Where Nine Prayed, a Fountain of Grace: Charleston Opens the Emanuel Nine Memorial Beside Mother Emanuel

Eleven years after a gunman's hatred took nine lives inside one of America's most storied churches, Charleston opened a permanent place to remember them, and to remember the faith they showed the world.

The Emanuel Nine Memorial opened to the public on Saturday on the grounds of Mother Emanuel AME Church, the South's oldest African Methodist Episcopal congregation, in downtown Charleston ^[1][3]. The program began at 9 a.m. with remarks from dignitaries, a ribbon-cutting, gospel and jazz performances, poetry and presentations honoring the nine, and visitors were welcomed throughout the day free of charge ^[3][4].

The Nine and the Night of June 17, 2015

On the evening of June 17, 2015, a white supremacist gunman joined the church's Wednesday night Bible study, sat with the members for about an hour and then opened fire, killing nine Black worshippers ^[1][6]. The dead were the Rev. Clementa Pinckney, the church's pastor and a state senator; Cynthia Hurd; Susie Jackson; Ethel Lance; the Rev. DePayne Middleton-Doctor; Tywanza Sanders; the Rev. Daniel Simmons; the Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton; and Myra Thompson ^[1][6]. The killer was later convicted and sentenced to death in federal court ^[6].

What followed stunned the nation. Days after the murders, relatives of the victims stood up in court and, through their grief, spoke words of forgiveness to the man who had killed their loved ones ^[6]. Their witness to the grace of Jesus Christ became one of the most powerful testimonies of the past generation, and it is a big part of why Mother Emanuel's story is told far beyond South Carolina.

For some families, coming back has taken years. The Associated Press, in a report published by The Washington Times, told of a granddaughter of the Rev. Daniel Simmons who needed years to find the strength to walk into the church basement where her grandfather attended his final Bible study ^[2].

A Courtyard Built for Fellowship

The memorial was designed by Michael Arad, the architect behind the National September 11 Memorial in New York ^[4][5]. At its center is a fountain, the Fountain of Grace, with the names of the Emanuel Nine set around its edge ^[3]. The courtyard is framed by two long fellowship benches that face each other, an image of the circle of believers who gathered that night with Bibles open ^[5].

The plans were first unveiled in 2018, during the church's 200th anniversary, and construction broke ground in 2023 ^[5]. The Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation had raised and pledged about $19.9 million toward a $25 million campaign before Saturday's opening, ABC News 4 in Charleston reported ^[5].

Charleston Mayor William Cogswell said that from this day forward the memorial will be part of the fabric of the city ^[3]. Deona Smith, executive director of the Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation, described the opening as the fruit of more than a decade of determination and perseverance ^[3][4].

Related A Cathedral Rises in Baghdad: Iraq Opens Its First Coptic Church and Asks the Christians It Lost to Come Home

Remembering Without Bitterness

The church's pastor, the Rev. Eric Manning, has described the work of remembrance as acknowledging the hatred behind the attack while walking a path toward reconciliation, NPR reported during last year's 10th anniversary observances ^[6]. That is a fitting charge for a nation that still struggles to talk honestly about race and still sees houses of worship targeted by violent men.

The lesson of Mother Emanuel is not that evil wins. It is that a congregation can bury its dead, open its doors again the following Sunday and answer hate with prayer. The church never stopped worshipping. The memorial now gives every visitor, of every background, a place to sit on those benches, read the names and consider what that kind of faith costs and what it gives.

What Comes Next

The courtyard is the first phase of the project. A Survivors' Garden honoring the five people who lived through the shooting is planned next ^[4][5]. For now, the fountain is running, the names are in stone and the gates are open on Calhoun Street, steps from the sanctuary where nine believers spent their last hour studying the Word together.