This morning on The Hart of the Economy with Evelyn Hart
Degree in Hand, Job Out of Reach: Half of the Class of 2025 Is Underemployed as the Entry-Level Door Narrows
A new Indeed report finds 50.4% of last year's graduates working jobs that don't need a degree, while senior postings climb and beginner roles shrink. Here is what families should take from the numbers.
Filed November 22, 2026 · 📍 NY 12207
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Indeed says 50.4% of 2025 graduates held non-degree jobs a year out, up from just under 40% for most of the past decade
- Senior-level postings rose 19.2% since January 2025 while entry- and mid-level postings fell about 4%
- The New York Fed's gauge shows recent-grad unemployment easing to 5.2% but underemployment rising to 42.5%
- Field of study, work experience and practical paths like the trades matter more than ever
A college diploma used to be the surest ticket into a professional career. For a growing share of young Americans, it is now a ticket into the same jobs they could have landed without one. About half of last year's graduates were working in jobs that do not typically require a degree a year after they left campus, according to a new report from Indeed's Hiring Lab [1].
The figure, 50.4% for the class of 2025, is a sharp break from the past. Indeed says the share of graduates it counts as underemployed hovered just under 40% for most of the last decade before climbing to its new high [1]. Forbes highlighted the finding this week, and Business Insider reported that many new graduates are settling for work that never needed the degree they paid for [3][4].
For families who have sacrificed to put a son or daughter through school, this is not an abstract labor-market statistic. It is the question being asked around a lot of Thanksgiving tables this week: did the investment pay off, and what should the younger brothers and sisters do next?
What the 50.4% Number Measures
It helps to be precise about what Indeed counted. The company drew its graduates from job seekers on its platform who have updated their profiles since 2022, then looked at the job each one held 12 months after graduation. If that job is one that does not typically require a bachelor's degree, the graduate is counted as underemployed [2].
Indeed itself cautions readers to focus on the change rather than the exact level. Its methodology notes that the level depends on where the thresholds are drawn, so the company measures the trend against a 2017-2019 baseline [2]. That caution matters, and it is why the more important story is not the precise number but the direction: by Indeed's yardstick, things have gotten noticeably worse for the newest graduates.
The government-adjacent gauge most economists watch tells a similar, if less dramatic, story. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York tracks graduates ages 22 to 27 and smooths its figures with a three-month moving average [5]. In its latest update, the New York Fed's measure of underemployment ticked up to 42.5%, even as the unemployment rate for recent graduates eased to 5.2%, its lowest reading in more than a year [6]. Earlier in 2026, the bank's figures showed unemployment for this group near 5.7% in the first quarter and 5.6% in the second, with underemployment around 41.5% and 42% [5].
Put the two measures side by side and the picture is consistent. Most graduates are finding work. A rising share are finding work that does not use the education they financed.
The Entry-Level Door Is Getting Narrower
The deeper problem Indeed describes is not a shortage of jobs. It is a shortage of first jobs.
Employers have been posting more openings for experienced hands and fewer for beginners. Since January 2025, Indeed says, postings for senior-level roles rose 19.2%, while entry-level and mid-level postings each fell about 4% [1]. Entry-level jobs also shrank as a share of everything posted, from about 49% in late 2023 to a low near 44.7% in mid-2026, before ending the period at 45.3% [1]. In September 2026, the entry-level share was almost four percentage points below where it stood in September 2023 [1].
That is the trap captured in the title of Indeed's chapter, which asks where young people are supposed to get the experience employers now demand [1]. A company that wants three years on a resume is not hiring the graduate who has none. When enough companies make that choice at once, the bottom rung of the ladder gets crowded, and graduates spill into retail, hospitality and other work that does not ask for a degree.
There is one hopeful note in the same data. Glassdoor reviews show workers with zero to two years of experience rated their career opportunities 3.41 out of 5 through mid-September, higher than more experienced employees, and their ratings have fallen less since 2022 [1]. Young workers who do get a foot in the door, in other words, still see a path upward.
Not Every Major Faces the Same Market
The pain is not spread evenly. The New York Fed's breakdown of recent graduates by field of study, based on 2024 Census data, found anthropology majors with the highest unemployment rate at 7.9%, followed closely by computer engineering at 7.8%, with computer science ranking fifth among 73 majors [5].
That ranking surprises many parents who were told a decade ago that coding was the safe bet. But the same data carry an important qualifier. Computer science and computer engineering graduates who do find work are far less likely to be underemployed, with rates below 20%, compared with an average of about 42% across all recent graduates [5]. The technical fields are harder to break into right now, but they still lead to degree-level work once a graduate gets hired.
The New York Fed's tracker also shows that recent graduates have been facing a higher jobless rate than the workforce as a whole, a reversal of the long-standing pattern in which a degree meant lower unemployment from the start [5].
What It Means for Families
None of this means college is a mistake. The degree still opens doors that stay shut to many workers without one, and for careers like medicine, engineering, teaching and law, it is the only door. But the numbers argue for a more sober, more practical approach than the one many families were sold.
First, the choice of field matters more than the name on the diploma. A student who borrows heavily for a degree with a crowded job market is taking a real financial risk, and parents have every right to ask that question plainly before the first tuition bill arrives.
Second, experience now counts as much as credentials. If employers want resumes with work history on them, the students who show up at graduation with internships, summer jobs, apprenticeships, military service or a record of real responsibility will stand apart. A young person who has worked hard at an ordinary job has learned something a transcript cannot show.
Third, the four-year campus is not the only honorable path. Skilled trades, certificate programs and on-the-job training lead to good, steady work, and the dignity of that work is something our grandparents never doubted. The Bible's counsel that whatever we do, we should work at it with all our heart, as for the Lord, applies to the electrician and the welder as surely as to the accountant.
What to Watch Next
The New York Fed updates its recent-graduate figures on a regular schedule, and the next releases will show whether the easing in unemployment holds while underemployment keeps creeping up [5][6]. Indeed's report is part of its outlook for 2027, so the company will be measuring the class of 2026 against the same baseline a year from now [2].
The key signal for this spring's graduates will be the entry-level share of job postings. If it keeps sliding, the squeeze Indeed describes will deepen [1]. If employers start reopening beginner roles, the class of 2026 may find the bottom rung less crowded than the class before it.
Either way, the message for students and parents is the same: plan early, choose carefully, work hard, and do not count on a diploma alone to do the job.
Sources
- [1]Indeed Hiring LabExperience Wanted. But Where Do You Get It?Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Indeed Hiring LabIndeed & Glassdoor's 2027 U.S. Hiring and Worklife Trends Report: Consolidated MethodologyOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Federal Reserve Bank of New YorkThe Labor Market for Recent College GraduatesOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Finger Lakes 1College graduate unemployment eases but many still work in jobs that don't require degreesOpens in a new tab ↗
Should towns welcome AI data centers?
- Yes, they bring jobs and tax money
- Only if they pay their own power costs
- No, they strain water and the grid
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.