Pushback
Biden's Memoir Calls the 2024 Debate Minor. The Record Says It Changed Everything.
Joe Biden's new memoir and a People interview downplay his June 2024 debate and link it to Hunter's trial, but documented age concerns and his exit weeks later tell a fuller story.
By MAYA THOMPSONStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 17, 9:30 AM · 4 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Former President Joe Biden's White House memoir, "Promise Me, America," goes on sale today from Little, Brown and Company. Ahead of its release, Biden offered two readings of the night that ended his political career: that his June 2024 debate against Donald Trump did not matter much, and that his halting performance owed a great deal to the weight of his son Hunter's criminal case. Both deserve a respectful hearing, and both deserve to be checked against the record.
What Biden is saying
In an interview with People magazine released last Wednesday, Biden looked back on the debate and called it "not very consequential". He said he had expected a second debate that never happened, and that the missing rematch did not trouble him.
The book turns to the cause. According to CNN, Biden writes that by the time he took the stage he was weighed down by Hunter's criminal trial, which had only just ended, along with the exhaustion of the job and surprise at Trump's aggressive style. CNN also reports that Biden defends his decision to seek a second term and devotes a full chapter to rebutting critics of his mental sharpness.
The memoir reaches well beyond 2024. Newsweek, which reviewed excerpts, reports that Biden writes of being wary of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's "Trump-like tendencies" and accuses him of bending democratic institutions to serve personal ends. Newsweek says Biden also argues that Netanyahu's conduct after the October 7 attacks came close to dereliction of duty, while CNN reports Biden's frustration that the Israeli leader did not think like a statesman. Readers who stand with Israel will note the harsh verdict on a wartime ally.
What the record shows
Start with the consequences. The debate was held on June 27, 2024, and 24 days later, on July 21, Biden ended his reelection campaign. In between, by Biden's own account, Nancy Pelosi worked behind the scenes to persuade elected officials and Biden delegates to abandon him. Vice President Kamala Harris took his place at the top of the Democratic ticket. A debate that drove a sitting president out of the race and handed his party a new nominee barely three months before Election Day was not a minor event. It is hard to name a more consequential presidential debate in modern history.
Next, the timeline. Hunter Biden's federal gun case went to trial in Delaware that June, and while it was under way his father told ABC News he would not pardon him. Biden is right that the case was fresh when he faced Trump; CNN notes the trial had only just concluded. Any parent can understand that burden, and the Biden family's pain over Hunter's troubles was real.
But questions about Biden's age and memory did not begin that month. In February 2024, special counsel Robert Hur released his report on Biden's handling of classified documents, and while he brought no charges, he described a man jurors would likely see as a "well-meaning elderly man with a poor memory". TheWrap reported that Hur also cited 2017 recordings in which Biden struggled to recall events, and found his memory worse still in his interview with investigators.
Voters had reached a similar verdict. An ABC News/Ipsos poll taken after the Hur report found that 86 percent of Americans considered Biden too old for another term, including 59 percent who said the same of Trump and 27 percent who named Biden alone. The New York Sun noted that the figure had climbed from 68 percent in May 2023 and 74 percent that September. Those numbers were on the books months before Hunter ever faced a jury.
The family story took one more turn after the election. On December 1, 2024, Biden pardoned Hunter on the gun and tax charges despite his earlier promises not to, and called his son's prosecution politically motivated. The pardon covers offenses going back to January 2014. Christians understand a father's mercy toward his son. But a leader who reversed himself so fully on that question invites careful weighing of his later explanations.
Who is pushing back, and what comes next
Conservatives answered the People interview quickly. Commentator Steve Guest called Biden's view delusional, and Steve Cortes pointed out that the debate forced Biden from the race just over three weeks later. Democrats who urged him aside get little comfort either, as the memoir revisits the pressure campaign by Pelosi and other party leaders.
Biden, who is being treated for stage IV prostate cancer that has spread to his bones, has said he will scale back in-person events to promote the book. He also told People he would not have run again had he known he had cancer. Americans of every stripe can pray for his health and family while still insisting on an accurate account of 2024.
That account matters beyond one memoir. The concerns raised by a special counsel and by voters in early 2024 were about whether the public was being told the truth about a president's fitness. A book that calls the debate inconsequential and places the weight on a son's trial leaves those concerns where they were. Now that the book is in stores, its version of events will be measured against that record.
Sources
- Fox News: Biden ripped for 'totally delusional' claim about debate that preceded his 2024 exit (link)
- CNN: What Biden says in his new book about 2024 and his dealings with Netanyahu, Harris and Pelosi (link)
- Newsweek: Biden Says Israel's Netanyahu Had 'Trump-Like Tendencies' in New Book (link)
- TheWrap: Special Counsel Report Raises Biden Memory Questions: 'Well-Meaning Elderly Man With a Poor Memory' (link)
- New York Sun: Vast Majority of Americans View Biden as Too Old To Serve, New Poll Finds After Special Counsel's Damning Report (link)
- Associated Press via ABC News: Biden pardons his son Hunter on gun, tax charges, despite previous promises that he would not do so (link)
— 30 —


