‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Democrats Are Weighing New Taxes for a Trillion-Dollar Agenda. A $2 Trillion Deficit Says Start Somewhere Else

As the incoming majority debates how to pay for undoing Medicaid reforms, reviving Obamacare credits and rolling back tariffs, the government's own ledger and the history of 'tax the rich' promises point toward restraint.

By DOUGLAS PARKStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 16, 9:30 AM · 4 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic early-morning view of the U.S. Capitol dome in Washington seen through a tall window, with a closed leather-bound ledger, a vintage brass adding machine and a small stack of coins on a polished…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Democrats won the midterms promising to bring down the cost of living. Less than two weeks later, the conversation inside the incoming majority has turned to a different question: how much to raise taxes.

The Wall Street Journal reported over the weekend, in a story highlighted by Political Wire, that Democrats broadly agree on what they want to undo, including President Trump's tariffs and the Republican changes to Medicaid, food stamps and health-insurance subsidies, but are divided over whether and how to pay for a price tag that could top a trillion dollars. Part of the debate, according to that report, is timing: whether to attach tax increases to their major bills or use the fight to show voters the stakes heading into 2028.

The menu is no secret. The Tax Foundation reports that restoring the expanded Affordable Care Act premium credits, which expired at the end of 2025, sits near the top of the Democratic list, along with larger child and earned-income tax credits, and that raising the 21 percent corporate rate and millionaire surtaxes, including one proposed by Sen. Chris Van Hollen, are leading ways to pay for it. Analysts at Grant Thornton note that reversing the Medicaid changes in last year's One Big Beautiful Bill Act is also among the party's first priorities. Democrats argue all of this restores help that working families lost and asks the wealthy to carry more of the load. That is a sincere argument, and it deserves a serious answer.

The Ledger Comes First

The Congressional Budget Office estimates the deficit for the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30 at $1.993 trillion, $218 billion more than the year before. Net interest on the public debt rose 11 percent, to $1.143 trillion. Washington now spends more than a trillion dollars a year simply to carry what it has already borrowed.

Now add the agenda. The CBO has estimated that the Medicaid changes Democrats want to reverse would reduce federal Medicaid spending by $911 billion over 10 years. Making the expanded Obamacare credits permanent would cost about $350 billion over a decade, according to the estimate the Tax Foundation cites. Those two items alone come to more than $1.2 trillion before a single new program is written. Rolling back tariffs would surrender more: the Tax Policy Center projects the current tariffs will bring in about $155 billion in net revenue in 2027 alone, Howard Gleckman wrote in Forbes.

A government already borrowing close to $2 trillion a year does not have a problem that new taxes on the top can fix by themselves. It has a spending problem, and the agenda the Journal described adds to it.

'Only the Rich' Rarely Stays That Way

History offers a warning about taxes sold as hitting only the top. In 1969, Congress learned that 155 high-income taxpayers had paid no federal income tax, and it answered with a minimum tax aimed squarely at people like them, according to the Tax Policy Center. Because the regular income tax was indexed for inflation and the alternative minimum tax was not, more and more ordinary filers were pulled in; by 2017, the AMT reached roughly 5.2 million filers. A tax aimed at a few wealthy households ended up landing on millions of families who never considered themselves rich.

Gleckman expects a Democratic Congress to push the top individual rate back to at least the pre-2017 level of 39.6 percent, with perhaps an extra surtax on very high incomes. Each of those ideas arrives with the same promise the 1969 law made. Families who remember the AMT have reason to read the fine print.

There is also a common-sense problem. Democrats campaigned on affordability. Higher corporate taxes and higher individual rates do not lower anyone's grocery bill, rent or insurance premium. They raise the cost of doing business in America at the very moment families are asking for relief.

Who Stands in the Way, and What Comes Next

The most important check is the one the Framers wrote into Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution: a bill becomes law only with the president's signature, unless two-thirds of each chamber votes to override his veto. The Tax Foundation notes that Democratic ambitions to raise taxes will be limited by President Trump's veto, so many proposals now are more likely to serve as messaging and to shape future policy. Grant Thornton likewise expects any Democratic tax bill to face a veto and says that, without Republican support, such measures would serve chiefly as markers for later negotiations.

The 120th Congress convenes Jan. 3, 2027. The larger fight comes at the end of 2028, when several tax cuts in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act are set to expire, which is exactly why the timing debate inside the Democratic caucus matters.

Republicans and the White House have a better offer to make: restrain spending, keep the tax cuts that let families hold on to more of their paychecks, and fix the programs that are leaking money before asking taxpayers to refill them. Scripture warns that the borrower is servant to the lender. A nation paying more than a trillion dollars a year in interest should take that to heart before it writes a single new tax.

Sources

  1. Political Wire: Democrats Torn Over Floating New Taxes (link)
  2. Grant Thornton: Midterm Dem rout puts tax policy at inflection point (link)
  3. Tax Foundation: What a Democratic Congress Means for Federal Tax Policy in 2027 (link)
  4. Forbes: Resurgent Hill Democrats Have Big Decisions To Make On A Tax Agenda (link)
  5. Congressional Budget Office: Monthly Budget Review: Summary for Fiscal Year 2026 (link)
  6. Tax Policy Center: What is the AMT? (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageA Washington Judge Bars a Sheriff From Telling ICE Who Is…Turn the pageThe Socialists Want AOC in the White House and Hochul Out…