‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Crime & Justice

Patel Urged Cyber Shields as FBI Breach Came to Light

Critics pounced on the FBI director's Thursday night Fox News appearance after reports of a crime-database intrusion. His message that night was a call to harden America's networks, and President Trump says he wants the bureau's old files in the open too.

By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 1:22 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: Dusk exterior of a stately stone federal building in Washington, D.C., tall windows glowing with blue light from rows of server racks inside, a translucent digital shield and padlock hovering over streams of data in the…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

FBI Director Kash Patel spent part of Thursday evening on Fox News urging American companies to harden their networks against hackers, and critics are now seizing on the timing after reports that intruders had reached one of the bureau's most important databases.

Patel appeared on Hannity and addressed the recent string of system failures that touched the Federal Aviation Administration, the National Security Agency and several private companies, Mediaite and the Daily Beast reported. He promoted Operation Winter Shield, an FBI initiative launched earlier this year to encourage businesses to strengthen their digital defenses, and pressed companies to update their systems and put up firewalls to keep attackers out, according to the Daily Beast and Breitbart.

CNN reported Friday that bureau officials learned of an apparent breach of the National Crime Information Center on Thursday, the same day as the interview. Mediaite and the Daily Beast cast Patel's comments, which included praise for the bureau's cyber work, as a premature victory lap. Breitbart pointed out that the account of the intrusion rests on anonymous sources, and the Daily Beast said the FBI had not immediately commented.

The Message Behind the Interview

The heart of Patel's message was a warning, not a boast: America's networks, public and private, need stronger locks. A reported break-in at a system as central as this one only underlines the point he was making.

The NCIC links federal, state, local and tribal law enforcement and holds fugitive and missing-person files, criminal records and sex offender registry information, according to the Daily Beast. This would be the second intrusion involving the FBI in recent months: in September, the group known as ShinyHunters reached information on bureau employees, and the FBI blamed an unnamed contractor. Who was behind the new breach, and whether any records were viewed, copied or altered, remains unclear.

Trump: 'Not Good,' but Maybe Revealing

President Trump addressed the breach Saturday in a telephone interview with Fox News, saying "it's not good. I don't like that," CNN reported. He added that he likes to look for a positive spin, suggesting the intrusion might bring to light records on the Russia investigation, his 2019 call with Ukraine's president and voter fraud, Axios reported.

His distrust of the bureau's Russia files has a documented basis. Special counsel John Durham's 2023 report concluded the FBI "failed to uphold its mission" in the Trump-Russia probe, cited 17 inaccuracies in its applications to surveil campaign adviser Carter Page, and found that agents did not pass exculpatory statements to the Justice Department, CBS News reported. The only conviction tied to that review was former FBI lawyer Kevin Clinesmith's guilty plea for falsifying an email used in the surveillance, and he received probation.

What Comes Next

The questions now belong to the bureau: how the intruders got in, what they touched, and whether the agencies that connect to NCIC every day need to change how they log on. Patel's own Winter Shield message, that every system needs stronger defenses, is now the standard the FBI will be measured against, and the officers who depend on accurate records deserve quick, straight answers.

Liberty Bell Report will keep following the investigation as the FBI, the Justice Department and Congress respond.

Sources

  1. Mediaite: Kash Patel Bragged About FBI Cybersecurity on Fox News Right After Bureau Was Hacked: Report (link)
  2. The Daily Beast: Kash Patel's Cybersecurity Victory Lap Blown Up by FBI NCIC Hack (link)
  3. Breitbart: Anonymous Sources Disclose Purported Hack of FBI Network After Kash Patel Praised Bureau's Cybersecurity (link)
  4. CNN: Trump downplays breach into FBI's crime database while reviving complaints about agency's Russia probe (link)
  5. Axios: Trump says FBI hack might expose Russia "hoax" (link)
  6. CBS News: Durham report finds FBI "failed to uphold its mission" in handling of Trump-Russia probe (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

UAE Runs Oil Past Iran's Blockade as Two Tankers Are Hit

A U.S.-backed Emirati shuttle is keeping crude moving out of the Gulf, the Wall Street Journal reports, even as projectiles struck tankers near Oman's Khasab on Saturday morning.

By PRIYA DESAIEnergy & Environment · Nov 21, 1:35 PM

Previous pageCrime & JusticeTurn the pageTerror-Listed Cartel's Leaders and 19 Others Indicted in…