Today on Sunshine State Report with Tomás Ortega
Florida Set for Record 20th Execution, 35 Years After a Keys Couple and Their Unborn Son Were Slain
Thomas Overton is scheduled to die Thursday evening for the 1991 Tavernier killings of Michael and Missy MacIvor, the same night Texas plans its own lethal injection.
Filed November 19, 2026 · 📍 Houston, TX 77002
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Thomas Overton, 71, is scheduled for lethal injection at 6 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison.
- It would be Florida's 20th execution of 2026, breaking the record of 19 set in 2025.
- Overton was convicted of killing Michael and Missy MacIvor and their unborn son in 1991.
- Texas plans to execute Reinaldo Dennes about an hour later for a 1996 Houston murder.
Florida is set to carry out its 20th execution of the year on Thursday evening, a new state record, when Thomas Mitchell Overton, 71, is scheduled to die by lethal injection at 6 p.m. at Florida State Prison for the 1991 killings of a Florida Keys couple and their unborn son, The Associated Press reported in a story published by NBC News [1]. The execution would surpass the 19 Florida carried out in 2025, which was itself the most in a single year since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976 [1][2].
Florida will not be alone Thursday night. Texas plans to execute Reinaldo Dennes, 70, about an hour later for the 1996 robbery and killing of Houston diamond dealer Janos Szucs, which would make him the ninth person put to death in Texas this year, according to the AP [1].
Behind the record and the legal arguments are two people whose lives were taken in their own home, and a child who never drew breath. Any honest account of Thursday has to begin with them.
A Crime That Shattered a Keys Community
Michael MacIvor and his wife, Susan, known to friends as Missy, were killed during an August 1991 break-in at their home in Tavernier, in the upper Florida Keys, according to the AP and the Florida Phoenix [1][4]. Missy MacIvor was eight months pregnant, and the couple's unborn son did not survive the attack [3][4].
This week, Local 10 News in Miami spoke with people who knew the MacIvors, including a state lawmaker from the same small community, as they remembered the couple [5]. For those who loved them, the passing decades have not erased the loss.
The case went unsolved for years. In 1996, Overton was arrested on an unrelated burglary charge, and that arrest produced a DNA sample that investigators matched to evidence from the killings, the AP reported [1]. Fox 35 Orlando reported that DNA testing linked him to evidence recovered from the couple's home, and that he was convicted and sentenced to death in 1999 [3].
A Long Road Through the Courts
Gov. Ron DeSantis signed Overton's death warrant on Oct. 21, setting the stage for the record, according to Fox 35 [3]. Some early reports, including Fox 35's, gave the year of the crime as 1992; the AP and the Florida Phoenix date the killings to 1991 [1][3][4].
Overton has always maintained his innocence. His defense has argued that investigators planted the DNA evidence used to convict him, and his attorneys filed a motion in late October arguing that untested evidence in the case should be examined, the AP reported [1].
Those claims did not persuade the courts. The Florida Supreme Court on Nov. 13 rejected his final state appeals and declined to stay the execution, the Florida Phoenix reported, noting that the justices said they have routinely turned away clemency-based arguments like the ones Overton raised [4].
His last request went to the U.S. Supreme Court. In that petition, his lawyers argue that clemency in Florida no longer works as intended for people on death row and that the governor's approach denies inmates due process, according to the Florida Phoenix [4]. No Florida death row prisoner has received clemency since 1983, according to the Death Penalty Information Center [2]. As of the latest reports Thursday, the execution remained on schedule [1][4].
Why DeSantis Has Quickened the Pace
Under Florida law, the governor alone signs death warrants for inmates who have exhausted their appeals, and DeSantis has framed his pace as an answer to delay, WUFT reported [6]. His stated goal, according to the station, is to bring justice to the families of victims who have waited decades for sentences handed down by juries to be carried out [6].
The MacIvor case shows what that wait looks like. Thirty-five years separate the night of the killings from Thursday's scheduled execution, and nearly three decades have passed since a jury delivered its verdict [1][3]. That is a very long time for a grieving family to wait for the law to finish its work.
Florida has carried out more than half of the 37 executions in the United States this year, the AP reported, and two more Florida executions are scheduled for December [1]. WUFT noted that Florida is one of only two states that let a jury recommend death without a unanimous vote; state law requires at least eight of 12 jurors to agree [6].
Scripture speaks soberly to this moment. The apostle Paul wrote that the governing authority "beareth not the sword in vain" (Romans 13:4), a reminder that justice for the innocent is a grave public duty, never a cause for celebration. Many Christians hold that conviction alongside prayer for every soul involved, including the condemned.
The Case Critics Are Making
Opponents of the execution have raised Overton's own history, and their arguments deserve a fair hearing. The Death Penalty Information Center, which is critical of how the death penalty is applied, reported that Overton served in the Army from 1973 to 1975, in his late teens, and that he would be the 15th military veteran executed under DeSantis [2].
The group also noted that Overton is a survivor of the Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys, the state-run reform school in Marianna whose record of abuse against children has become a lasting stain on Florida's history [2]. He would be at least the 12th Dozier survivor executed by the state, according to the center [2]. It also argued that he was sentenced by a non-unanimous jury that never heard mitigating evidence about his life [2].
Critics further contend that the clemency process has become an empty formality, the argument at the heart of his U.S. Supreme Court petition [4].
Supporters of the sentence answer that the courts have examined this case for decades. The conviction rested on physical evidence, the claim of planted DNA has been reviewed and rejected, and the Florida Supreme Court found no reason to halt the sentence [1][4]. A hard childhood and honorable service are real parts of a man's story, but they do not erase what a jury found he did to a young family in their home.
The National Picture
The Texas case scheduled for Thursday carries its own long history. Dennes was sentenced to death for the 1996 killing of Szucs during a robbery in which about $3.6 million in diamonds was taken, the AP reported [1]. His attorneys have challenged the strength of the evidence, but prosecutors recently pointed to a 2022 Spanish-language Telemundo interview in which the Cuban-born inmate acknowledged his guilt, according to the AP [1]. An appeal in the Texas case was still pending as of Thursday's reports [1].
The AP also noted that capital punishment has drawn renewed national scrutiny since Tennessee's failed attempt to execute Christa Pike in October [1]. Even so, Florida's pace has made it the clear national leader, and its share of this year's executions dwarfs that of any other state [1].
What Happens Tonight
Barring intervention from the U.S. Supreme Court, Overton is scheduled to receive a three-drug lethal injection at 6 p.m. Thursday at Florida State Prison, the AP reported [1]. If the execution proceeds, it will set Florida's all-time annual record [1][2]. Texas is scheduled to carry out the Dennes execution in Huntsville about an hour later [1].
Whatever the hour brings, the names that matter most tonight are Michael and Missy MacIvor and the son they were preparing to welcome. Thirty-five years ago, a quiet home in the Keys was broken into and a family was taken. The state's answer comes late, but it comes through the law, after a jury's verdict and decades of review. It should be received not with cheering, but with the solemn seriousness that justice for the innocent deserves.
Sources
- [1]NBC News (AP)Florida set to carry out its record-breaking 20th execution same day as a Texas lethal injectionOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Death Penalty Information CenterFlorida Set to Conduct 20th Execution This Year—New State Record—with Execution of Military Veteran and Dozier School Survivor Thomas OvertonOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Fox 35 OrlandoFlorida schedules 20th execution of year as DeSantis signs death warrant for 1992 Keys murdersOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Should Florida ban new data centers until it studies power and water use?
- Yes
- No, bring the jobs
- Only near neighborhoods
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.