of Congress in January, and he posted it on Instagram. According to Fox News, the video calls on the new majority to abolish U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, shut down immigration detention centers and end the Electoral College, among other items in a sweeping list. Breitbart reported that the actor, whom it described as a Democratic Socialist, also wants Democrats to protect abortion rights and transgender Americans once their majority takes hold on Jan. 3.

Mr. Leguizamo is a gifted performer, and he is entitled to his politics. His list also captures what a loud wing of the activist left now expects from the party it helped elect. That makes it worth answering seriously, with the document every member of the new Congress will swear an oath to support.

The Electoral College Is in the Constitution

The way Americans choose a president is written into Article II of the Constitution. No Congress can repeal it by majority vote, however large that majority is. Changing it requires a constitutional amendment, and Article V sets a deliberately high bar: two-thirds of both the House and the Senate to propose one, or a convention called by two-thirds of the states, followed by ratification in three-fourths of the states. That means 38 states would have to agree.

The Framers made it hard on purpose. They wanted the basic rules of self-government changed only when the whole country reaches a broad consensus, not whenever one election produces a new set of winners. The Electoral College makes candidates compete state by state, which is why small states, farm country and the industrial Midwest still get the attention of anyone who wants to be president.

ICE Enforces Laws Congress Wrote

ICE exists because federal law created it, and undoing a law takes a new one. Under Article I, Section 7, every bill must go to the president, and if he vetoes it, Congress needs two-thirds of each chamber to override. A bill to abolish ICE would land on the desk of a president who has made immigration enforcement a centerpiece of his term.

It is worth remembering what the agency actually does. The Department of Homeland Security reported that ICE carried out the most arrests and deportations in its history in the 2026 fiscal year. Those officers are enforcing immigration statutes that Congress itself passed. Abolishing the agency would not repeal a single one of those laws. It would simply leave them unenforced, and a law no one enforces is an invitation to break it.

Abortion Is Back With the People

On abortion, the Supreme Court has already settled who decides. In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, the Court held that the Constitution does not confer a right to abortion and moved to "return the issue of abortion to the people's elected representatives". The debate now happens where it belongs, in state legislatures and at the ballot box, where both sides can make their case to their neighbors. Congress can debate national legislation, too, but any such bill runs into the same veto and override math as an ICE bill.

The same is true of the hard questions about children and gender. They are being argued in statehouses, courtrooms and school board meetings across the country, which is exactly how a free people should settle disagreements this deep.

The Real Path Forward

None of this means the new majority is powerless. Starting Jan. 3, Democrats will control the agenda in both chambers, with the power to hold hearings, write spending bills and send legislation to the president. But the Constitution gives every sweeping change a longer road than a viral video does: persuade the country, win the votes and live with the checks the Framers built.

Those checks protect everyone. A future Republican majority cannot rewrite the presidency on a whim either. Americans who want ICE to keep doing its job, and who want presidents chosen the way the Constitution prescribes, can take comfort that the system is working as designed. They should also make their voices heard to the new Congress, as plainly as Mr. Leguizamo made his.

Sources

  1. Fox News: 'The Odyssey' actor John Leguizamo demands Democrats 'abolish ICE,' shut down detention centers (link)
  2. Breitbart: 'The Odyssey' Star John Leguizamo Demands Democrats Abolish ICE, Shut Down Detention Centers, Protect Abortion Rights and Transgender Americans (link)
  3. National Archives: The Constitution of the United States: A Transcription (link)
  4. U.S. Department of Homeland Security: ICE Breaks Records in Fiscal Year 2026, With Most Arrests and Deportations in Agency's History (link)
  5. Supreme Court of the United States: Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageBillions From Abroad, Names Kept Secret: Why the Fight to…Turn the pageTwo Patients, Not One: The Facts Don't Back the Claim That…