This morning on Power Play with Connor Maguire
Nineteen and Already in the Record Book: Matthew Schaefer's First Hat Trick Powers the Islanders Past Columbus, 5-1
The teenage defenseman becomes the first Islanders blueliner with three goals in a game since Denis Potvin in 1982, as Mathew Barzal sets up two in his home return and Casey Cizikas closes in on 1,000 games.
Filed November 18, 2026 · 📍 Long Island, NY 11501
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Matthew Schaefer, 19, scored three goals, the last into an empty net, in a 5-1 win over Columbus at UBS Arena.
- He is the first Islanders defenseman with a hat trick since Denis Potvin on March 4, 1982.
- Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves as New York won its third straight game after a four-game skid.
- Casey Cizikas played his 998th career game and is lined up to reach 1,000 on Saturday in Detroit.
Matthew Schaefer is 19 years old, and on Tuesday night at UBS Arena he did something no Islanders defenseman had done in more than four decades. The rookie blueliner scored three times, the last into an empty net with 3:52 to play, as New York beat the Columbus Blue Jackets, 5-1 [1][2].
It was the first NHL hat trick of his young career, and it put him in rare company. The Associated Press reported that Schaefer is the second-youngest defenseman in league history to score three goals in a game, and the first Islanders defenseman to do it since Hall of Famer Denis Potvin on March 4, 1982 [2]. Daily Faceoff noted that he is only the third teenage defenseman ever to record a hat trick in the NHL [3].
How the Night Unfolded
Schaefer was everywhere. He finished with three goals on nine shots and logged 23 minutes, 23 seconds of ice time, according to the AP [2]. The Islanders carried a 2-0 lead into the third period before Zach Werenski, Columbus' top defenseman, slipped past Ryan Pulock and scored 1:12 into the period to make it 2-1 [2].
That was as close as the Blue Jackets would get. New York pulled away in the third, with Anthony DeAngelo also finding the net, according to Field Level Media [1]. With Columbus goaltender Cam Talbot pulled for an extra attacker late in the game, Simon Holmstrom set up Schaefer, who finished the hat trick into the open net [2]. At the other end, Ilya Sorokin stopped 28 shots and came within a period of a shutout [2].
The win was New York's third in a row, a welcome turn after a four-game losing streak earlier this month [1].
Barzal's Return and a Veteran's Milestone
Schaefer was not the only feel-good story on Long Island. Mathew Barzal picked up two assists in his first home game since returning from injury, the New York Post reported [4]. The Post noted that Barzal is only months removed from wondering whether his career might be cut short [4], which made a two-point night in front of the home crowd all the sweeter.
Then there is Casey Cizikas, the kind of player every winning locker room needs. Tuesday was the 998th regular-season game of his career, the Post reported [5]. Looking back on the long road that brought him to this point, the veteran center told the paper it "hasn't been easy" [5]. According to Daily Faceoff's weekly rundown, Cizikas is lined up to play his 1,000th game Saturday night in Detroit, which would make him just the fourth player to reach 1,000 games for the franchise [6].
Connor's Take
There is a lesson in having Schaefer and Cizikas on the same roster. One is a teenager just beginning to write his name into the record book. The other is a grinder who has spent his entire career with one club, doing the hard, unglamorous work that rarely makes the highlight shows. In an era when players change teams as often as they change sticks, a thousand games in one sweater is a testament to loyalty, consistency and a work ethic that never shows up on the scoresheet.
Schaefer, meanwhile, plays with a poise that belies his age. Defensemen are not supposed to jump into the rush, fire nine shots and score three goals in the same night, let alone at 19. Islanders fans who remember the Potvin years know what an elite two-way defenseman can mean to a franchise, and the comparisons will only grow louder if nights like this keep coming.
What matters most right now is the standings. Three straight wins have steadied a team that looked shaky earlier this month, and a healthy Barzal gives the lineup back one of its most dangerous playmakers. If Sorokin keeps stopping pucks like this and the kid on the blue line keeps growing, the Islanders have the makings of a club that can stay in the playoff hunt deep into the winter.
What Comes Next
The countdown to Cizikas' milestone is on. If he stays in the lineup, the Islanders' next game will be his 999th, with No. 1,000 set for Saturday's visit to the Red Wings [6]. For a franchise that has always prized grit, there could hardly be a better week to celebrate one of its own.
Sources
- [1]Field Level MediaMatthew Schaefer's hat trick lifts Islanders over Blue JacketsOpens in a new tab ↗
- [2]NBC4 Columbus (Associated Press)Defenseman Matthew Schaefer records 1st NHL hat trick as Islanders beat Columbus 5-1Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
Should athletes keep politics out of the game?
- Yes, just play
- They can speak off the field
- They have every right to speak out
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.