Immigration & Border Security
Labor Department Proposes Biggest Green Card Hiring Overhaul in Two Decades to Put American Workers First
The PERM proposal would replace newspaper ads with online recruiting, end the Schedule A shortcut and bar sponsors that laid off Americans in similar jobs.
By COLE BRENNANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 16, 3:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
The Labor Department on Monday proposed the broadest rewrite in nearly two decades of PERM, the labor certification that stands between most employers and a green card for a foreign worker, with a clear aim: make companies look harder for Americans before they look abroad.
In announcing the proposal, the department said the change will put American workers "first in line for high-skilled, high-paying job opportunities over foreign labor". Bloomberg reported the department framed the plan as stronger protection for Americans who have lost their jobs in layoffs.
The proposal is not final and changes nothing for employers today. The public will have 60 days to comment once it formally appears in the Federal Register, which Newsweek reported was scheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 17.
What Would Change
PERM is the first step for most employment-based green cards in the EB-2 and EB-3 categories, and it is meant to show that no qualified American is available for the job. The process has drawn scrutiny over employers allegedly placing required job ads in print publications where few American job seekers would ever see them, Just the News reported.
The proposal would retire that model. Instead of mandatory newspaper ads, employers would recruit online through their own websites, job boards, social media, job fairs and campus recruiting, according to the department. Just the News reported the opening would have to be posted on the company's website and on mainstream online recruitment portals, and Forbes reported the advertising period would be extended, with ads generally running at least 90 days. The department also said employers would be barred from tailoring job openings to fit a foreign worker.
The modernization would also cut costs. The department estimates employers would save about $164 million a year by dropping required newspaper advertising, Newsweek reported.
The layoff rules are where the proposal gets tougher. An employer that laid off U.S. workers in the same or a similar occupation within the previous two years would be blocked from using PERM for those roles, Forbes reported, compared with a six-month look-back under current rules. The Washington Post described it as a two-year bar on sponsoring green cards for the laid-off positions. The department said laid-off Americans would be considered throughout the process, and Just the News reported employers would have to give priority to laid-off employees before turning to a foreign worker.
Finally, the plan would end Schedule A, a list of pre-designated occupations that lets employers skip an individual test of the American labor market. Schedule A has covered professional nurses and physical therapists, along with certain workers of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts. Without it, hospitals and other employers sponsoring those workers would have to recruit the same way every other PERM sponsor does.
Why It Matters
The proposal follows a season of enforcement. Last month the administration suspended Microsoft's and Adobe's access to the program, the Washington Post reported. Monday's plan moves from case-by-case crackdowns to rules that would govern every sponsor in the country.
The logic is hard to argue with. A green card is permanent, and the promise behind PERM is that the job went abroad only because no qualified American could be found. That promise means little if the search consists of an ad in a newspaper most job seekers never open. It means even less when the same company recently handed pink slips to Americans doing the same work. Asking employers to advertise where Americans actually look for jobs, for long enough that they can respond, and to call back their own laid-off workers first, is the kind of common-sense safeguard most working families would assume was already in place.
There are real trade-offs. Ending Schedule A means hospitals that sponsor foreign-trained nurses would face a full recruitment process they have long been able to skip. A longer advertising window adds time to every case. Against that, employers would no longer pay for print ads, and the department's savings estimate suggests the paperwork side of the process could get cheaper even as the hiring test gets stricter.
Reactions and What Comes Next
Critics of the current system have pointed to buried print ads as evidence that the American-worker test was too easy to satisfy, and the proposal takes that concern on directly. For employers and the immigration lawyers who file their cases, the end of Schedule A and the longer recruitment window are the provisions that add new steps and time.
Formal responses from businesses, hospital groups, worker advocates and lawmakers are expected to arrive through the comment docket over the next two months. After the comment period closes, the department must review what it receives before it can issue a final rule, and current PERM rules remain in force until then. If the Nov. 17 publication date holds, the 60-day window would close in mid-January.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor: US Department of Labor proposes to modernize permanent labor certification recruitment, strengthening protections for American workers (link)
- Newsweek: Green Card Update: Labor Department Proposes Sweeping PERM Changes (link)
- Forbes: Employers Who Sponsor Foreign Workers' Green Cards Could Face Tougher Rules, Labor Dept. Proposes: What To Know (link)
- The Washington Post: Trump administration proposes restrictions for employer-sponsored green cards (link)
- Just the News: Labor Department proposes sweeping changes to foreign labor program (link)
- Bloomberg: US Proposes Tighter Rules for Employer-Sponsored Green Cards (link)
— 30 —


