‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Autos & Transportation

Duffy Traces Friday's Ground Stop to a Contractor's Router Swap and Vows Accountability as Flights Return to Full Operations

A router installed during L3Harris's copper-to-fiber upgrade flooded the FAA's network, the transportation secretary says, as investigators work to separate human error from faulty hardware.

By FRANK KOWALSKIStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 14, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Cinematic dusk scene at a large American airport: an air traffic control tower glowing against a purple-orange sky, rows of parked commercial jets with plain white liveries and no markings at the gates, and in the foreground…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says the failure that froze every departing flight in America on Friday began with a routine upgrade, not an attack. A contractor, L3Harris, was switching decades-old copper telecommunications lines to fiber at a remote Federal Aviation Administration site when the trouble started, Duffy said, according to CNBC.

A router made by L3Harris and installed for the FAA sat at the center of the breakdown, Reuters reported. Once it came online, Duffy said, it began flooding other routers on the air traffic control network with connection attempts until the system was overwhelmed, CNN reported. The flood destabilized communications data at 17 of the FAA's 22 en route centers, the facilities that guide planes between airports, and because engineers could not immediately find the root cause, the agency halted departures nationwide, according to Reuters. The FAA told Reuters that communications did not fail outright and that no center went dark; controllers instead saw unstable, inconsistent data.

Human Error or a Bad Box?

Investigators have not yet decided which it was. Duffy said officials are working out whether the installer made a mistake or the router itself was faulty, CNN reported. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said the review will determine whether the router was installed or configured incorrectly or was simply defective, Fox Business reported.

L3Harris said it is supporting the FAA in its investigation into the conditions that led to the Nov. 13 ground stop, according to Reuters. Duffy has made clear he expects better. He said whoever supplied the router has to do a better job, Reuters reported, and he said people will be held accountable if mistakes were made, according to Fox Business.

There is history here. In 2009, a technician for Harris Corp., the company that later became L3Harris, misconfigured a router while moving the FAA's network to fiber, disrupting 129 air traffic facilities, according to a Transportation Department inspector general review cited by Fox Business.

Equipment That Was Overdue Two Decades Ago

Duffy has framed the outage as the bill coming due for years of neglect. The routers now being replaced are about 25 years old and were supposed to be swapped out in 2006, he said, according to Reuters. That timeline matters. The equipment that failed on Friday was overdue for replacement long before this administration arrived, and Duffy has tied the breakdown to the country's aging aviation infrastructure while pressing for more money to finish the upgrades, ABC7 New York reported.

Not everyone accepts his account. Some air traffic controllers told CNN they "don't buy" Duffy's explanation, and the head of the controllers' union said communications with some aircraft were disrupted during the episode, Yahoo News reported.

Hochul Calls for His Resignation

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul went further on Saturday, calling on Duffy to resign or be removed by President Trump, ABC7 New York reported. Hochul blamed controller shortages and repeated communications breakdowns on his leadership and urged Congress to open a full investigation.

Duffy's answer has been to keep the focus on getting travelers home and fixing the cause. He said Saturday that air traffic operations were back to full strength, while warning that passengers would keep seeing some delays and cancellations as airlines reposition planes and crews, CNN reported. The aftershock is still large: Saturday cancellations topped 5,000 by early afternoon, according to Yahoo News.

What Comes Next

The FAA's review of the router and the installation work will decide whether the fault lies with a person, a part or a process. Whatever it finds, the answer should be made public, and any contractor that falls short on work this critical should answer for it, exactly as Duffy has promised.

For travelers, the advice for the rest of the weekend stays simple: check your airline's app before you leave for the airport, because aircraft and crews are still out of position.

The larger lesson is the one Duffy has been making for months. A country that moves millions of people through its skies every day should not be one router away from a nationwide shutdown. Fixing that takes modern equipment, real oversight of the contractors who install it and the money to finish the job, and Friday's failure has put all three squarely in front of Congress.

Sources

  1. Investing.com (Reuters): US aviation shutdown blamed on L3 Harris installed router (link)
  2. CNBC: Nationwide ground stop followed contractor upgrade to L3Harris telecommunication system: DOT's Duffy (link)
  3. Yahoo News: FAA ground stop latest updates: Controllers' union chief says communications with some planes were disrupted; cancellations top 5,000; Duffy blames L3Harris (link)
  4. Fox Business: Sean Duffy says L3Harris work may have caused FAA nationwide ground stop (link)
  5. ABC7 New York: Gov. Kathy Hochul calls on Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy to resign after ground stop creates travel mess (link)
  6. CNN: US flight ground stop latest: Duffy says either faulty router or contractor error likely caused airspace meltdown (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageLaid Off Since 2023, Brampton's Autoworkers Wait for…Turn the pageTesla Starts Selling the Cybercab to Select Buyers at…