‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Crime & Justice

Tisch Keeps NYPD Job as Mamdani Rebuffs Calls to Oust Her

Nearly 11 months in, New York's tough-minded police commissioner and its socialist mayor are making their partnership work, even as the far left keeps pushing for her removal.

By ELIJAH CARTERStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 21, 1:55 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: A New York City police precinct house at blue hour on a Manhattan side street, its green globe lamps glowing beside the entrance steps, a patrol car with no readable markings parked at the curb, the Brooklyn Bridge and lower…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

New York's police commissioner and its democratic socialist mayor have found a way to run the city's police department together, the Wall Street Journal reported Saturday, nearly 11 months into one of the most unlikely partnerships in American politics. The Journal described Commissioner Jessica Tisch as a billionaire top cop working alongside Mayor Zohran Mamdani.

The Mayor Says She Stays

Mamdani has turned back pressure from his own left flank to push Tisch out. After a shooting involving federal immigration officers in the Bronx, the city's Democratic Socialists of America chapter urged him to remove her, and he answered, "Jessica Tisch is the police commissioner, I have no plans to change that," according to a report carried by Yahoo News.

The Times of Israel described the campaign against Tisch, a vocal defender of Jewish safety in the city, as an inflection point for New York's Jewish community, and reported that she has built a working relationship with the mayor without backing away from her pro-Israel views.

Common Ground, and Hard Calls

The two appeared side by side on Nov. 16 to announce the disbanding of the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, fulfilling a Mamdani campaign promise, CNN reported. Tisch backed the restructuring, saying the department must always be willing to examine how it operates and make improvements, according to CNN.

The arrangement dates to last November, when Tisch agreed to stay on as commissioner under the incoming mayor, NBC New York reported. At their first joint appearance, she brushed aside speculation that she would be demoted, amNY reported.

Why It Matters

For the families, shop owners and officers of New York, a steady, professional hand at the top of the department is not a partisan prize. It is the difference between a city that holds its gains and one that slides backward. Tisch has kept her post by staying focused on the job, and Mamdani deserves credit for resisting the activists who wanted a more pliant commissioner.

That does not mean every decision has been the right one. Liberty Bell Report has argued that New Yorkers deserve the full public safety case before units like the Strategic Response Group are broken up, and that question has not gone away. A commissioner who will tell a mayor no, in public if necessary, is exactly what a city needs when its leader rose from a movement that once championed defunding the police.

What Comes Next

The real test is whether Tisch keeps the authority to run the department her way as pressure from the left continues. If she does, New York may prove that a serious police commissioner can outlast the politics around her. If she does not, it will be a warning for every city weighing whether a progressive mayor and a professional police chief can truly share power.

Sources

  1. The Wall Street Journal: How New York's Billionaire Top Cop and Socialist Mayor Are Making It Work (link)
  2. Yahoo News: Mamdani stands by NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch amid demands for her removal (link)
  3. CNN: SRG: Mamdani disbands controversial NYPD unit, fulfilling campaign promise (link)
  4. NBC New York: Jessica Tisch agrees to be Mamdani's NYPD commissioner (link)
  5. amNY: NYC top cop Jessica Tisch shakes off speculation of 'demotion' under Mayor Mamdani during first joint appearance (link)
  6. The Times of Israel: Threats to NYPD's pro-Israel commissioner are an inflection point for New York Jews (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageCrime & JusticeTurn the pagePatel Urged Cyber Shields as FBI Breach Came to Light