Markets
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Updated 6:54 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Sports

Last night on Saturday Nation with Wade McAllister

Let the Tape Decide: UCLA's Bob Chesney Disputes Bret Bielema's Broken-Nose Claim as the Big Ten Reviews the Play

Illinois says quarterback Katin Houser was hurt coming out of a pile in Pasadena. UCLA's coach says the film will show nothing of the kind, as the unbeaten Bruins turn to Michigan.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic night scene of a rain-soaked college football field inside a historic bowl-shaped stadium at the foot of dark mountains, floodlights cutting through drifting rain and mist, a lone brown leather…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Part of our continuing coverage: Ten and Oh in the Rain: Dieffenbach Returns From a Shoulder Scare and Scooter Jackson's Two Picks Keep No. 4 UCLA Perfect, 22-14

Key points

  • Bob Chesney says the film won't show the 'purposeful kick' Illinois described
  • Katin Houser had nose surgery Monday after a broken nose and concussion; the Big Ten is reviewing the play
  • Sophomore Carson Boyd may make his first start against Iowa
  • The Rose Bowl is opening its north-side seats for UCLA's Nov. 28 game with USC

UCLA's perfect season now comes with a side dispute that only the Big Ten office can settle. On Tuesday, Bruins coach Bob Chesney pushed back on Illinois coach Bret Bielema's suggestion that quarterback Katin Houser's broken nose came from something that happened after the whistle in Friday night's 22-14 UCLA win, saying the game film would not show anything like what Illinois described, the New York Post reported [1].

Houser left on Illinois' final drive in Pasadena with a broken nose and a concussion, and he had surgery on the nose Monday morning [1][4]. Bielema has sent the play to the conference office for review [1][2].

Two Coaches, Two Accounts

Bielema's account is narrow and specific. According to the Post, he said Houser went into the play with an unbroken nose and no concussion, that nothing happened during the tackle itself, and that the damage came as players were coming out of the pile [1]. He said he saw something on the play and turned it in to the league, which now has the review [1].

Chesney's answer on Tuesday was just as direct. He described Illinois' claim as an accusation of "a purposeful kick to the kid's nose," and said the film would not back it up [1]. He acknowledged that he had heard from the Big Ten about the play, but the Post reported he suggested there was not much to discuss [1]. The Post also noted that replays shown on the Fox broadcast did not appear to show any intentional contact after the play [1].

Neither coach has asked for anything more than a fair look at the tape, and that is how it should be. Suggesting that a college player deliberately hurt an opponent is serious business. So is a young quarterback leaving the field with a broken nose and a concussion. The right place to sort it out is a league office with every camera angle, not a Tuesday press conference. Until the Big Ten speaks, this desk will not name or blame any UCLA player, because no one has shown that anyone did anything wrong.

Illinois Turns to Its Third Quarterback

Whatever the review finds, Illinois has a more pressing problem. Houser's status for Saturday's game against Iowa is in doubt, 247Sports reported, because he has to recover from surgery and clear the concussion protocol in a short week [3]. Bielema has not ruled him out [3].

If Houser cannot go, sophomore Carson Boyd is in line to make his first career start, which would make him the Illini's third starting quarterback of the season, ESPN reported [2]. The News-Gazette in Champaign wrote that the surgery likely means a quarterback change [4].

The depth chart offers little cushion. Backup Michael Clayton II is out with a hand injury, and receiver Hudson Clement is done for the season with a shoulder injury, according to 247Sports [3]. That is a lot of turnover for any offense in the middle of November, and it puts a heavy load on a young quarterback who has yet to start a college game.

UCLA's Road Runs Through Ann Arbor

For UCLA, the real business this week is Michigan. The Bruins head to the Big House on Saturday, and the New York Post asked whether one of the sport's biggest crowds will bring the noise for the visit [6].

Back home, the excitement is building for the regular-season finale. The Rose Bowl will open more seating for UCLA's Nov. 28 game against USC, removing all of the tarps on the stadium's north side, a UCLA spokesperson confirmed to the Post [5]. The Post called it a rare move, driven by the surge of interest in the unbeaten Bruins [5].

That is the kind of problem Chesney is glad to have. Every one of those extra seats will be filled by someone who wants to see whether this perfect run can last two more weeks.

Wade's Take

Football is a violent game, and it is played by young men who deserve protection. Bielema did what a coach is supposed to do when he believes one of his players was wronged: he sent the play to the league through the proper channel. Chesney did what a coach is supposed to do when his players are accused: he stood up for them and pointed to the film.

The wise course now belongs to everyone else. Scripture tells us to be quick to listen and slow to speak, and that is good advice for fans and commentators who have already made up their minds about a play the league has not finished reviewing. Let the tape decide.

In the meantime, the best thing anyone can do for Katin Houser is pray for a full recovery, whether he plays Saturday or not. The rest will be settled in the Big Ten office, and on the field: against Iowa, in Ann Arbor and, on Nov. 28, in a fuller Rose Bowl.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Should athletes keep politics out of the game?

  1. Yes, just play
  2. They can speak off the field
  3. They have every right to speak out
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.