Investigations & Special Reports
Locks on Paper Only: GAO Finds 17 of 22 Federal Agencies Have Not Fully Followed Washington's Own Cybersecurity Playbook
The watchdog's review of 'zero trust' security plans landed in a week of hacks at the FBI and Agriculture Department. Only five agencies passed, and GAO issued 40 fixes.
By KEVIN NAKAMURAStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 4:15 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Taxpayers spend billions of dollars a year protecting federal computer systems. A new report from the Government Accountability Office suggests many agencies still have not finished the basic planning needed to make that money count.
GAO, the nonpartisan investigative arm of Congress, reviewed plans for "zero trust" cybersecurity at 22 major civilian agencies and found that only five fully addressed selected guidance from the White House Office of Management and Budget and the National Institute of Standards and Technology. Although almost every agency had written an implementation plan, the other 17 had not fully documented key elements needed to guide their efforts, the watchdog said.
Who fell short
The 17 agencies include the Departments of Agriculture, Commerce, Education, Energy, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security, Housing and Urban Development, Interior, Justice, State and Treasury, according to yourNEWS. Just the News reported that the Labor, Veterans Affairs and Transportation departments, the General Services Administration and the Social Security Administration were the five that met the guidance.
GAO issued 40 recommendations to the 17 agencies, focused on updating their plans to cover enterprise-wide rollout, clarify who is responsible for what, and document how mature their systems are. The findings reflect conditions as of August, and HSToday noted the report was released this week.
Why it lands so hard right now
The timing could hardly be more pointed. The Justice Department, home to the FBI, and the Agriculture Department are both on GAO's list, and both have faced reported breaches in recent days, at the FBI's national crime database and at a farm-payment system. PJ Media and yourNEWS tied the findings to this month's wave of government technology failures.
To be fair, GAO was careful on this point. The report reviews planning documents, not specific breaches, and it does not establish that any agency's planning gaps caused or contributed to a particular cyber incident. But a security plan is the blueprint for every lock on the door. When the blueprint is incomplete, it is harder for anyone, including Congress, to know whether the locks work.
What zero trust means
Zero trust is a simple idea with a complicated rollout. Instead of assuming that anyone already inside a government network can be trusted, every user, device and request has to prove itself, every time. Washington has pushed agencies toward this model for years, and GAO's review measured how well their plans matched the guidance meant to get them there.
A watchdog without teeth
The GAO findings follow a September report from the Homeland Security Department's inspector general that found most agencies missed a deadline to adopt cloud security requirements issued by the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, Federal News Network reported. The inspector general found that 86% of agencies had not put all mandatory cloud security policies in place by the June 2025 deadline, and concluded that CISA lacks the authority to require full and timely implementation of its binding directives.
In other words, the federal government's own rules are clear, but the agency charged with enforcing them cannot make other agencies follow them on schedule. That is a management failure, and it is the kind of problem that does not show up in a budget line until something goes wrong.
What it means for taxpayers
Americans have every right to expect that agencies holding their tax records, health data, farm payments and criminal records protect that information as seriously as a bank protects a vault. Fixing this does not require a new bureaucracy. It requires agency leaders to finish the work they were already told to do, and Congress to hold them accountable when they do not.
What comes next
Agencies typically respond to GAO recommendations within months, and GAO tracks whether they follow through. With Democrats taking control of Congress in January and both parties alarmed by this month's outages, the 40 recommendations are likely to come up in oversight hearings. The question for each of the 17 agencies is simple: how long until the plan on paper becomes protection in practice?
Sources
- U.S. Government Accountability Office: Cybersecurity: Agencies Need to Fully Address Federal Guidance as They Refine Zero Trust Architecture (GAO-27-108661) (link)
- HSToday: GAO: 17 Federal Agencies Have Gaps in Zero Trust Implementation Plans (link)
- yourNEWS: Federal Watchdog Finds 17 of 22 Agencies Fall Short of Cybersecurity Standards Amid Widespread Technology Outages (link)
- Just the News: Report finds majority of government agencies were not in compliance with federal cyber regulations (link)
- Federal News Network: IG report finds government cyber directives lack teeth (link)
- PJ Media: Report Reveals That Most Government Agencies Were Not Compliant With Federal Cyber Regulations (link)
— 30 —


