Investigations & Special Reports
Kentucky's Auditor Says She Found $1.5 Billion in Waste and Got a 'Troubling' Answer From Beshear's Team
Allison Ball points to Medicaid double payments, shared Social Security numbers and SNAP errors, while the governor's office disputes her biggest estimate and calls her numbers inflated.
By KEVIN NAKAMURAStaff Correspondent · KENTUCKY · Nov 21, 9:30 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Kentucky's top auditor says her office has found $1.5 billion in taxpayer waste across state government, and she is accusing Gov. Andy Beshear's administration of brushing off the findings, Fox News Digital reported on Saturday. Beshear, a Democrat widely seen as a possible 2028 presidential contender, has pushed back hard on the auditor's numbers in the past, calling them inflated.
The dispute between Auditor Allison Ball, a Republican, and the governor is not new. But the size of the claimed waste, and the stakes for a governor with national ambitions, make it a story worth following for every taxpayer who wonders where the money goes.
What the Auditor Says She Found
According to Fox News Digital, Ball's audits have flagged a wide range of problems: ineligible noncitizens receiving benefits, Social Security numbers being used by as many as 10 people at once, duplicate payments to individuals, and roughly $100 million in errors in the food stamp program known as SNAP.
The single largest piece is in Medicaid. Ball's office has said Kentucky paid $836 million to managed-care companies for Medicaid recipients whose coverage was also being paid for by another state at the same time, WHAS11 reported. The examination began in August 2023 at the request of the federal Department of Health and Human Services' inspector general, according to that report.
Ball took her concerns to Congress earlier this year. In prepared testimony for a House Oversight subcommittee in April, she described findings that included ineligible noncitizens receiving Medicaid benefits.
A 'Troubling' Response, the Auditor Says
Ball's frustration is as much about the reaction as the findings. She told Fox News Digital she has not received the cooperation she wanted from the governor's office and described its answer to her concerns as a "really troubling response". According to Fox, she said the governor's staff has tended to respond that such problems happen in every state.
She also warned that once money goes out the door, it is unlikely to come back. Ball told Fox that clawing back improper payments is difficult, which is why stopping them before they happen matters so much. She has warned that the problems could put some federal funding at risk, including grants that support Kentucky's Medicaid program, WHAS11 reported.
Looking ahead, Ball described the coming year as a major opportunity to tackle waste, fraud and abuse in Kentucky, according to Fox.
The Governor's Side
Beshear's administration rejects the auditor's math. His office called the $836 million Medicaid estimate "a wild extrapolation from a small subset" and said that, once Kentucky gained access to updated federal cross-checking databases, the overlap with other states turned out to be far smaller, WHAS11 reported. The governor's office also said there was no chance Kentucky would lose federal Medicaid funding over the issue.
Beshear himself has called Ball's claims "wildly inflated," and his administration has said one of her reports contains significant errors, according to WHAS11. The two officials have clashed on other fronts as well: Ball sued Beshear over his failure to carry out a kinship-care law passed by the General Assembly, Kentucky public television reported.
Why It Matters
Every dollar of waste is a dollar taken from working families, and from the truly needy people these programs are meant to help. Medicaid and SNAP exist to serve those who qualify. When the same person is covered and paid for twice, or when one Social Security number shows up on multiple benefit files, it drains resources from the people the safety net was built to catch.
The numbers are disputed, and taxpayers deserve a clear accounting from both sides. If the auditor's estimates are too high, the administration should show its work in detail. If they are close to right, Kentuckians are owed an explanation and a plan to fix it. Either way, the answer should not be that waste happens everywhere. Good government begins by refusing to accept that.
The politics are hard to ignore. A governor who hopes to make a national case for his record will face questions about how his administration guarded the public purse. Fair-minded voters will want to hear his full response, and they will also want to see the auditor's evidence tested in the open.
What Comes Next
Ball has signaled she will keep pressing in 2027, and she has urged the governor to work with her office to close the gaps she has identified. The Medicaid review began at the request of federal inspectors, and their comparison of enrollment records across states could go a long way toward settling who has the numbers right.
Kentucky will choose Beshear's successor in 2027, and as we reported this week, Rep. James Comer has already entered the race as an early Republican front-runner. However that contest turns out, the next governor will inherit the question at the heart of this fight: whether Kentucky's benefit programs are paying only the people they are supposed to pay.
Sources
- Fox News: 2028 presidential contender under fire from state auditor over waste, fraud, abuse fears: 'Troubling response' (link)
- WHAS11: Auditor warns Kentucky risks losing federal funds after finding $836M in 'Medicaid waste' (link)
- WHAS11: Kentucky auditor cites $1B of waste, fraud; Gov. Beshear pushes back (link)
- U.S. House Committee on Oversight: Prepared remarks of Kentucky Auditor Allison Ball (link)
- KET (PBS): Auditor Ball sues Beshear over kinship bill (link)
— 30 —


