Politics
Cruz Races to Seat Trump's Dallas Judge Before Democrats Take the Senate as Cornyn Holds Back His Blue Slip
Texas' two Republican senators clashed on the Senate floor over T. Elliot Gaiser, the President's pick for the Northern District of Texas, with only weeks left in the GOP majority.
By AVA STERLINGStaff Correspondent · TEXAS · Nov 21, 2:15 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
A fight between Texas' two Republican senators over a single federal judgeship in Dallas spilled onto the Senate floor this week, and it has put a spotlight on how little time conservatives have left to fill the bench before Democrats take control of the chamber in January.
At the center of it is T. Elliot Gaiser, the head of the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel, whom President Trump nominated to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Sen. John Cornyn has declined to return his "blue slip," the paper signal of support that home-state senators traditionally give before a district court nominee can get a Judiciary Committee hearing, according to The Texas Tribune. Sen. Ted Cruz supports the nominee and wants him confirmed before the new Congress arrives.
What happened on the floor
The Washington Sun first reported that the two senators argued so loudly that reporters in the press gallery could hear them, with Cornyn at one point saying he was upset at someone for ending his career. The outlet noted it could not tell whether that remark was aimed at Cruz or at the President. The Sun reported that the exchange ended with Cornyn waving Cruz off and walking away toward the Democratic side of the chamber, and the Houston Chronicle and other outlets picked up the account.
Cruz later confirmed the outlines of the account to CBS News Texas. "I was not shouting," he said, adding that Cornyn had been shouting and cursing at him.
The bad blood has a history. Cornyn lost his Republican primary runoff in May to Attorney General Ken Paxton, whom the President endorsed, and he leaves the Senate in January. Reports have noted that Cruz's political consulting firm worked for Paxton, and Cornyn has said he knew Cruz was never one of his supporters.
The case each senator is making
Cornyn's stated objection is about home-state ties. He has argued that Gaiser is not a Texas lawyer and has not gone through the vetting Texas senators normally give the state's judges, and he has recommended Fort Worth attorney Steve Fahey instead, according to the Tribune. Cornyn said the White House has asked for information about Fahey.
Cruz's argument is about the calendar. He has said the White House told senators a brand-new nominee could not finish an FBI background check in time to be confirmed this year, and he has pointed out that Gaiser has already been vetted because of the senior Justice Department post he holds. Cruz told CBS News Texas he believes that once Democrats hold the majority they will shut down judicial confirmations, leaving the Dallas vacancy unfilled.
The White House has not said whether it would switch to Cornyn's preferred candidate. An official told reporters the administration expects all of the President's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year. RedState, which has been sharply critical of Cornyn, called his move an obstruction of a conservative nominee.
Why it matters
For conservatives, judges are one of the most lasting things any President leaves behind. District judges serve for life, and the Northern District of Texas hears major cases on immigration, energy, guns and religious liberty that often end up at the Supreme Court. The Constitution gives the President the power to nominate judges and the Senate the job of advice and consent. The blue slip appears nowhere in that text; it is a Senate custom that each Judiciary Committee chairman decides how to honor.
To be fair to Cornyn, he has spent two decades shaping the Texas federal bench, and senators of both parties have long guarded their say over judges in their own states. Still, the arithmetic is unforgiving. Once the Senate changes hands, the President's ability to fill vacancies with judges who read the Constitution as written will depend on Democrats, and Cruz is betting that a qualified nominee in hand is worth more than a promising one who cannot be confirmed in time.
What comes next
The Senate has only a few working weeks left before the new Congress is sworn in. Unless Cornyn returns the blue slip, the Judiciary Committee chairman sets the custom aside, or the White House changes course, Gaiser's nomination is likely to expire with this Congress. Either way, the episode is a reminder to conservative voters that the last days of a majority matter, and that every seat on the federal bench counts.
Sources
- CBS News Texas: Cruz confirms report that Cornyn shouted and cursed at him on the Senate floor (link)
- The Texas Tribune: Sen. John Cornyn blocks Trump nominee for federal judge in Texas (link)
- The Washington Sun: A Senate Shouting Match (link)
- Houston Chronicle: 'I'm mad at you!': Texas senators reportedly blow up on Senate floor (link)
- RedState: Cruz Confirms Row on Senate Floor, As Cornyn Reportedly Pulls Yet Another Obstructionist Move (link)
— 30 —


