Pushback
A Washington Judge Bars a Sheriff From Telling ICE Who Is in His Jail. Congress Wrote Cooperation Into Federal Law
Attorney General Nick Brown won a ruling that Adams County broke the state's sanctuary law by sharing custody lists and release times with federal agents. Federal statutes and the Supreme Court have long treated that kind of cooperation as part of how immigration law is meant to work.
By JACK HOLLISTERStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 16, 10:40 AM · 4 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
In Adams County, in Eastern Washington, the sheriff's office did something many sheriffs across the country still do every day. It told federal immigration officers who was sitting in the county jail and when they would walk out. On Friday, a state judge ruled that doing so broke Washington law.
What the State Won
Spokane County Superior Court Judge Marla Polin ruled that the Adams County Sheriff's Office violated the Keep Washington Working Act, the 2019 state law that limits how local police and jails may work with federal immigration enforcement, The Spokesman-Review reported. Attorney General Nick Brown's office brought the case against the county and Sheriff Dale Wagner, and it went to trial in July, according to The Center Square.
The judge found that the sheriff's office sent lists of people in custody to Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the Border Patrol, shared release times, let federal agents interview people held in the jail, and held some people based only on civil immigration warrants or detainers, the Washington State Standard reported. The court also found that the custody lists sent to federal agents were more accurate than the jail's public roster.
Polin rejected the county's argument that the law violates the state or federal constitution or is preempted by federal law, and she issued a permanent injunction ordering the county to revise its policies and train its staff, The Center Square reported. Brown called the ruling a victory for the rights and dignity of every Washingtonian regardless of birthplace, and said it was the first time a state court had applied the law's provisions.
That is the state's case, stated fairly. Olympia decided that local deputies may not help federal immigration agents in these ways, and a court has now enforced that choice against a sheriff elected by his own county's voters.
What Federal Law and the Supreme Court Say
Congress spoke to this question 30 years ago. Under a 1996 law, 8 U.S.C. 1373, no state or local government may prohibit or in any way restrict its officials from sending information about a person's citizenship or immigration status to federal immigration authorities, or from receiving it.
A second statute goes further. Under 8 U.S.C. 1357(g)(10), state and local officers need no formal agreement with Washington, D.C., to communicate with federal officials about a person's immigration status, or to cooperate in identifying, arresting, detaining or removing people who are in the country unlawfully. In other words, federal law treats cooperation as normal, not as misconduct.
The Supreme Court has said the same. In Arizona v. United States in 2012, the justices struck down several parts of Arizona's immigration law but let stand the provision requiring officers to check a person's immigration status. Writing for the Court, Justice Anthony Kennedy called consultation between federal and state officials an important feature of the immigration system and noted that Congress has encouraged the sharing of information about possible immigration violations. The same opinion affirmed the national government's broad power over immigration and the status of aliens.
Judge Polin concluded that the state law is not preempted, and states do have room to keep their own officers out of federal enforcement. There is a real difference, though, between a state declining to help and a state forbidding an elected sheriff from cooperating in the very ways federal law invites. By the court's own finding, the custody lists were a more accurate version of a roster the public can already see.
Holding someone past his release date on a civil detainer alone is the hardest part of the sheriff's practice to defend, and courts are right to look at it closely. But this ruling reaches much further, to custody lists, release times and jail interviews.
Common sense matters here, too. When federal officers know when a jailed person is due to be released, they can take custody at the jail, in a secure and controlled setting. When they are kept in the dark, they have to find that person later, at a home, a workplace or on a street corner, where the risks to officers, bystanders and the person being arrested are all higher.
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
Wagner is not backing down. He said his office strongly disagrees with the ruling and will appeal, and he argued that no law should keep local officers from working with federal authorities when that cooperation helps keep violent criminals off the streets, The Center Square reported. The court also noted that Wagner saw no need to change his office's policies after the 2019 law took effect.
The appeal will test whether Washington's sanctuary law can stand alongside the federal statutes Congress wrote to keep information moving between governments. Sheriffs across the state have reason to watch closely.
Washington's voters and lawmakers are free to debate how much help local deputies should give federal immigration agents. But a sheriff who tells federal officers who is in his jail, and when they will be released, is not defying federal law. He is doing what federal law plainly invites. The appellate courts should look hard at whether Olympia has gone further than Congress allows.
Sources
- The Spokesman-Review: Adams County illegally cooperated with federal immigration officials, Spokane judge rules (link)
- Washington State Standard: County violated WA law restricting coordination with ICE, judge rules (link)
- The Center Square: Washington court finds county broke sanctuary law by aiding ICE (link)
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute: 8 U.S. Code 1373: Communication between government agencies and the Immigration and Naturalization Service (link)
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute: 8 U.S. Code 1357: Powers of immigration officers and employees (link)
- Supreme Court of the United States: Arizona v. United States (2012) (link)
— 30 —


